BRADENTON, Fla. — Not long after Nick Gonzales finishes his daily pregame work at second base, the former first-round pick regularly makes time to field ground balls on the other side of the bag.

Unlike last year, Gonzales is no longer fighting to make the Pirates opening day roster. A strong campaign in 2024 established him as the club’s everyday second baseman.

With a spot secured, some might ponder why Gonzales continually allocates part of his schedule to fielding grounders at shortstop. The answer pertains less to the position itself and more toward the player who holds that starting job: Isiah Kiner-Falefa.

“I try to take ground balls at short with him just so I can learn as much as I can about his views and philosophies on certain things,” Gonzales told the Post-Gazette. “He’s also just a great leader. He’s very outspoken on certain things that he feels we need to do.”

Advertise with us

Acquired in the final hours before last year’s trade deadline, Kiner-Falefa stands out on the Pirates roster for a handful of reasons. Among the projected infield starters, he is the elder statesman, boasting seven years of big-league experience. He has played in large markets and on some of the game’s greatest stages.

Depending on the year and ballcap, Kiner-Falefa has filled a multitude of roles, having started at seven different positions and batted in all nine spots of the order. This season, he will play the most important spot in the Pirates infield — an opportunity he very much looks forward to.

“I think what makes me valuable to teams is my ability to play everywhere,” Kiner-Falefa said. “Right now, the Pirates need a shortstop.”

Kiner-Falefa has been a full-time shortstop in two prior seasons throughout his career. The first go took place in 2021 during his final season with the Texas Rangers. The second came in the year after, with the New York Yankees.

That 2022 campaign served as a monumental year of Kiner-Falefa’s baseball journey — one filled with challenges and failures but ultimately plenty of lessons that led to growth on and off the field. Now three seasons removed from his battle in the Bronx, the 29-year-old is ready to attack the challenge again with an enhanced skill set and fresh perspective.

Advertise with us

Chasing ‘Superman’

A lifelong Yankees fan, Kiner-Falefa still boasts a smile when reflecting upon his first trip to the Bronx.

“It was either 2005 or 2006,” Kiner-Falefa recalled. “My travel baseball team was the first ever Hawaiian team to win a tournament in Cooperstown. After the tournament, my dad and I went to watch the Yankees for five games. It was awesome. It still gives me goosebumps.”

Kiner-Falefa remembers joining in with fans from the left field bleachers during the traditional “roll call” that occurs in the first inning. He remembers the excitement he felt getting to watch his favorite player, Derek Jeter, play shortstop for the game’s most iconic franchise. Little did he know, one day he would be playing the same position for the same club.

On March 12, 2022, the Rangers traded Kiner-Falefa and Ronny Henriquez to the Twins for Mitch Garver. One day later, the Twins flipped Kiner-Falefa, along with Josh Donaldson and Ben Rortvedt, to the Yankees for Gary Sanchez and Gio Urshela.

While at first disappointed to leave the place where his career began, Kiner-Falefa was elated to see where the two-day whirlwind brought him.

Advertise with us

“It was surreal to learn that I was not only going to play for them but that I would be playing shortstop,” Kiner-Falefa said. “I think that was the coolest thing.”

Unfortunately for Kiner-Falefa, Yankees fans did not share the same excitement for his arrival. That offseason, premier shortstops such as Corey Seager and Carlos Correa both hit the free agent market. Both would end up replacing Kiner-Falefa — the former signed with the Rangers in November, while the latter signed with the Twins on March 18, five days after Kiner-Falefa was traded to New York.

“I think the Yankees fans were set on having one of those guys,” Kiner-Falefa said. “But instead, they traded for me. And then, for them to see the Twins sign Correa right after because they traded me, I think there was a lot of pressure on me after that. I guess I wasn’t the guy that they wanted, and that was tough for me.”

Kiner-Falefa quickly learned the bright lights of New York City come with demanding standards. The player he grew up idolizing set a high bar of excellence for all Yankees shortstops moving forward. And while Kiner-Falefa felt his game was in a good spot, it was hard to ignore the instant pressure.

“I didn’t realize who they really wanted,” Kiner-Falefa said. “I was a homegrown Ranger, someone who I’d say at the time was a fan favorite. I went from being loved in one organization to New York, where I immediately felt pressure to perform at a level that I wasn’t sure I could reach. I didn’t know if I could hit 20 home runs or bat .300.”

Advertise with us

Although for his own standards, Kiner-Falefa delivered an adequate showing — 1.5 wins above replacement (WAR), per FanGraphs, and 10 defensive runs saved — he was unable to match the likes of that elite duo. Game by game, fans grew more frustrated at his performance, which led to frequent criticism both at the ballpark and on social media.

“It was really tough,” Kiner-Falefa said. “I got in my own head. At that time, I was someone who was very vocal on Twitter. When I was with the Rangers, I would watch Jomboy videos, watch all the fan stuff. But then it started to turn into ‘We hate IKF.’

“When I saw that, I tried so hard to flip the narrative. I wasn’t focusing on what was important to me. I wasn’t focusing on what I had to do to get ready for the game. I was just trying to be Superman and I think I was getting worse and worse and worse as the season progressed with that mentality.”

A clear mind

Kiner-Falefa’s 2022 season ended with him being benched in the playoffs. That following spring, he lost his starting job to rookie Anthony Volpe.

For some players, that series of events would serve as a reason to seek a different opportunity or, at the very least, feel discouraged. Kiner-Falefa, however, took a different approach. Humbled throughout his first year in New York, he took it upon himself to improve.

Advertise with us

“I knew what I had to work on,” Kiner-Falefa said. “The fans let me know, and I worked on it all offseason.”

That process began when Kiner-Falefa started working with Johan Martinez-Khalilian, a mental performance coach. Rather than comparing his statistics to others at his position, Kiner-Falefa learned to focus on maximizing the best of his own abilities.

Kiner-Falefa discovered that regardless of his position, he can still be an asset to his team. Rather than turning a cold shoulder to Volpe, he instead took the rookie under his wing, something the Yankees shortstop said made a notable impact in his young career.

“He helped me with everything, with baseball and life,” Volpe told the Post-Gazette. “He had the locker next to mine. He shared some of the best, funniest stories. He was always there for me. He was kinda like a big brother for me my rookie season. It meant the world to me. He’s an amazing player, but what people didn’t see is that he went out of his way every chance he got for me and the rest of the guys on the team to help us.”

Relegated to a utility role in 2023, Kiner-Falefa made the most of his extra downtime.

Advertise with us

He became an even more versatile defender, learning how to play each of the three outfield positions. He improved his throwing arm, going from a player fans once deemed “noodle arm” to someone whose top relays reached as high as 92 mph. He cleaned up minor infield mechanical flaws, eliminating a “tap” he would routinely do in his glove before delivering a throw. And throughout the process, he also learned how to ignore the outside noise.

Kiner-Falefa’s willingness to roll with the punches eventually won over a portion of the Yankees fans that once regularly booed him. They, too, saw the value he provided. Although statistically, he had produced better years, he credits that 2023 season as a major turning point in his career.

“It sped up the process of, ‘What you do off the field translates to what you do on the field,’ ” Kiner-Falefa said. “How you live your life off the field, if you’re creating bad habits off the field, you’ll get bad habits on the field. For me, in 2022, I was into social media. I got caught up in all of that. Being able to put that away and look at myself in the mirror every day over the past two years was refreshing.

“I was able to fall back on my feet and be a good player again.”

Another chance

After leaving the Yankees at the end of 2023, Kiner-Falefa knew that one day, he would get another chance to be a starter at his old position. That opportunity presented itself in late August 2024, when the Pirates moved Oneil Cruz to center field and chose Kiner-Falefa to be his replacement as the everyday shortstop.

Advertise with us

"I wouldn't say it's specifically why we acquired IKF,” manager Derek Shelton said on Aug. 26, the day the move was announced. “ ... I think once we got to the point where we acquired him and then we realized looking forward what was best for us, it was an added benefit to that."

The Pirates reaffirmed their faith in Kiner-Falefa this offseason, stating numerous times over the winter their plan was for him to remain the starting shortstop. And similar to the spring of 2022, some Pirates fans have expressed skepticism over this decision.

A sluggish showing at the plate following the trade deadline, paired with some unfavorable fielding metrics from his time in New York, has led some to question if Kiner-Falefa is capable of being a productive starter at short. But this time around, Kiner-Falefa has a new approach to his detractors.

“When I got to Pittsburgh, I feel like I could’ve played a lot better,” Kiner-Falefa said. “I felt like I didn’t play well in the second half. Who knows what that’s from? But I know I can be better. I know I can play like I did in the first half of last season for an entire year. I made some strides and have carried them over year to year. I’m excited to just go out there and attack with a clean, clear mindset.”

Despite still being relatively new to the club, Kiner-Falefa has already assumed a sizable leadership role within the clubhouse. Gonzales is far from the only Pirate to highlight Kiner-Falefa’s value to the team, with others such as Ke’Bryan Hayes, Nick Yorke and Jared Triolo expressing similar sentiments.

Advertise with us

The collective report on Kiner-Falefa is he emphasizes the little details. Knowing the Pirates roster is built differently than other clubs he has experienced success with, he arrived in Bradenton driven to create a winning culture.

“The biggest thing is that I don’t take anything for granted,” Kiner-Falefa said. “I understand every day you get the jersey on, every day you have a starting job is a great opportunity. But that opportunity can also go away in a heartbeat. It just taught me how to prepare at a different level. A level where I have to be ready every game as if it were a playoff game.”

A successful 2025 season from Kiner-Falefa would provide a sizable boost to the Pirates’ postseason chances. Should he replicate the offensive success he had prior to last year’s deadline — .292 batting average, 116 OPS+ through 83 games with Toronto — or play the Gold Glove-caliber defense he has previously provided at other positions, most of his current doubters will likely change their tune.

Whether Kiner-Falefa can maintain that high level of play for a full season as a big-league shortstop remains to be seen. His opportunity to back his words begins March 27 — on opening day.

“I know those guys will be really lucky to have him,” Volpe said. “He doesn’t need to be anything other than the person and the player that he is. He will be a huge help for that team.”