CINCINNATI — The Pirates opened their three-game weekend series at Great American Ball Park with a 5-3 loss to the Reds on Friday evening. Brady Singer was the winning pitcher, improving to 3-0, while Bailey Falter suffered the loss, dropping to 0-2. Emilio Pagan closed the game out with a perfect frame in the ninth inning, earning his third save of the season.

Both clubs tallied four hits throughout the contest. Reds third baseman Jeimer Candelario had the biggest knock of the game, tagging Falter for a two-run homer in the bottom of the first inning, putting Cincinnati ahead for good. Adam Frazier’s two-run homer in the top of the fifth made the game interesting, but Derek Shelton’s club was unable to generate any additional offense for the rest of the evening.

A full recap on Friday night’s game can be read here. Below are the Post-Gazette’s three takeaways from the contest.

Costly free passes

Normally well in command of the strike zone, Falter’s inability to locate his pitches created a great deal of trouble from the very start. Falter walked the first three batters he faced Friday, putting himself in an early jam. The first walk came across on a double-play ball hit by Spencer Steer, while the second walk scored as a part of Candelario’s homer.

Advertise with us

"I would guess it was the cold,” Shelton said. “You saw Singer's the same way. It was uncharacteristic from both guys, just big misses. Brady walked three, had a lot of deep counts. When I went out the one inning to make a pitching change, the balls felt like cue balls. It's cold, it's tough and it looked like he just had a little trouble with his command. I thought he settled down nice. Obviously we made the error, but he settled down and was able to get us through five."

While Falter would settle in a bit in the later innings, he went on to issue a pair of additional free passes before his night came to an end, giving him a career-high five walks in the loss. His issue was especially prevalent with the fastball, struggling to locate his most frequently used pitch in a few locations, most notably at the top of the zone.

“No excuse,” Falter said. “Five walks, just can't happen. I think probably a career-high for me, which is unfortunate. Just had no feel in the first inning, honestly.”

After avoiding any free passes in his first start, Falter has now awarded the opposition eight free bases — six walks, two hit batters — in his last two outings. Six of those eight batters to reach via walk or hit by pitch have come around to score.

Backstop blues

Although Falter’s location issues were what put the Pirates in an early hole, the defensive play behind the plate only made things worse. Joey Bart, the Pirates’ starting catcher Friday evening, exited after the first inning due to lower back discomfort.

Advertise with us

Endy Rodriguez replaced Bart for the remainder of the game, where his early-season defensive struggles continued. Entering Friday’s contest, Rodriguez’s defensive metrics were already unfavorable, being responsible for -3 defensive runs saved and boasting a -2 fielded run value, per Fangraphs.

"I think right now, a little bit of it is we're seeing he's missed a little bit of a year,” Shelton said. “He's also really athletic and trying to do some things. It's just slowing him back down. I would rather slow him back down than push him forward. We just have to make sure we continue to talk about these things with him."

In the bottom of the third inning, Rodriguez added to those undesirable totals, committing his second error of the season behind the plate and fourth overall (the other two occurring as a first baseman), on a questionable throw to third base, as a pair of runners were trying to advance 90-feet.

The play started with Falter bouncing a ball in the dirt, which Rodriguez successfully blocked. Rodriguez, noticing Elly De La Cruz — the runner on second — was breaking for third, decided to snap a quick throw to the bag. The throw, however, was impeded by his catcher’s mask, disrupting his arm path and causing the ball to sail past Ke’Bryan Hayes at the bag, and into the outfield.

“I couldn't stop my arm because it was in full motion,” Rodriguez said. “As we know, it's more dangerous to try to stop the arm, rather than just letting it go. So, I just tried to get it to a position where Ke' could handle it, but I couldn't do that."

Advertise with us

De La Cruz and Steer both came around to score on the error, making the game 5-0. Those two runs ultimately made the biggest difference in the contest, with the first serving as the game-winner.

After missing nearly all of last season due to elbow surgery, Rodriguez, as noted above, has made a series of mistakes in the field. But despite the early rough going, the young backstop has found a way to maintain his positive mindset.

"It comes from [the fact] that I gave my 100% today,” Rodriguez said. “I did all that I could do to help the team. We all came here from our gifts. That's all we got."

No offensive threats

Fresh off a performance that featured only five hits — all of them singles — in a 13-inning contest, the Pirates’ bats were once again silent, mustering only four base-knocks in their loss Friday evening. Consistent offense has been the biggest issue for the Pirates in their first 13 games. The club currently boasts no hitters with a batting average over .300 and only two — Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Bart — that are hitting over .250.

The Pirates’ starting lineup for Friday’s game received pointed criticism from fans on social media, with many asking how the team could have such a limited number of proven threats at the plate six years into a regime. And while slow starts for their proven talents such as Bryan Reynolds, along with newcomer veterans such as Frazier and Tommy Pham, have played a part in this, another, and perhaps bigger factor is the team’s overall lack of depth.

Advertise with us

Spencer Horwitz, who was acquired this offseason to be the team’s everyday first baseman, remains on the injured list, as does starting second baseman Nick Gonzales. Bryan Reynolds, who is dealing with a shoulder issue, is only limited to playing designated hitter, forcing Andrew McCutchen to play right field, a position the team seems to be uncomfortable with him playing back to back days.

For the second-straight game, Oneil Cruz was unavailable due to a finger injury that was sustained when he was hit by a pitch Tuesday. And as if those issues weren’t enough, the Pirates lost Bart, a regular in the middle third of the order, after the first frame. What remained was simply no match for a Reds pitching staff that entered the game with the fourth best ERA in MLB. And Shelton didn’t pretend to deny said notion.

"It's challenging right now,” Shelton said. “We've just got to get back to full strength. We've got to keep going and keep grinding through it, but we've got to get back to full strength. Right now, we're just not there."