MIAMI — The Pirates fell to the Marlins by a final score of 3-2 Sunday afternoon at loanDepot park. Anthony Bender was the winning pitcher, while David Bednar suffered the loss. Here are the Post-Gazette’s three takeaways from the contest.
Holderman, Bednar continue to struggle
After watching the duo of Colin Holderman and David Bednar fail to close out the most important games of last season, Pirate fans have witnessed both struggle early on in 2025.
After blowing a two-run lead on opening day, and nearly allowing the game-winning run Saturday, Holderman struggled again Sunday, allowing a two-out solo homer to Griffin Conine that tied the game at two in the bottom of the seventh inning. The longball handed Holderman his second blown save in three outings.
"Lack of execution,” Derek Shelton said when asked what the issue has been with the right-hander. “Him trying to go one place in the zone and didn't get it there."
Caleb Ferguson followed Holderman, throwing a scoreless eighth inning. But in the ninth, Bednar was called upon and quickly suffered his second loss of the season.
Similar to opening day, poor fielding didn’t help Bednar’s case. Derek Hill opened the frame with an infield single and then quickly advanced two extra bases after stealing second and moving over to third on an errant throw from Endy Rodriguez.
Read More
With the go-ahead run 90-feet away and no one out, Bednar had no room for any further mistakes. But in that same at-bat, a mistake occurred, as the right-hander bounced a 2-1 split-finger in the dirt that turned into a wild pitch, allowing Hill to score with no throw.
Despite getting four solid starts from the rotation, the Pirates leave Miami with only one win due to their inability to maintain leads late in games. Per the Elias Sports Bureau, Shelton’s squad is the first MLB team to be walked off for their first three losses in a season since the 1924 Pirates. Holderman and Bednar played a part in two of those three losses, with the other occurring in extra-innings.
While Shelton has remained loyal to both Holderman and Bednar, it’s worth questioning how long he can continue to pitch both in high-leverage spots moving forward. Neither are displaying reliable command within the strike zone, while other relievers such as Ferguson, Dennis Santana and Ryan Borucki all not only had better springs, but looked sharper in their respective outings in Miami.
Bats MIA
Although the poor fielding and bullpen meltdowns stand out most, it’s worth noting that the Pirates scored only 14 runs in 39 innings of baseball against a team that lost 100 games last season. For the third time in four games, the Marlins out-hit the Pirates, despite Pittsburgh’s starters allowing two-earned runs or less in each of those three contests.
“Offensively, we've got some work to do still,” Shelton said. “We've got some guys who are trying to find their footing in the early going, and that's a challenging thing early on. Guys get a couple of 0-fers, and then they press a little bit. We just need some balls to fall.”
After going 3-for-18 with runners in scoring position Saturday, Pittsburgh went just 1-for-5 in such situations Sunday. The Marlins bullpen continued its string of success against the Pirates in the series finale, throwing a combined 3 ⅓ scoreless innings of relief to set up another comeback win. In total, the Pirates scored just five runs, four earned, in 18 ⅓ innings against Miami relievers.
Plenty to work on
All preseason, Shelton and his team spoke about the importance of winning close games. “Winning on the margins,” was the phrase frequently used by the Pirates manager, while his players identified the club as a group of “grinders” who aimed to beat teams by playing better fundamental baseball.
But the exact opposite has been the reality for the Pirates so far in 2025.
"Tough series,” Shelton said after Sunday’s loss. “We have some things that we really need to correct. … It's challenging. We've got some things to work on."
From bad fielding, to mistakes on the bases, to poor execution on the mound, the Pirates have managed to lose three games in which they were ahead entering the bottom of the seventh inning. Morale was understandably low within the Pirates clubhouse after each of the three losses. A mix of frustration and discouragement can be felt while walking from locker to locker.
Veteran leaders seem to be the ones especially bothered by the ugly start, but that same group has notably been the ones to compose their emotions and keep looking ahead.
“I think these losses that we’ve had, it seems like the game is speeding up on us,” Andrew McCutchen said. “So, obviously you have some mental mishaps and that happens in the game. It’s just unfortunate that they are happening and you go to those moments and you go, ‘That’s why you lost.’ I don’t necessarily think that’s why. It plays a part in it, but you just have to learn from those and address it now, so it’s not happening for the course of the season.”
McCutchen continued on, stating that the only way the Pirates find their way out of this early funk, is to work harder.
“You can do this (talking hand gesture) all you want, you can say little things all you want, but if you’re not working on it, you’re not going to do it,” McCutchen said. “It’s going to become a little tougher and a challenge for you to execute when you have to. So, it’s understanding who you are individually as a player, knowing what your role is and executing. It’s plain and simple.
“If you’re a guy that has speed and you’re at the top of the order and you bunt, bunt. If you need to get that runner over from second to third, get that runner over from second to third and get that run in from third. Offensively, doing that, it’s defensively doing the same thing. From a pitching standpoint, doing what they do, it’s doing all that because obviously, and I said it before, it’s what we have to do. It’s what we have to do to win, we have to be mentally sound and we have to execute and that’s plain and simple.”
Prior to McCutchen’s words of wisdom, Sunday’s starting pitcher Andrew Heaney offered his own guidance to the club, in a more short-winded but pointed way.
“[Expletive] it, it's early,” Heaney said. “You've just got to keep playing."
Perhaps a combination of those two perspectives is the only way this group of players can recover from a dreadful opening series, with an even tougher road ahead.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.