BRADENTON, Fla. — Andrew McCutchen recognizes his days as an everyday outfielder have long since passed him by.
McCutchen, 37, only got seven starts in right last season while battling a few injuries and is now coming off one of the most serious of his career after partially tearing his left Achilles tendon last September. Though yet to appear in a spring training game for the Pirates as either a hitter or fielder, McCutchen is confident he can still occasionally trot to the outfield in 2024.
“It's just being ready, being capable to do it,” McCutchen said. “I don't feel like there'll be anything that can — at this moment — stop me from doing it.”
McCutchen made it abundantly clear he isn’t expected to regularly post up in front of PNC Park’s Clemente Wall. Instead, the plan is for McCutchen to be available to spell starters like Bryan Reynolds every few days to get them essential time off their feet.
That will come in conjunction with more frequent time as a designated hitter for McCutchen. The last two seasons, McCutchen has been in a lineup 179 times as a DH, including a career-high 97 occurrences last year in his first campaign back with the Pirates since 2017.
While designated hitter duties are what’s primarily awaiting McCutchen in what will be his 16th MLB season, he’s eager to be an outfield option. Having received a clean bill of health from team doctors in the offseason, McCutchen said he’s inching himself closer to appearing in games, both as a hitter and fielder.
Read More
“You got to be a little more cautious,” McCutchen said. “But at the same time, you understand you have a job to do. I have things I need to prepare, boxes I need to check. So it's doing all that, all the while being aware of what's going on with your body.”
As the calendar turns to March, McCutchen said there’s nothing he hasn’t done on the field yet — besides play in a game, of course. But as McCutchen noted, replicating game-like situations is a difficult chore in baseball.
For as many fly balls as McCutchen catches on practice fields or trips he takes around the bases during batting practice, they pale in comparison to actually playing in a game — especially so for McCutchen when it comes to seeing how his Achilles will respond.
“I don’t really even care about the live at-bats,” McCutchen said. “But just getting the reps in the games, hitting the ball, running down the line, rounding bags, putting on the brakes — little things like that that happen in the game that you're prepared for.”
McCutchen imagines he’ll start appearing in spring training games soon. Last season, McCutchen appeared in 12 total, four of which came as a right fielder. If not for taking a pitch off his left hand in early March, he probably would have appeared in more in 2023.
But as is to be expected of any veteran, especially one coming off an injury of McCutchen’s nature, he’ll be slowly brought along this spring. McCutchen isn’t terribly worried, instead understanding his body has to undergo a healing process he’s got no prior experience with.
While McCutchen dealt with a torn ACL in his left knee in 2019, the Achilles has brought along wholly new challenges.
“It's something I've never had to deal with,” McCutchen said. “It was a little different of preparation for me this offseason. But was able to handle that, take care of it and trying to stay on top of that now. I'm feeling pretty good going into this year.”
With the way McCutchen swung the bat when healthy last season, simply having him good to go as a DH would behoove the Pirates. Extrapolating his .256/.378/.397 slash line across a full season, it’s not inconceivable McCutchen could hit 20 home runs for the 10th time in his career.
But if McCutchen can provide a league-average defense or better, it would provide the Pirates with an unexpected luxury at least once a week. He’s shown the ability to do so over the last two years, combining to save one out above average, per Fangraphs.
In the meantime, McCutchen will keep with his holding pattern of waiting for the chance to take the field this spring.
“That's probably the hardest process of this whole thing,” McCutchen said. “Letting your body do what it needs to do to heal itself so you can get out there and play the game.”
Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and @AndrewDestin1 on X





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.