The Pirates’ 2024 season started out with hope for a postseason run and hype about upcoming prospects. Some of the hype hit, while some flamed out, and the Pirates will finish far too similar to previous seasons. Let’s take a look back to see where it all went wrong:
THE OFFSEASON: Setting up to fail
The 2024 season’s shortcomings started in the offseason. The Pirates committed $36.3 million toward seven big-league players (Aroldis Chapman, Yasmani Grandal, Marco Gonzales, Andrew McCutchen, Martin Perez, Michael A. Taylor and Rowdy Tellez) prior to opening day.
Per FanGraphs, that group of acquired players generated 3.3 WAR and had a total production value of $26.9 million for Pittsburgh heading into the final homestand.
To go along with unproductive acquisitions, the Pirates also lost a pair of projected key contributors in the offseason due to injury, as both right-handed pitcher Johan Oviedo and catcher Endy Rodriguez underwent Tommy John surgery.

MARCH: The month of injuries
Viewed as the unquestioned strength of the team entering the 2024 season, the Pirates bullpen was depleted by injuries during spring training. Right-hander Dauri Moreta saw his season come to an end and received Tommy John surgery. Colin Holderman and Carmen Mlodzinski both were sidelined for the majority of spring and were forced to begin the regular season on rehab assignments with Triple-A Indianapolis. Though he never officially went on the injured list, David Bednar pitched just twice in spring training. Rather than sending him on a rehab assignment to begin the year, Bednar started the regular season in the major leagues.
As for non-pitching injuries, Yasmani Grandal started the season on the injured list, forcing Henry Davis to carry the load as the club’s starting catcher in April.
Read More

APRIL: The month of foreshadows
With no buildup throughout spring, Bednar struggled in his high-leverage role, blowing three saves in the opening month of the regular season. Bednar, however, was not the only Pirates reliever to struggle.
Aroldis Chapman also blew a pair of saves toward the back end of the month. While solid starting pitching, at times, made up for the club’s bullpen struggles, the offense was too much to overcome. Derek Shelton openly criticized his team’s approach, saying they were not being aggressive enough at the plate. General manager Ben Cherington said on his radio show that only three position players were playing at the level the club had projected entering the season.
After starting 9-2, the Pirates finished April with a record of 14-17. Their slide included a six-game losing streak in the middle of the month and six losses in their final seven games entering May.

MAY: The month of slumps
Tellez, Taylor, Jared Triolo, Jack Suwinski, and a recently activated Grandal all struggled mightily at the plate. Tellez was the worst of the bunch, finishing May with a minus-1.2 WAR, second-worst in MLB. The Pirates bullpen finished May with a 5.21 ERA, the worst in the National League.
The unit’s worst moment came during Paul Skenes’ debut, where Kyle Nicolas, Josh Fleming and Colin Holderman combined to walk six runs in during the top of the fifth inning. Less than two weeks later, the bullpen blew back-to-back games against the Giants, having led by at least four runs in both contests.
May also marked the end of Roansy Contreras’ time in Pittsburgh. A former top-100 prospect and promising young arm acquired from the Yankees in exchange for Jameson Taillon, Contreras was designated for assignment to make room for Skenes on the 40-man roster. He was traded just days later to the Angels.

JUNE: The month of ugly mistakes
Despite finishing June with a winning record (14-12), the Pirates still had plenty of frustrating blunders. A disastrous pair of relief appearances from Ben Heller in the early half of the month washed away two potential comeback victory efforts.
A week later, Grandal’s lazy throw back to the mound allowed the Rockies to steal home plate in a blowout victory at Coors Field.
Edward Olivares’ poor slide at home plate in Atlanta on June 29 prevented the Pirates from scoring a go-ahead run in extra-innings against the Braves.
A red-hot month from Bryan Reynolds, an unexpected turnaround from Tellez and a lights-out effort from the starting rotation ultimately outweighed the bad. Despite some ugly moments, the Pirates were playing better baseball.

JULY: The month of false hope
The surge of improved play inspired Cherington to buy at the deadline, acquiring infielder Isiah Kiner-Falefa from the Blue Jays, outfielder Bryan De La Cruz from the Marlins and left-handed reliever Jalen Beeks from the Rockies.
With a strong rotation, Cherington also felt comfortable enough to move starters Martin Perez and Quinn Priester, trimming his club’s pitching depth just days before it embarked on a month with only three off days. The moves also came in a month where Jared Jones was placed on the injured list and left-handers Bailey Falter and Marco Gonzales had just returned from their own IL stints.

AUGUST: The month of implosion
The Pirates’ best month of 2024 was followed by their worst. A banged-up and notably thinner starting rotation failed to go deep into ballgames, putting more stress on a bullpen that was unable to pick up the slack. Holderman and Bednar were responsible for seven of the club’s 18 losses, while others in lesser leverage roles also failed to produce consistent clean innings of relief.
A season-worst 10-game losing streak in the front half of the month erased all of July’s progress and eliminated Pittsburgh from serious playoff contention. Kiner-Falefa, De La Cruz and Beeks hurt the Pirates more than they helped.
On August 26, the Pirates moved Oneil Cruz from shortstop to center field, signaling that they had officially set their sights on 2025. Just two days later, they suffered their most humiliating loss of the season, a 14-10 defeat to the Cubs in a game where they led by seven runs entering the seventh inning.

SEPTEMBER: The final month of failure
The Pirates started the final month of the season by going hitless in the first six innings three separate times in a week. The most notable poor offensive showing came on Sept. 4, when Cubs rookie Shota Imanaga and a pair of relievers threw a combined no-hitter in a 12-0 win over Pittsburgh at Wrigley Field. Tellez pitched the frame for the Pirates that evening, his third relief appearance in less than two weeks. Shelton generated headlines after the loss when asked of his decision to once again pitch the first baseman.
On Sept. 11, Cherington announced that he expects Shelton to return as the club’s manager in 2025. Things remained relatively quiet on the Pirates' end until the final week of the regular season. With six games remaining, the club designated Tellez and Taylor for assignment. Tellez’s dismissal drew heavy criticism when reports surfaced that he was only four plate appearances away from a $200,000 incentive bonus.
Both Cherington and Shelton claimed finances had nothing to do with Tellez’s dismissal.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.