The first thought that went through Jason Delay’s head when he learned Endy Rodriguez would require significant elbow surgery, ending his 2024 season before it started, was one of empathy.

Delay saw firsthand how hard Rodriguez works and knew what he was supposed to mean to not only the Pirates’ pitching staff, but their growth as a team.

“He was playing winter ball because he loves the game so much and just wants to improve,” Delay said. “You feel for him. I think he’ll come back stronger from it, but it is what it is. You have to move forward.”

That injury and its ramifications have been discussed plenty this winter, specifically relative to Henry Davis. But there’s another layer involving Delay and the fact that his role will almost assuredly increase.

Advertise with us

“I hate for any opportunity to come at someone else’s expense, but that’s kind of where we are,” Delay said. “I feel like I’m ready to take that step.”

Most important for the Pirates will clearly be rapid growth from Davis behind the plate — and the 2021 first-round pick has done everything in his power to make that happen. Still, it’s hardly a guarantee that Davis will go from two innings to 100-plus games behind the plate.

The only other catcher in the system with any meaningful experience is Ali Sanchez, who has just seven MLB games under his belt. General manager Ben Cherington has said the Pirates are interested in adding behind the plate in some capacity, but it also seems like they’re willing to entrust Delay to do more.

“Jason Delay had a really good season for us last year,” Cherington said last weekend at PiratesFest. “He became a really dependable part of the team, both on the defensive side of things and chipping in with good at-bats and key base hits. We feel good that he’s still in that group and in part of that competition going forward.”

Davis’ development and possible additions aside, there are numbers that classify Delay as starter-level good.

Advertise with us

The first of those is probably Baseball Savant’s fielding run value (FRV), an all-encompassing mark to quantify defense based on a number of factors. Delay was tied with Endy Rodriguez with an FRV of 2. Only 20 MLB backstops were better.

Delay also excelled with pitch-framing — though this is where frustrated Pirates fans start grumbling about Austin Hedges. In that aspect, Delay was eighth across MLB, per FanGraphs. When it comes to defensive runs saved, which is another FanGraphs number, Delay ranked 22nd.

The areas where Delay lacked included blocking and throwing, which were 49th and 57th, respectively. They’re fine for a backup but not good enough for someone in his position — below-average bat on a team that wants its catchers to defend really well.

On the flip side, Delay gives the Pirates certainty, which is crazy because he contemplated his retirement a couple years ago before finally making his MLB debut in June 2022.

Starting last season as Hedges’ backup, Delay was a regular late-inning defensive replacement when the Pirates would pinch hit for their No. 1 catcher late. His role became reduced to playing only 1-2 times per week after the Pirates promoted Rodriguez.

Advertise with us

“I think I established myself a little bit,” Delay said. “The staff and the guys on the team trust me back there. That goes a long way.”

At the same time, Delay wasn’t entirely happy with what he did over 70 games, specifically on offense. Over the first two months, Delay was outstanding, hitting .319 and posting an .818 OPS in 28 contests.

But then he scuffled, hitting .204 with a .560 OPS over the final 42, numbers that would be problematic if Delay became the starter in 2024.

“I still don’t feel like I performed to the best of my capability, particularly over the course of the season,” Delay said. “I had a really good start. It’s just figuring out how to maintain that throughout the year.”

One thing working in Delay’s favor could be his relationship with Mitch Keller. The Pirates’ opening day starter had a 2.37 ERA in 10 games with Delay. It was 9.11 with Rodriguez back there.

Advertise with us

Delay also meshed well with Quinn Priester in his next-to-last start of the season — two earned runs allowed over six innings Sept. 24 in Cincinnati.

“He's always really, really prepared,” Priester said. “Being able to trust him back there in some of those situations, it gave me more confidence.”

As with many things Pirates-related, there are myriad moving parts.

Can Delay give the Pirates more than his career .604 OPS? Will Davis develop enough to warrant more playing time? Do they add someone? Questions that are impossible to answer in January.

However, a credit to Delay, he proved he’s a bonafide major leaguer, at minimum a no-maintenance and well-respected backup ... with the possibility that a larger role could help him grow even more.

Advertise with us

Kranick claimed

The New York Mets claimed Max Kranick off waivers from the Pirates, a source confirmed to the Post-Gazette. Kranick was designated for assignment last week when the Pirates announced the addition of Martin Perez. In 11 MLB games, the 26-year-old Scranton native had a 5.56 ERA and was coming off Tommy John surgery in June 2022. Kranick does have a 3.55 ERA over parts of seven seasons in the minor leagues.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.