At this time last year, it could be argued that the Pirates entered spring training with positivity on their side.

Coming off a 76-win campaign, 14 more than the year prior, some viewed 2024 as the year Pittsburgh’s current regime would make a true playoff push. At least some people on the outside were starting to believe. But, oh how things have changed throughout just one whole trip around the sun.

As the Pirates report to Bradenton, Fla., on Feb. 12 to begin their 2025 season, an undeniable ring of negativity surrounds the entire organization. A disappointing effort in 2024, which was defined by an epic collapse following the trade deadline, left a sour taste in the mouths of many. That feeling of displeasure continued to spread throughout the offseason, as the Pirates made only a handful of moves to address a roster that boasted its share of glaring flaws.

Some of the club’s most loyal supporters spent the winter voicing their frustration, most notably through billboards urging owner Bob Nutting to “Sell the Team,” a series of pointed questions during a highly contentious Q&A session with management during PiratesFest and by publicly mocking a survey from the team, which aimed to learn how fans felt about the organization.

Advertise with us

After six straight losing seasons — and nine straight years without a postseason appearance — fans expressed their desire for change. There seems to be a clear disbelief that the 2025 Pirates, as currently assembled, are capable of being significantly better than years past.

But despite a clear outcry for something different, those running the operation remain adamant that better results are on the near horizon.

“I believe we’re going to go into 2025 with as strong a major league roster as we’ve had since I’ve been here,” general manager Ben Cherington said in October during his end-of-season press conference. “Just as importantly, I think we’re going to go into 2025 with as strong of a baseball operation as we’ve had since I’ve been here, and we need both. Ultimately, proof’s in the pudding. Gotta go to do the work and get the results on the field. I’m excited about what’s ahead in 2025 and beyond because I do believe we’ll go into ‘25 in the strongest position we’ve been in all of those areas.”

Improve from within?

The Pirates’ offseason activity reflects Cherington’s confidence. As of the time of this writing, Pittsburgh has spent just under $15 million (14.7) in free agency.

The club is largely banking on internal improvement to be the difference maker in 2025, of which there is plenty of room for it to take place. The Pirates are returning just six players who accumulated 1.5 or more WAR last season, per both Baseball Reference and FanGraphs, and boast a farm system that ended 2024 ranked 20th out of 30 MLB teams, per MLB Pipeline.

Advertise with us

The roster’s key strength will be its starting rotation, headlined by Paul Skenes, the 2024 National League Rookie of the Year and the favorite to win the National League Cy Young this season. Other young arms such as Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler, Braxton Ashcraft, Thomas Harrington and Mike Burrows will also factor into the equation, as will veterans such as Mitch Keller, Bailey Falter and Johan Oviedo, who returns from Tommy John surgery.

While the rotation boasts potential to be one of the better units in MLB, the bullpen and starting lineup both remain filled with question marks. The Pirates offense and late-game pitching served as the two main reasons why the club squandered more than a few winnable games in 2024. With little additions to either group, the players understand that they have to be better fundamentally.

“Baseball is such a fundamentally sound game, and if you do those things right, a lot of times you put yourself in position to win the game,” designated hitter Andrew McCutchen said last month at PiratesFest. “Sometimes you’re just gonna get flat out beat and there’s nothing you can do about it. But when you get in those instances where you have a chance to win the ballgame by laying a bunt down, by getting a guy over, getting a guy in with less than two outs from third base, making the routine plays, when you do all those little things ... you have a real good opportunity to win it.”

New but familiar faces

Pittsburgh’s crop of newcomers also represents the front office holding true to its conservative methods of acquiring external talent. The Cherington regime, entering its sixth year, has still not signed an external free agent to a multi-year contract. McCutchen, who turned 38 this offseason, was the club’s highest-paid free agent this offseason, returning on the same one-year, $5 million deal as he did the two seasons prior. The highest paid newcomer is outfielder Tommy Pham, who signed a one-year, $4,025,000 deal earlier this week.

The Pirates signed just three other major league free agents who will report to Bradenton this spring: left-handed relievers Caleb Ferguson and Tim Mayza and veteran utility man Adam Frazier. Each member of that trio is coming off a down year, signed to one-year deals worth $3 million or less.

Advertise with us

Additionally, all five players on the 40-man roster who were acquired via trade — right-handers Brett de Geus, Chase Shugart and Peter Stzelecki and infielders Spencer Horwitz and Enmanuel Valdez — all arrived on pre-arbitration deals.

Familiarity remains a key for the Pirates. Each of the nine newcomers to the 40-man roster boast some form of overlap with a member of the Pirates’ baseball operation’s management staff, most coming during a shared stint with a prior employer.

McCutchen and Frazier are of course former Pirates, having played for the franchise both prior to and during the Cherington era. Cherington also has familiarity with Mayza and Horwitz, who he shared time with in Toronto during his stint as Blue Jays vice-president of baseball operations from 2016 through 2019. Assistant general manager Steve Sanders was also in Toronto at that time, working under Cherington before joining him in Pittsburgh.

Shugart and Valdez both come from Boston, the place where Cherington, Sanders and Justin Horowitz, the Pirates’ director of amateur scouting, began their careers. However, of those three, only Horowitz boasts an overlap with Pham, Shugart and Valdez during their time with the Red Sox. New management hires have also helped bring in faces familiar to them. Michael Voltmer (pro scouting) and Kevin Tenenbaum (research and development) hold connections to de Geus and Ferguson (Dodgers) and Strzelecki (Guardians).

Reasons for optimism?

So with so much of the same, how do the Pirates expect 2025 to be different? What internal improvements do they believe can make the ultimate difference?

Advertise with us

For the players, it starts with developing a winning culture within the clubhouse. While most of the veterans from last year’s team are no longer around, numerous players expected to be key contributors intend to take a bigger leadership role in 2025.

“In the short time I’ve been here, we’ve had buy-in,” Skenes told reporters at PiratesFest. “There are a lot of guys, and guys that, frankly, I wouldn’t have expected it from, are talking about changing some things in the clubhouse and that kind of thing. Because we had a good clubhouse last year, but it wasn’t anything crazy. … We’re going to work on getting it there and we’ve started already.”

“I’m not going to change who I am and get in the middle of the clubhouse and scream and holler and do all that,” added All-Star outfielder Bryan Reynolds. “But I think I got better at it last year, too, just keep building that and saying things when they need to get said, little things here and there.”

For the coaches, it means finding the right support staff to strengthen areas of weakness and further build upon areas of strength. Newly hired hitting coach Matt Hague will aim to revamp a Pirates offense that has struggled in many areas. Former Triple-A Indianapolis manager Miguel Perez will look to do the same for the bullpen, which boasts its share of projects. Finally, Brent Strom will look to add a new perspective to the Pirates’ pitching group as an assistant.

“I don’t think you can overstate the impact that coaches can have on it, too, so we made some good additions there,” Skenes said. “It’s not a complicated thing. It’s hard to do, but it’s not complicated. We just have to play better, and I think we have the pieces to do that.”

Advertise with us

While the belief, internally, looks to be strong, the Pirates know they have much to prove. Which young catcher will step up to pair with Joey Bart? Can Spencer Horwitz hold his own as an everyday big leaguer? Will Ke’Bryan Hayes remain healthy? How will Oneil Cruz fare in his first full season as a center fielder? Can Jack Suwinski recover after a dreadful showing last summer? Who will hold which roles in the bullpen?

Each aforementioned question will play a significant impact on how the Pirates 2025 unfolds. Despite many doubters, the Pirates believe they have the correct answers, and Feb. 12 marks the beginning of their opportunity to prove themselves right.