They’ve been through a pandemic and several sizable trades. There have also been two long-term extensions signed, which equals the number of 100-loss seasons and No. 1 overall picks, not to mention a promising start and finish to this past season.
But as the Pirates reconvene in Bradenton, Fla., this week for spring training, there’s a different goal on the horizon for 2024:
Win.
For as much as this Pirates group has experienced when it comes to team-building — Bryan Reynolds, Ke’Bryan Hayes, David Bednar, Mitch Keller and Jack Suwinski emerging as a solid core, Oneil Cruz tantalizing and prospects reaching the major leagues and flashing potential — the hardest work is only starting.
These young Pirates are well-aware of the payoff and what it could feel like if they can recreate those playoff years from 2013-15. They also know this spring will be a key pivot point when it comes to the biggest breakthrough yet.
“We know it's there,” Suwinski said of the urgency to produce a winning season. “The guys before me and some of the older guys are doing a really good job of leading us and setting those expectations.”
Read More
It should be a fascinating chemistry experiment to track, one with some strange parallels to what the Pirates experienced in February 2013. There’s a platoon once again at first base, a third baseman who posted a strong second half the year before, an important utility guy and also a left-handed pitcher (or two) added via agency.
See: Andrew McCutchen. No matter how much you change — Cutch had not even popped the question to Maria on “The Ellen Show” — some things remain the same.
“We have to look around and believe in the process,” McCutchen said. “It’s more than reading names on a piece of paper and saying, ‘OK, this is the team we have.’ There are a lot of things we have to do to make that work.”
Cutch isn’t wrong, and we’ll get there. But the storylines are freaky, aren’t they?
Heading into that transformative season, Pedro Alvarez was very much a defensive liability — the polar opposite of Hayes — but hit .274 with an .869 OPS over his final 94 games of 2012.
Alvarez, who had produced a .696 OPS over his first two MLB seasons, would increase that to .770 in 2013 while earning his first and only All-Star nod. Hayes hit .299 with an .874 OPS over his final 49 contests of 2023, finishing with a .762 OPS.
For the Pirates to accomplish their goals in 2024, Hayes simply has to be front and center — with more than his incredible glove, too.
Josh Harrison played five positions in 2012 and six a year later, recording an out as a pitcher in a blowout. It should be the same thing for Jared Triolo, as he expands from third base, second and first to potentially some shortstop and outfield, as well.
Similar to how the 2013 team leaned on both Garrett Jones and Gaby Sanchez, the 2024 Pirates figure to deploy Rowdy Tellez against right-handed pitching and take advantage of how well Connor Joe typically fares against lefties.
Pitching-wise, the Pirates would be thrilled if Marco Gonzales and Martin Perez fared as well as Francisco Liriano did back in the day, although there are obvious differences when it comes to the overall depth of the starting rotation.
“We want to win,” Keller said. “I mean, we’ve always wanted to win, but I feel like we have a really good, cohesive group where we can come together and really do something special.”
The precise definition of that can be tough, but it’s obviously shooting higher than 76 wins to fit owner Bob Nutting’s definition of contending throughout the season.
At the same time, much needs to happen for the Pirates to make some noise in the National League Central, as well as what should be a heated chase for one of three wild card spots.
The biggest question this offseason — for perfectly understandable reasons — revolved around starting pitching. Pittsburgh finished 2023 with just two traditional starters. One had Tommy John surgery (Johan Oviedo). Gonzales and Perez obviously aren’t sure bets.
If the Pirates are going to legitimately break through in 2024, there’s a different path they’ll need to take than in 2013. That group had A.J. Burnett, Jeff Locke, Francisco Liriano, Charlie Morton and Gerrit Cole among the top five in starts. Nobody had worse than a 3.52 ERA.
The interesting part is that those gaudy numbers represented substantial improvement from 2012, when James McDonald,, Kevin Correia, Erik Bedard and Jeff Karstens were the four most frequently used starters beyond Burnett.
If the Pirates are to do something similar this time around, the improvement must come from the likes of Roansy Contreras, Quinn Priester and Luis Ortiz, as well as the emergence of Paul Skenes, Jared Jones and others.
"We know to be the team we want to be in Pittsburgh, we have to be good at developing pitching," general manager Ben Cherington said. "I think we’ve actually made a lot of progress in that. There are signs, but we have to keep getting better."
“We have a lot of young talent,” Colin Holderman added. “We’re excited to see what we can do.”
The uncertainty surrounding the starting staff doesn’t exist as much in the bullpen, where the $10.5 million addition of Aroldis Chapman came out of nowhere but should also give the group a competitive advantage.
If it’s not two-time All-Star David Bednar closing games, the seven-time All-Star Chapman — who threw 266 pitches that registered 100 mph or harder in 2023 — is more than capable of filling in. A two-time World Series champion, Chapman also has plenty of experience to impart on this young club.
In fact, spring training will be an important time for Chapman and Perez to establish themselves as veteran voices. Tellez, too, as his fun-loving personality should be warmly welcomed.
“There's a lot of young talent here,” Chapman said, with Pirates director of communications Melissa Strozza translating. “They're very hungry to win. I was excited to be a part of that.”
By adding Chapman, the Pirates can be more liberal with the use of Holderman, Carmen Mlodzinski and Ryan Borucki. They should also increase their chances of protecting leads. The challenging part will involve acquiring them.
The biggest offensive question mark for the Pirates isn’t hard to find. It’s 6-foot-7 and almost always smiling and laughing. Oneil Cruz can hit the ball harder and farther than most others in MLB — hence why there will be so much attention paid to his return from serious ankle surgery.
If Cruz can make good on his considerable potential, the top of the Pirates’ lineup might be better than expected, with Cruz followed by Bryan Reynolds, Hayes, Tellez, McCutchen, Suwinski and Henry Davis, in some order.
If not, well, you saw what happened last year, when the Pirates cycled through Rodolfo Castro, Tucupita Marcano and Alika Williams at shortstop. They need Cruz to add what Starling Marte did atop the lineup back in the day — and probably more.
“It’s going to be different this year,” Cruz promised. “Especially now that I’ll be able to add to our team and help us out.”
There’s some measure of development left with Suwinski, the Pirates needing to see more consistency and fewer strikeouts. Discussing Davis and what becomes of him behind the plate has also taken up a fair amount of the offseason, along with whether Liover Peguero, Nick Gonzales or someone else winds up starting at second base.
So many questions, so much to monitor over the next seven weeks.
Starting in spring, the Pirates will need to get to work on carving out an identity, one that’s likely predicated on speed, athleticism and getting on base, similar to what they showed during the 20-8 start of 2023.
As Hayes said, it’s a natural evolution. No longer are the Pirates in some sort of “tryout stage.” They’re looking to figure out roles and develop consistency within them.
“We know what we can do, especially with how we started last year,” Hayes said. “I’m sure everyone is looking forward to getting back to Florida and getting back to work. I know I am.”
While there’s plenty to learn about the Pirates getting on base more, power potential and young guys blossoming into MLB regulars, let’s also not lose sight of the macro at play.
Cherington, president Travis Williams, and manager Derek Shelton were hired in October-November 2019 following a train wreck of a season.
They were charged with restoring stability and competitiveness, and they were given time to do it, revamping development, coaching and a bunch of other stuff.
The 14-win improvement was nice, sure. An indication the plan may be working. But if there’s an over-arching theme to govern this upcoming Pirates season, it’s that progress only goes so far.
The 2012 team started out hot, then saw a 16-36 finish sink them to four games below .500. In 2023, a three-month stretch where the Pirates went 27-49 was far too much to overcome.
In the first case, it took young players growing up and developing mixed with the presence of key veterans to ultimately make it work. Will it happen this time around, too? There’s certainly plenty of optimism that it will.
“We’ve got the pieces and ability,” Bryan Reynolds said. “We just have to go do it.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.