The hometown kid had the perfect chance to redeem himself against the team that drafted him.

Less than 24 hours removed from seeing his streak of 19 straight saves end, closer David Bednar entered in the ninth inning of Thursday afternoon’s game at PNC Park seeking to preserve the Pirates’ 5-4 lead over the Padres. Bednar instead blew his fifth save of the season and second in as many games, yielding three earned runs in a 7-6 loss.

The defeat marked the Pirates’ sixth in seven game, as well as the fourth time they have been swept this season In the process, the club’s record on the year dropped to 56-58.

“That’s just unacceptable,” Bednar said. “The guys battle back both games, and it’s just a big-time letdown on my end. Today was incredibly frustrating. Just a lot of free stuff, and that just can’t happen.”

Advertise with us

Bednar gave up an infield single before sandwiching a pair of walks around his lone strikeout of the afternoon. With the bases loaded, Bednar induced a ground ball to second, one that briefly looked like it might lead to a game-ending double play.

Instead, it was hit so slowly that shortstop Oneil Cruz had to hurry on the turn. His throw to first was off the mark and allowed the Padres to tally the go-ahead run from second.

"It's one of those damned if you do, damned if you don't throw it,” manager Derek Shelton said of Cruz’s play. “If you don't throw it, everyone wants to know why you didn't throw it with that arm.”

Padres second baseman Luis Arraez put the finishing touches on the visitors’ three-game sweep with an RBI double to right-center off Bednar, which prompted his departure. Bednar left the contest with his seasonlong ERA up to 5.77, as well as five blown saves on the campaign.

Both Bednar and Shelton attributed his recent struggles to a lack of fastball command. The two-time All-Star who was once so reliable has endured quite the mercurial season, which started with blowing three of his first four save opportunities.

Advertise with us

Drawing upon that experience, when he was booed off the field at PNC Park in early April, Bednar is confident he can get through another trying stretch.

“Obviously, this really sucks. There’s no other way around it,” Bednar said. “But I have total confidence in myself to get back on the right track. And there’s still a lot of season left. These are big games, but there are still a lot of big games left.”

The ones in the rearview mirror show a forgettable homestand for the Pirates, in which they went 1-5. Now, they face the daunting task of six straight road games on the West Coast, starting with three against the Dodgers and another trio with the Padres.

Including Thursday’s loss, the Pirates fell to 19-22 in one-run games. It’s a reflection of a struggling bullpen, one that entered the contest with a 4.40 ERA on the year, a figure that ranked fifth worst in MLB, and has been taxed by a couple of recent games with rain delays.

Not to mention, scuffling reliever Colin Holderman — once the Pirates’ most reliable bullpen arm this season — landed on the injured list prior to Thursday’s contest with a right wrist sprain. Holderman had given up 11 runs, eight of them earned, over his previous 4⅓ innings.

Advertise with us

But on Thursday, Bednar was the latest culprit for coughing up a Pirates lead.

“These guys battled their butts off, and to be in the position, up in the ninth, I should be able to convert those,” Bednar said. “And especially the past two nights, not being able to is tough.

“But you know what? I’m confident I’ll be able to get through this, and I’ll be able to convert this next couple.”

On the mound

Starter Luis Ortiz again labored out of the gate. Ortiz, who had yielded nine earned runs over his previous 10⅓ innings, was tagged for a pair before the first inning concluded. Padres third baseman Manny Machado pounced on a hanging slider from Ortiz for a two-run homer to give San Diego its first lead of the game.

The Padres made it back-to-back innings with homers, as outfielder David Peralta turned on a cutter from Ortiz for a two-run shot of his own. Before Ortiz could record his fourth out of the contest, the Pirates found themselves eyeing a four-run deficit.

Advertise with us

“They are taking advantage of the first pitch of the at-bat,” Ortiz said, with major-league coach Stephen Morales translating. “The plan hasn’t changed. I’m just attacking the strike zone and making my pitches.”

Despite those two forgettable innings to open the contest, Ortiz settled down to cover four more frames and aid a beleaguered bullpen. In total, Ortiz gave up just four hits and walked one, but the long ball got the best of the right-hander again.

In his previous start, Ortiz gave up three home runs in the first inning. While four-baggers haven’t been a terribly serious issue for Ortiz this season, they have been recently. Of the nine home runs Ortiz has given up in 2024, six have come in his last three starts.

“Sometimes, they hit out good pitches that are well located,” Ortiz said. “Sometimes, I leave them on top of the plate. It’s just a matter of continuing to execute pitches.”

At the plate

As they often have this week, the Pirates clawed back from an early deficit. The club pushed across three runs in the sixth inning and took a 5-4 lead in the bottom of the seventh courtesy of a two-run homer by Joey Bart.

Advertise with us

The four-bagger was Bart’s ninth of the season, which is two shy of matching his career high with the Giants in 2022.

“I wish I could've probably done it earlier in the game when we had guys on base,” Bart said. “But I just want to fight through every at-bat, never talk myself out of it all the way through the third, fourth, fifth at-bat.”

Before Bart put the Pirates in front, Cruz got them on the board with an RBI single in the sixth. But Cruz was thrown out at second after he stared at his shot and took too long to turn on the jets. Shelton unsuccessfully challenged that Cruz was safe at second.

Subsequently, the Pirates couldn’t get the umpires to take another look at a close play later in the frame. With the bases loaded and the Pirates trailing by one, Isiah Kiner-Falefa slowly rolled a grounder to third and was thrown out on a bang-bang play at first.

Shelton said even if he had a challenge, he wouldn’t have used it on that play.

Advertise with us

"He was out,” Shelton said of Kiner-Falefa. “ ... When we called upstairs, they said he was out."

All told, it was a solid series for the Pirates offensively after being shut out in the first game. Combined, the Pirates scored 14 runs across the three games and 31 runs during the six-game homestand.

But during that stretch, the Pirates also went 0-4 in one-run games.

“We know we gotta win those games. When it comes down to it, those one-run games are huge,” Bart said. “There's a lot of one-run games won every year by good clubs. We've won one-run games, but lately, we haven't. So we'll be better. We'll find ways to win.”

They said it

“He's done it a lot of times. There's no hiding that,” Bart said of Bednar. “The guy knows how to end games. Just been scuffling a little bit. I know we got full support of him. We know he'll bring it.”

Advertise with us

Up next

Friday: Pirates at Dodgers, 10:10 p.m., Dodger Stadium

TV, radio: SportsNet Pittsburgh, KDKA-FM (93.7)

Probable pitchers: RHP Mitch Keller (10-5, 3.20) for Pirates; RHP Jack Flaherty (8-5, 2.80) for Dodgers

Key matchup: Flaherty, a former Cardinals starter whom the Dodgers acquired from the Tigers just before the trade deadline passed, has had many encounters with the Pirates over the years. Across 89⅓ innings against the Pirates, Flaherty has a career 2.52 ERA.

Hidden stat: Since allowing five runs in ⅔ of an inning on May 23 against the Giants, right-hander Hunter Stratton has posted an 0.67 ERA (13⅓ innings pitched, 1 earned run) over his last 12 appearances.

Advertise with us

Saturday: Pirates at Dodgers, 9:10 p.m., Dodger Stadium

Probable pitchers: RHP Paul Skenes (6-1, 1.99) for Pirates; RHP River Ryan (1-0, 1.72) for Dodgers

Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and @AndrewDestin1 on X