BRADENTON, Fla. — Before top prospect Bubba Chandler throws any pitch in his arsenal, he sets a clear plan in his mind: Aim right down the middle.

“Let the movement play how it is,” the 22-year-old righty said. “[If you’re] kind of getting a little too cute with it, guys aren't going to swing at it.”

Chandler believes he can hit his spots should the situation call for it. But the Pirates’ most prized farmhand is nearing the big leagues because of his stuff — a fastball that can touch the upper 90s and a scintillating slider, among other offerings. And as challenging as Chandler’s repertoire is for opposing hitters, it can be just as arduous for whichever catcher is behind the dish.

Chandler is not alone on this front. The same goes for other pitchers in the organization with elite arsenals — Paul Skenes, Jared Jones and Kyle Nicolas, to name a few.

Advertise with us

“We got power arms, and that’s kind of where the game’s going, too,” catcher Jason Delay said. “There are still guys who are hitting their spots every time, but the game’s kind of moving toward more power stuff, especially [as] you get later in the game and you get to the back half of the bullpen.”

Per TruMedia, the Pirates had the highest average spin rate from right-handed fastballs last year of any MLB team. And while that figure is certainly buoyed by the likes of Skenes and Jones, the pitching staff at large is littered with hurlers who can really huck it.

So how do the Pirates catchers intend to keep up? Easy — get their hands on some more leather.

Jordan Comadena has been a bullpen catcher for the Pirates since 2016. Promoted to full-time catching coach this offseason, he has always encouraged the team’s backstops to use the biggest gloves they’re comfortable with.

“With the stuff that guys feature now, the velo, the shapes and the velocity on offspeed pitches,” Comadena said, “and the intent with which they’re looking to receive, moving the ball and how we catch — the biggest glove you can find is going to provide you some room for error.”

Advertise with us

Comadena said at the minimum, catchers should be using mitts with a 34-inch circumference. Delay’s model is that size, as is Endy Rodriguez’s.

Henry Davis, meanwhile, switched to a 35-inch model in 2023 after using a 33-inch glove throughout college and his first two years of pro ball. And Joey Bart currently has the biggest glove among the bunch, one that’s a whopping 36 inches in circumference — just like the mitts the Reds’ Jose Trevino and Angels’ Travis’ d’Arnaud have started stuffing their left hands into over the last few years.

“Everybody’s using big gloves,” Comadena said. “And companies, I think, are realizing that and they’re starting to make more models that lend to the bigger size. I mean, it used to be hard to find a 35-inch or bigger.”

Gloves as large as the ones some of the Pirates catchers are currently using in big-league games were once a rarity. But it’s hardly unprecedented for catchers to embrace more massive mitts to adjust to their pitching staffs.

When knuckleballer R.A. Dickey was enjoying the best years of his career with the Mets, catcher Josh Thole turned to a Rawlings women’s softball catcher’s mitt for a time to accommodate those unpredictable pitches. Some naysayers believe using larger mitts, though, can inhibit a catcher’s ability to quickly transfer the ball to his throwing hand for stolen base attempts.

Advertise with us

From his perspective, Comadena said that’s a bit of a misconception and catchers get accustomed to whatever they’re working with.

“The bigger glove, you practice with it, you train with it and you do all your stuff with it — there’s no issue with throwing, transferring balls,” Comadena said. “I think catchers around the league in general, their hands are as good as they’ve ever been.

“Catchers are as athletic and dynamic as they’ve ever been in terms of just the position in general. And so, the bigger glove, there’s no downside to it, in my opinion.”

The upsides, meanwhile, are numerous. Davis said the larger glove helps him keep errant offerings in front of him because he can use it like a paddle to more easily block wild pitches. Delay, meanwhile, said he’s aware of some research that suggests more sizable mitts are better suited for framing borderline pitches.

MLB’s automated ball-strike challenge system (ABS) has already made its debut in spring training and it could one day render pitch framing a less valued craft. But ABS has yet to be instituted for regular season play, meaning pitch framing will be as important as ever in 2025.

Advertise with us

Any little edge to steal strikes can benefit the Pirates — a team built to win from its pitching staff — tremendously. To Comadena, a larger glove can only help catchers receive pitches and present them better.

“The bigger glove, you’ve got more glove showing up over the plate when you make your move,” Comadena said. “And again, it goes back to creating room for error. Bigger pocket, bigger space to target with and to catch the ball. The larger surface area that the pitcher can see that you can have to catch the ball, you don’t have to be as perfect.”

Take it from Skenes, who was a catcher himself during his playing days at Air Force. Skenes preferred to use a bigger glove when he got in the squat partially due to his big hands but also because he liked to create as big of a target as possible. Now that he’s toeing the rubber instead of donning the tools of ignorance, Skenes likes the large target that bigger gloves offer, as well as their benefits.

“Catch the ball,” Skenes said. “Keep strikes strikes and make balls strikes.”

It’s a straightforward task in theory but one that is much more challenging than it seems. From Delay’s standpoint, it’s not terribly difficult to present the ball when a pitcher hits his spot right on the nose.

Advertise with us

Where defensive-minded catchers really make their money is on the misfires, especially ones that still land in the strike zone.

“Even if you’re set up on the inside of the plate and it’s on the complete opposite side of the plate,” Delay said, “how do you still maintain a strike?”

Precision and skill are both required.

Davis, for instance, has worked diligently to improve his defense over the last couple of years in conjunction with Comadena’s assistance. He said Comadena helped him grow as a catcher, going from “questionable” defensively to where Davis now feels he’s in a solid spot.

And it was Comadena, after all, who advised Davis to trade in his 33-inch glove for a 35-inch one when he got to the big leagues a few years back.

Advertise with us

“The quality of stuff you’re seeing, it matters a lot,” Davis said. “Especially with how aggressive modern catching technique is, you’re trying to move the ball aggressively back toward the zone.

“You need the biggest glove you can get.”