More so than bringing Andrew McCutchen back or signing Rowdy Tellez as a platoon first-base option with power potential, the need for starting pitching has framed this offseason for the Pirates.

While discussing McCutchen, Tellez, Endy Rodriguez’s elbow injury and more over Zoom on Wednesday morning, general manager Ben Cherington was understandably asked a couple questions about the state of the starting staff.

The key takeaway: Cherington is pleased with the progress the Pirates have made but doesn’t necessarily view it as final.

“We would still like to add to the starting rotation,” Cherington said.

Advertise with us

During a previous answer, Cherington sort of accidentally teased the addition of Martin Perez, whose $8 million free agent deal is pending a physical. Cherington also spoke on the trade earlier this month to acquire Marco Gonzales.

At the same time, the most interesting thing Cherington said relative to pitching and potential changes to the starting rotation involved the time remaining in the offseason and how the Pirates have resisted the urge to make a move that they felt could be improved.

“There are things we can do right now, things we could say yes to that we have not said yes to because we don’t yet like the deal,” Cherington said. “We’re gonna keep hunting opportunities.”

As reported yesterday when the Post-Gazette broke the news of McCutchen signing a one year, $5 million deal for 2024, the most likely outcome for the Pirates to supply help to Mitch Keller, Perez and Gonzales is via trade.

The Pirates have four players — Jared Triolo, Liover Peguero, Nick Gonzales and Ji Hwan Bae — who will compete for time at second base. Their best position player prospect and No. 2 overall according to MLB Pipeline (Termarr Johnson) also plays that position and will likely debut this year at Double-A.

Advertise with us

In other words, the Pirates could deal from a position of strength. If there’s an offer on the table, could Cherington be trying to get a better starting pitcher from a certain team or maybe hoping to avoid trading a particular prospect? Makes you wonder.

It’s also interesting to assess what they have in right field. Connor Joe, Joshua Palacios, McCutchen and Triolo could conceivably play out there. Canaan Smith-Njigba is probably due another big league shot, too. Edward Olivares is an intriguing addition, while Bae, if he can hit consistently, holds more defensive value in center field than second, which would bump Jack Suwinski.

A lot of moving parts.

And also components for a trade that could net the starting pitcher Pittsburgh needs.

“We’ve made some progress [with pitching],” Cherington said. “In addition, outfield/first base was an area that we wanted to strengthen. We’ve made some additions in those spots.

Advertise with us

“We feel like it’s a deeper roster, adding in areas where we wanted to add, and also certainly not satisfied. We have a long time between now and opening day. Our aim is to use every day between now and opening day to continue to make the team better.”

‘A big impact’

Wednesday marked the first time Cherington has spoken since the Pirates signed Rowdy Tellez to a one-year, $3.2 million deal, plus $800,000 in available incentives. Cherington and manager Derek Shelton were in Toronto with Tellez and have obviously seen plenty of him during his time with the Brewers (2021-23).

Tellez struggled a bunch this past season, hitting just .215 with a .667 OPS in 105 games. But he was also dealing with several injuries and nowhere near the best version of himself.

“We’re hoping he makes a big impact,” Cherington said. “This is taking a bet on a bounce-back. He’s still a relatively young player. He’s a left-handed hitter with huge power. He’s got hitting skill. He’s always had an idea of how to hit. When he’s in his best physical shape, he’s been a really productive hitter. He gives us a threat from the left side that we don’t have a lot of.”

Advertise with us

In addition to power, the Pirates in Tellez also got someone who has a solid track record of making good swing decisions.

Tellez posted a 24.2% chase rate in 2023, which was in the 77th percentile across MLB. His whiff rate was 21.9% (69th percentile). Across the board, Tellez’s numbers show someone who has become more comfortable navigating an at-bat and working to get his pitch as opposed to over-aggression and a lot of swing and miss.

Should the health component work out, there’s a pretty high ceiling that came into view in 2022, when Tellez had a .767 OPS in 153 games, with 35 home runs and 89 RBIs.

“When he’s hot, man, he’s hot,” McCutchen said of Tellez, with whom he played in 2022. “He can add a lot to this lineup. ... It’s a bat that we needed. I’m looking forward to playing with him. I think he’ll be able to enjoy the right-field wall.”

Mum on move

Advertise with us

The Pirates need to make a roster move to officially add McCutchen but said in a press release that it would be announced at a later date. They'll also need to make one to clear space for Perez.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.