As the Pirates are set to arrive in Bradenton, Fla., on Wednesday to begin preparations for their 2025 campaign, plenty of storylines surround individuals on the roster. Derek Shelton and his staff will have six weeks to determine which 26 players best give them the opportunity to win games at the start of the regular season.
While the final answers will be revealed in late March just before opening day, let’s try to take our best guess for the road ahead. Below are a few Pirates spring training predictions from the Post-Gazette’s beat.
Biggest surprise
Destin: Mike Burrows
Perhaps it’s my being overly enamored with a singular impressive showing, but I really liked what I saw fromthe right-hander in his MLB debut at Yankee Stadium. Burrows was once as prized a pitcher in the Pirates’ organization as any, and that reality only changed because of injury and additions like Paul Skenes. Burrows does enough this spring to lock down the fifth and final spot in the Pirates’ rotation.
Hiles: Johan Oviedo
Back from Tommy John surgery, Oviedo will look better than every Pirates starting pitcher not named Paul Skenes this spring. Any debate toward Bubba Chandler making the opening day roster will be washed away with Oviedo’s dominance within the Grapefruit League. Motivated by a loss in arbitration, the right-hander will prove that he is still a more than capable big-league starter.
Read More
Biggest disappointment
Destin: Bailey Falter
Remember last spring when Falter struggled mightily and many were surprised to see the left-hander earn a spot in the starting rotation out of camp? I’m not saying it’ll be a repeat in 2025, but Falter has mostly labored in spring training as a big leaguer — he possesses a career 5.65 ERA in Grapefruit League games. Don’t be surprised if it’s another slow start for Falter that ends up being relatively meaningless.
Hiles: Endy Rodriguez
Unlike Oviedo, Rodriguez will struggle in his first action against major league talent, post-Tommy John surgery. His issues will primarily come at the plate, although questions about his throwing arm could surface as well. A shaky spring will result in the 24-year-old starting the regular season in Triple-A, where he can get everyday reps.
Best prospect
Destin: Termarr Johnson
The actual correct answer is likely to be Bubba Chandler, but let’s not forget: Johnson hit two home runs against the Blue Jays in a spring training game last year and most certainly did not look out of place. The former No. 4 overall pick is a ways from making his MLB debut, but Johnson is amply capable of putting on a show again in Bradenton.
Hiles: Bubba Chandler
While it would’ve been fun to give more of a dark horse pick, Chandler is too darn good to overlook. In recent years, Chandler has been the type of player who typically heats up a month or so into the regular season. However, it’s fair to expect him to take his game to the next level knowing that a big-league call up is in his near future.
Best non-roster invite
Destin: DJ Stewart
Stewart’s path to making the Pirates’ roster out of camp is fairly straightforward: mash against right-handed pitchers, play adequate defense, and there could be a reserve corner outfield spot waiting for him. It’s been two years since Stewart posted a .839 OPS in 59 games with the Mets, but it’s entirely possible he can channel those offensive capabilities across February and March. If he does, Stewart is a good bet to stick with the Pirates out of camp.
Hiles: Tanner Rainey
There are a handful of non-roster pitchers I’m excited to watch this spring, and Rainey is certainly in the mix. His 2024 showing was not great, but he did put together a sizable body of work in his first season back from Tommy John surgery. Should he recapture some of the velocity he had pre-surgery, he could make for a nice pickup for the Pirates’ bullpen.
Late addition (position)
Destin: Outfielder
Even with the late signing of Tommy Pham, I’m not so convinced the Pirates are done with adding to the outfield. Perhaps they are banking on one of the left-handed hitting outfielders in Jack Suwinski, Joshua Palacios and Ji Hwan Bae rising above the rest — but who’s to say the Pirates wouldn’t like to increase the competition for the fifth and final outfield spot? I’m guessing a left-handed hitting outfielder joins the fold later on in camp.
Hiles: Starting pitcher
Sure, the rotation is the most solid of any unit on the roster, but with pitching, anything can change in an instant. Should there be an injury, even something minor, or back-end starters such as Falter and Oviedo not look up to par, the Pirates could consider finding an additional depth piece in the rotation until their young arms in Triple-A are ready for the majors.
Opening day roster
Destin
Starting pitchers: Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller, Jared Jones, Bailey Falter, Mike Burrows
Bullpen: David Bednar, Carmen Mlodzinski, Colin Holderman, Kyle Nicolas, Caleb Ferguson, Dennis Santana, Tim Mayza, Johan Oviedo
Catchers: Joey Bart, Endy Rodriguez
Infielders: Spencer Horwitz, Nick Gonzales, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Ke’Bryan Hayes, Jared Triolo, Adam Frazier
Outfielders: Bryan Reynolds, Oneil Cruz, Tommy Pham, Andrew McCutchen, Ji Hwan Bae
Hiles
Starting pitchers: Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller, Jared Jones, Bailey Falter, Johan Oviedo
Bullpen: Tanner Rainey, Carmen Mlodzinski, Kyle Nicolas, Tim Mayza, Caleb Ferguson, Dennis Santana, Colin Holderman, David Bednar
Catchers: Joey Bart, Jason Delay
Infielders: Spencer Horwitz, Nick Gonzales, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Ke’Bryan Hayes, Jared Triolo, Adam Frazier
Outfielders: Bryan Reynolds, Oneil Cruz, Tommy Pham, Andrew McCutchen, Joshua Palacios





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.