Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where the Post-Gazette reporters Andrew Destin and Noah Hiles answer all of your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, tweet them at @AndrewDestin1 and @_Noahhiles or email them at adestin@post-gazette.com and nhiles@post-gazette.com. Andrew and Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions.

Steve: Should Shelton consider shutting down David Bednar? Just watching him you see something is off.

Destin: Absolutely. Given his struggles, the two separate stints on the injured list and the Pirates’ falling out of postseason contention, I see few reasons to continue pitching David Bednar. As a two-time All-Star, he has proven capable of getting through a full big-league season but was sidetracked from the get-go this year. Hence, I think it would be in Bednar’s best interests — both physically and mentally — to shut him down for the rest of the season.

Hiles: I think that’s the best thing for both parties. Bednar is going through the worst struggles of his big-league career. While there is still a chance he could turn things around in September, I’m not sure if it’s worth risking things getting even worse. Like it or not, this guy is still a piece of this club’s foundation. There is still a very good relief pitcher in there, he just hasn’t shown it throughout most of 2024. If it were my call, I would end his season now. Have him spend September in Bradenton, working out, getting individual instruction and most importantly, just getting away from this mess. They have to get him right for 2025. Pull the plug on this year and start mapping out a plan to find the old David Bednar, the one who made back-to-back All-Star teams.

Advertise with us

Allen: Will they win 74 games? Vegas set the number at 73.5 at the beginning of the year.

Destin: Following Wednesday’s loss, the Pirates would need to go 12-17 the rest of the way to get to 74 wins. I think they do, but a good bit of that has to do with strength of schedule. A 10-game homestand featuring seven contests against the Nationals and Marlins should be quite favorable for the Pirates. My preseason prediction was 79 wins, and I think that’s starting to become quite unlikely. But I imagine they’ll split the difference and get right around 76 wins.

Hiles: I still think they will win over 74 games. Their schedule is much easier this final month. The offense truly hasn’t been that bad as of late, and with Jones back in the rotation, I think the starting pitching will be better than it was in August. The bullpen has killed this club and might continue to do so. However, despite the recent three-day disaster that took place against the Cubs, I still think this team can win at least 12 more games this year.

Mike: Given Bubba Chandler's success early on in AAA, do you think he'll get a chance for a spot start with the Bucs similar to the cup of coffee Oneil Cruz got in '21?

Destin: I personally don’t think success has anything to do with this equation. While Chandler’s had a phenomenal season, comparing the prospect of Chandler getting a cup of coffee to Cruz’s in ’21 is apples to oranges, in my mind, considering we’re dealing with pitchers and hitters. With only a few weeks left in Triple-A Indianapolis’ season, I imagine it’s in the Pirates and Chandler’s best interests to keep pitching him at that level and finish strong heading into the offseason.

Advertise with us

Hiles: I totally agree with Andrew. Chandler could be the best pitcher in Triple-A and I don’t think it would change much with his development plan for 2024. They have a very detailed plan for Chandler, similar to what we’ve seen with Jared Jones, Paul Skenes, etc. My guess is they just let him finish the year strong in Triple-A. If we see him in the big leagues, I don’t think it will be more than one outing. They might let him face the lineup one time through. But I would bet against that happening.

Ryan: What do you guys think about the play of Reynolds. Looked good this home series against the Cubs

Destin: Defense aside, I’d say it’s safe to say Reynolds has turned in quite a solid season. He’s certainly cooled in August, but that’s in comparison to a pair of stellar months in June and July. On a team littered with inconsistency across the board — the bullpen, defense, offensive contributions — Reynolds has been among the few bright spots on a regular basis. It’s not a surprise that he’s hit at least 20 home runs for the fourth straight season based on his even-keeled nature and approach to the game.

Hiles: Aside from taking Skenes first overall, Reynolds has been the best investment Cherington has made during his time with the Pirates. The guy continues to improve and has been the team’s most reliable hitter all season. His defense is a bit of an issue, but he more than makes up for it at the plate. Moving forward, he would be a guy I might consider simply making my full time designated hitter. Simply let the man focus on what he does best — mashing baseballs.

Tom: With the season over why not DFA Joe, MAT, etc and get young kids in there daily? Davis should play every day. Cook & Nick from AAA.

Advertise with us

Destin: I imagine this roster will look quite different come September, when one pitcher and one position player from the 40-man can be added. At this juncture, it would be difficult to say who exactly will head out of town. But I have to figure that Billy Cook and Nick Yorke aren’t the only hitters in the minors we see at some juncture. Perhaps Jack Suwinski returns, or Liover Peguero gets his first substantial big-league shot this season. Either way, I have to believe a youthful wave will be embraced sooner rather than later. It’s just unclear in the interim who will be deemed expendable.

Hiles: Unless they made an additional move that I missed, I believe the Pirates still only have 38 men on their 40 man roster. If that’s indeed the case, then there is a clear path for both Cook and Yorke to be added. They could be September call-ups, although like Andrew mentioned, I think Suwinski and Peguero will get priority over both. But I agree with the point you’re going for, Tom. It’s time to play the kids, or at least guys who we know will be here in 2025. Michael A. Taylor won’t be here. Yasmani Grandal won’t be here.

ME: Now that Cruz is moving to CF and the OF seems set (in theory), do you see Jack moving to 1B provided he rediscovers his bat? Or maybe Reynolds to 1B and Jack to LF? If both are plausible, which makes more sense to you?

Destin: I think both options are plausible, especially given your prefacing it’s assuming Suwinski finds his stroke again in the batter’s box. Personally speaking, I would move Reynolds to first base. Per Baseball Savant’s Outs Above Average metric, Reynolds has been the worst defensive left fielder in MLB this year. As he continues to decline as an outfielder while the Pirates seek his bat to remain at least above average, I think it would behoove Reynolds to be moved to first base. That being said, Suwinski makes some sense as a lefty. But I feel that creates more question marks rather than answers for 2025.

Hiles: There are a few ways to look at this. We’ll start with Reynolds, who I think is due for a position change in the near future. Personally, I would just make him the full-time designated hitter. He could still play a few games a month in the outfield when needed, but I’d just let him focus on being the best hitter possible. Suwinski could be a decent candidate for first base, but that’s assuming he’s still a big piece for this team moving forward. Perhaps the Pirates changed their feelings toward Jack after this disastrous year. Based on where he is now, is it smart to view him as anything more than a platoon outfielder? And would moving him to a completely new position be something he can handle on top of figuring out how to fix his problems at the plate? I would personally view Suwinski as my fourth outfielder in 2025 — a guy that can platoon in right field with De La Cruz, and play at the other two spots when guys need a day off. I’m going outside the organization to find answers at first base.

Advertise with us

Eric: I firmly believe a house cleaning is in order BUT how much credit do we need to give the organization for Cruz seemingly turning a corner at the plate. Is it enough to believe in the vision? Similarly, what’s the case to turn around the rest of the year? Will we see some more prospects make an appearance?

Destin: I’d say the vast majority of credit should go to Cruz. It’s hardly been a seamless transition getting back to competing in the big leagues after missing nearly all of the 2023 campaign. But especially lately, he’s resembled the player the Pirates have been steadfast in believing Cruz is capable of becoming. So the Pirates deserve some credit for their conviction. But in terms of the rest of the season, one has to believe the solution is trying different players. Jack Suwinski, Liover Peguero, Nick Yorke and Billy Cook are all players I’d like to learn more about in September.

Hiles: I’d be willing to give the Pirates staff a bit of credit for guiding Cruz through the issue, but he deserves the bulk of the praise, as he’s the one who put the work in. I think that can be said for just about any individual baseball player who turns a corner. The coaching staff can only do so much, it’s on the player to ultimately produce better results. As far as the second half of the question, like we mentioned earlier, I look at Suwinski and Peguero as the most likely call-ups. We might also see Yorke or Cook, but I doubt we both this year.

Thank you all for following along! Please subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter and YouTube channel: @PGSportsNow.