The signing of Rowdy Tellez by the Pirates to a one-year contract represents a big bet.
Quite literally, as the first baseman/designated hitter is 6-foot-4, 270 pounds, an offensive tackle or defensive end playing baseball. But as the Pirates entered the offseason knowing they needed additional left-handed power and had a deficiency at first, they didn’t have to go far to find someone who checked a couple of important boxes.
After the Brewers non-tendered Tellez last month, the Pirates on Thursday signed the 28-year-old to a one-year contract worth $3.2 million guaranteed and $800,000 more in incentives. The contract is pending a physical.
Tellez is coming off a down year in 2023, one that saw his slugging percentage drop from .461 to .376 and his home run total shrink from a career-high 35 in 2022 to just 13 in 105 games. Tellez hit .215 and had a career-low .667 OPS.
Injuries played some part, as Tellez missed time with right forearm and left ring finger issues. And the cost of Tellez’s contract via arbitration, projected at $5.9 million, was prohibitive enough for the Brewers to move on.
However, it’s an interesting fit for the Pirates, who figure to platoon Tellez with Connor Joe or Jared Triolo at first base and could also divvy up designated hitter reps with Andrew McCutchen — once again, assuming he’s back — and Tellez.
Read More
The driver, of course, will be the power that was obvious from Tellez in 2022, the pop that produced 23 doubles, 35 home runs, 89 RBIs and a .767 OPS. The year before, Tellez hit .272 with an .814 OPS in 56 games after a trade to Milwaukee.
Dig into Tellez’s splits, and it’s easy to see why a platoon situation makes sense. He had a .174/.269/.261 slash line against lefties in 2023. For his career, Tellez has slashed .236/.308/.386 against them.
It shouldn’t matter a ton because Joe, Triolo and McCutchen, all right-handed hitters, have handled lefties well. Joe, for instance, slashed .265/.365/.452 against them last year.
The Pirates needed a left-handed bat who could hit righties and got one in Tellez, who has a .232/.302/.464 career slash line against them.
A 30th-round pick out of Elk Grove High School in Sacramento, Calif., Tellez also has a reputation for being a fun personality, something the Pirates also saw up close. He should fit in well with a much younger Pirates group.
While Tellez isn’t short on power, he has produced below-average numbers at first base, although it’s doubtful that matters much here.
The Pirates are banking Tellez, with a clean bill of health and regular reps, can get back to his previous performance, where the biggest dip was evident when Tellez faced heat.
After slugging .500 against fastballs in 2022, leading to much of his success, that number sat at just .363 in 2023, the worst of Tellez’s career.
The connection to Toronto is obvious — and falls in line with other stuff this regime has done. The Blue Jays drafted Tellez and had him make his MLB debut in 2018, when he appeared in 23 games and hit .314 with a .943 OPS.
Tellez played 111 games in 2019, hitting .227 with a .742 OPS that included 19 doubles and 21 RBIs. His OPS was a robust .886 in 35 games in the shortened 2020 season, and Tellez struggled with a .209 average and .610 OPS before he was dealt midway through 2021.
We’ll see whether Tellez can bounce back. Given his age, that shouldn’t be an issue. He’s healthy, and the Pirates don’t need him to do anything more than play passable defense.
It’s also a fairly low-risk move given the money and length of Tellez’s contract.
FanGraphs now estimates the Pirates’ 2024 payroll at $58 million after they also acquired Marco Gonzales (defrayed by the Mariners and Braves down to $3 million) at the Winter Meetings.
Given what general manager Ben Cherington said in Nashville — that the payroll would surpass the 2023 level (roughly $73 million) — it leaves at least a $15 million gap for more pitching, which remains the club’s biggest area of need.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.