Toren Mehta wanted nothing more than an afternoon at the ballpark with his father. Having recently fallen in love with the game of baseball, the 9-year-old refused to miss out on the opportunity to watch his Pittsburgh Pirates play in his home city of Philadelphia.
The day couldn’t have been any better. The sun was shining. The Pirates had a sizable lead over the Phillies. There was no chance the father-son duo was leaving early to beat the traffic. And in the top of the ninth inning, their continued presence was rewarded.
On a 2-2 pitch from Ricardo Pinto, Pirates veteran designated hitter Andrew McCutchen connected on a slider over the plate, sending it 378 feet to left field for his 300th career home run. Toren and his father, Vinay, were on the receiving end of the big fly.
“I didn’t see it because there were a bunch of people, and then I just felt it hit my hat,” Toren said. “Then I knew it bounced up, and my dad caught it.”
They were unaware of the ball’s significance. And at that time, the world was unaware of the Mehta family’s recent journey. In October 2022, Toren was diagnosed with acute leukemia. For the next year, he spent his days in and out of the hospital and doctors’ offices, fighting for his life.
Baseball was one of the few things that kept Toren going throughout his most challenging days. But when face-to-face with McCutchen, his favorite player, he chose to keep this story to himself.
Read More
A few days after Toren presented McCutchen his 300th home run ball, a story ran in The Pitt News detailing the fourth-grader’s backstory. Word began to spread, eventually reaching Pirates owner Bob Nutting, who then took it upon himself to give Toren and his family a day to remember.
The Mehta family made its way to Pittsburgh this weekend for the Pirates’ showdown against the Atlanta Braves. On Saturday, before the game, Toren had the chance to be a part of the Pirates family. He met his favorite players, played catch on the field during batting practice, tossed out the first pitch and then watched the game with Nutting in his personal suite.
This is the story of how Toren’s magical day came to be:
Shocking news
Something just didn’t feel right. Multiple things, actually.
Toren recalled waking up on a Monday morning in October feeling really tired. And in addition to his fatigue, there was a “bump” in his neck that caused extra discomfort. After missing school that day, he tried to return for a half-day the next morning.
The hope was he would be feeling better by Wednesday, so he wouldn’t have to miss baseball practice. But instead of having fun with his friends on the field, Toren spent that evening with his father in the hospital.
“I was scared,” Toren said. “They did a couple of checkups. That’s when they told us the news.”
“I was in shock,” Vinay added. “They drew his blood. The doctor showed me the results. All of his white blood cells, red blood cells and platelet counts were through the roof. He said immediately, ‘Your son has acute leukemia.’ They had to transport him to begin treatment that evening. At this point, it was like 11 p.m. I was just in shock. You just don’t expect anything like that.”
That day marked the beginning of Toren’s battle with cancer, a fight that still persists to this day.
The early months were the most difficult. While Toren’s friends were out trick-or-treating on Halloween, he was in the hospital. He spent the majority of third grade too weak to attend school. He received over 20 spinal taps throughout his first year of treatment.
There were plenty of tears, from both Toren and loved ones. But even in his darkest moments, baseball was always there to provide a break from reality.
“The time I started getting into baseball was around the time I was diagnosed,” Toren said. “I used to just watch the game if someone else had it on TV. I didn’t really start watching it on my own until I was in the hospital. I just would turn on the TV and watch playoff baseball.”
The ‘bigger, broader picture’
Andrew McCutchen still struggles to wrap his mind around what happened on April 14.
The Pirates slugger was overwhelmed by the kindness Toren and Vinay showed him that afternoon, not asking for anything more than a picture and an autograph in exchange for his 300th home run ball.
“Honestly, one of the best reactions I could have gotten from a family, the dad and the son,” McCutchen said. “It was very genuine. They didn’t want much. They didn’t want anything. They just wanted to give me the ball. I was appreciative of that. It makes you want to do more for people, as opposed to people who want the moon — and rightfully so. For him, he just wanted to give it to me. Obviously, I had to hook them up a little bit. Makes you want to do it more.”
But as time went on, McCutchen began to appreciate the moment even more. He, like Nutting, learned of Toren’s backstory. While he didn't speak with the Mehta family following that Sunday, he said he looked forward to seeing them Saturday.
McCutchen told the Post-Gazette that he appreciated the family’s kindness and humility. And outside of their brief interaction, he also appreciates how the magical day was made possible.
“It’s crazy how things happened,” McCutchen said. “For it to lead to that moment, on that day, a lot of stuff had to happen. I could’ve hit the home run in Miami, Washington, that previous homestand or even last year. I tore an Achilles, dealt with some injuries and wasn’t able to get to it until this year. Then I had a slow start to the season. Then, leading up to my last at-bat in Philly, I hit it square and they caught it.
“To not even remotely think of what led to them coming to that game that day, it’s just a bigger, broader picture. When I sit there and I think about that, it just makes you kind of appreciate where you are. Things like that help you remember that you’re just playing a game.”
McCutchen isn’t the only one overwhelmed by the chain of events that occurred prior to his 300th blast. The Mehta family has also found joy in the way everything unfolded.
“We always told him, when he would ask us why this happened to him, that there has to be a reason,” Toren’s mother, Ami Patel, said. “I’m not saying his past was the reason, but I don’t know. Stuff like this, it re-instills faith in you.”
‘Stronger than ever’
Toren is currently receiving maintenance therapy. His fight isn’t over but is far more bearable than it was a year ago. Vinay and Ami can’t help but smile when listening to their son detail his journey. The two remained impressed with his strength throughout the entire process.
“He’s handled it so well, with such grace, strength and courage,” Ami said. “We say all the time that he even makes me forget what he’s battling because he handles it all so well.”
Toren has been doing especially well as of late. He has become an even bigger Pirates fan, asking the family’s Amazon Alexa for score updates each evening before he goes to bed. And more importantly, Toren is once again working to play the game of baseball, something he’s missed out on throughout his illness.
“He’s mostly back to his old self — or even stronger than he was before,” Vinay said. “We’ve been playing baseball since we went to that game. He hadn’t actually worn a glove since his diagnosis. We hadn’t tossed a ball before then because he just wasn’t strong enough to do it. But over the past few weeks, we’ve been tossing the ball in the backyard. He looks stronger than ever.”
That practice in the backyard was put on display Saturday afternoon, when Toren delivered the game’s first pitch to his father at PNC Park.
Accompanied by more than 20 friends and family members, he made the most of his day on the North Shore. Toren was reunited with McCutchen, who gave him the pair of batting gloves he wore while hitting his 300th home run. He also met numerous other Pirates, including his favorite players, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Paul Skenes.
“It was amazing,” Toren said with a smile from ear to ear. “This was the best day ever.”
Toren and Vinay Mehta showed up to Citizens Bank Park on Sunday, April 14 just hoping to enjoy a ballgame. Instead, fate delivered an experience that neither of them will forget.
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and @_NoahHiles on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.