SANTO DOMINGO, Dominican Republic — While Shohei Ohtani’s record-breaking $700 million contract signed earlier this offseason generated plenty of headlines across Major League Baseball, many of them (understandably) expressing amazement at the largest contract in the history of professional sports, the deal was interpreted a little differently in Pittsburgh.
Nothing against Ohtani, of course. Generational talent, a freak, maybe the best baseball player ever. But the gap between the Pirates and the Dodgers was already gigantic, and it got even bigger with the Japanese sensation’s contract.
Asked what he thought about Ohtani’s deal and whether it was good or bad for baseball, Pirates owner Bob Nutting declined to speak directly about another team’s player or the actions of a fellow owner. At the same time, the disparity between how the Dodgers and Pirates conduct themselves can’t be ignored.
Whether it’s because of Ohtani or not, Nutting said he hopes the ultimate outcome is for baseball to undergo some type of economic reform, potentially with a salary cap, floor and revamped revenue sharing — changes Nutting advocated for during a March 2021 interview with the Post-Gazette.
“I think what it highlights is we absolutely still need ongoing work on economic reform,” Nutting said Saturday at the Pirates’ academy in the Dominican Republic. “The unlevel playing field in baseball is a huge handicap and challenge for the Pittsburgh Pirates.”
The challenge also isn’t getting any smaller, at least until the current collective bargaining agreement expires in December 2026.
Read More
It’s still unlikely — especially considering the 30-to-none vote in favor of a fairly similar economic structure with the current CBA — that a cap and floor would be installed. The Pirates are also taking a hit when it comes to the expiration of their previous TV deal with AT&T SportsNet and the subsequent co-ownership of SportsNet Pittsburgh alongside the Penguins.
Pirates president Travis Williams and general manager Ben Cherington have said this offseason they don’t believe the change in TV revenue will impact how the Pirates spend, while Nutting insisted Saturday they shouldn’t use MLB’s current economic setup as an excuse for recent poor results.
“We’ll work as hard as we can within the system, and we’re going to win baseball games despite an unlevel playing field,” Nutting said. “We don’t want to have anyone in the organization embrace that as an excuse. That’s not who we are.
“But there are wildly different resources available to different teams. That makes Ben’s life harder. It’s a serious challenge. And ongoing economic reform is critically important.”
It will certainly be interesting what — if anything — MLB does to fix its economic landscape.
Nutting said MLB commissioner Rob Manfred is “fully aware of that,” when it comes to the need for economic reform. The Pirates owner also seemed to reference recent rule changes intended to make games faster and more action-packed.
Could a cap/floor system, one designed to increase parity while maintaining lucrative player salaries akin to how the NFL, NBA and NHL function, be in the offing?
Tough to say, though Nutting hopes and believes there will be change after this CBA expires.
“I know the commissioner’s office is fully aware of that; I know they’re working really hard on it,” Nutting said. “Rob has done a great job for his career being aware of, and working on, ways to make it more fun for the fan and an equal playing field.
“Every team is concerned about competitive balance. Every team is concerned about economic reform, no matter where they sit in the spectrum. I’m probably more concerned than average because of where we sit. But I think the whole industry recognizes that there’s a lot of work to do.”
Asked again whether he thought there was a chance legitimate economic reform could arrive in the next CBA cycle, Nutting answered “yes” before praising the big-picture direction of baseball.
“Over time, we have absolutely made progress,” Nutting said. “It’s not linear. We’ll take small steps forward and small steps back. But overall, I think the industry is moving in a really good, healthy direction.”
Another extension possible?
Two years ago, it was Ke’Bryan Hayes. Last season, despite turbulence during the offseason, spring training and the first week of the regular season, Bryan Reynolds. Could the Pirates complete a long-term extension for the third consecutive year?
They certainly have candidates in Mitch Keller, David Bednar, Oneil Cruz and Jack Suwinski. Spring training is also when those conversations often occur, although there’s obviously no limit in either direction.
Nutting said extending more guys is something the Pirates are “actively looking at, actively discussing” and that he would be thrilled if one or more happened. But he didn’t necessarily view it as a sign of the Pirates’ team-building progress.
“I would love to see that get done,” Nutting said. “I’m not sure I see it as a sign of progress, but I would see it as a sign of continued ongoing commitment to execute on the plan that we’ve had. I think we’re moving forward in a good direction.
“We’ve tried to sign players effectively and strategically. I think Ben has done a very good job at that. I know we have candidates that we’d love to do that again with this year.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.