Bryan Reynolds leaned back in his leather chair, scanned the room around him and smiled. The subject Reynolds was discussing this particular afternoon involved expectations for the Pirates in 2024, its purveyors a group of kids who can sometimes make the 28-year-old Brentwood, Tenn., native feel like he might as well be sitting on a rocking chair.
After what Reynolds has witnessed in Pittsburgh — a regime change in fall 2019, a full-scale rebuild that next winter, the focus continually calibrated toward the future — what has happened both literally and figuratively around the Pirates’ franchise player has provided a welcomed change.
You know, that there should actually be some expectations for this group next season.
“We try to win every game, obviously,” Reynolds said. “But it will be nice when that’s the sole focus next year. We have our young guys up here and accustomed to it. Now, the hope is to add some pieces in the offseason and make the playoffs next year.”
While it’s hard to call where the Pirates stand a crossroads, the turn they expect to make in 2024 does buttress the transportation metaphor. A winning record and potential postseason spot this way. Don’t miss the turn. As Pirates fans know, the re-routing process stinks.
Perhaps most important to the Pirates reaching their intended destination, the final 2 1/2 months of this season offered a heap of important mile markers, from the promotion of young players to the cruise-control-consistent offense supplied by Reynolds and Ke’Bryan Hayes, the Pirates’ two highest-paid players and clear cornerstones of the current push.
Read More
After a blistering 20-8 start, then a 21-46 stretch where the Pirates struggled to avoid potholes, the final 67 games (35-32) have infused all parts of 115 Federal Street with a belief that this group has turned a corner — one where winning baseball is unquestionably the expectation in 2024.
“We’ve already started talking about next year and doing what other teams have done to get into the playoffs,” Hayes said. “We’re going to be there next year.”
Why Hayes and others feel this way involves the twists and turns that have kept fans equal parts enraptured and enraged over the past six months, progress made and clarity achieved that defined the 2023 season for the Pirates.
Among the many important items:
• Reynolds and Hayes, the latter of whom should be recognized this offseason as the best defensive third baseman in Major League Baseball, functioning as the team's two best players for an extended stretch.
• Talented youngsters who've transitioned from prospects to major leaguers, obtaining a wealth of experience along the way. It hasn't been perfect with Henry Davis, Endy Rodriguez, Liover Peguero, Quinn Priester, Jared Triolo and others. But the Pirates have also played their best while fielding a team that’s a year younger, on average, than the other 29 in MLB.
“We went through spurts where we won a lot of games and played really well as a team,” Priester said. “I know if I take care of my business this offseason, I’m gonna make an impact next year with the things I’ve learned.”
• As much fuss as there’s been over the Pirates’ hitting and pitching coaches — Andy Haines and Oscar Marin, respectively — there has been progress. Over the final 2 1/2 months, the Pirates nearly cracked MLB’s middle-third with most of those metrics. Enough? No. But there was improvement.
• In addition to Reynolds and Hayes, Jack Suwinski has blossomed into a key offensive performer, where many of his statistics mirror those of more established players and multiple-time All-Stars.
• The Pirates’ 14-win bump also comes with a few sizable qualifiers — in one sense, literally. It happened largely without 6-foot-7 Oneil Cruz, a potential budding star and someone who played just nine games because of a fractured left ankle.
Also lacking was 60% of a starting rotation, as JT Brubaker, Mike Burrows and Vince Velasquez — three of the team’s top top seven pitchers in spring training — suffered season-ending arm injuries.
“We have a bunch of people coming back,” ace pitcher Mitch Keller said. “Who knows who we’re gonna sign and what that’s gonna look like, but just to look around and be like, ‘Damn, we got some really good pieces, and we’re only gonna add more to it,’ it’s really cool.”
The evolution of Keller is no less important than the aforementioned. Labeled as a potential bust as recently as April 2022, Keller rode his recent ascent into the MLB All-Star Game this year. A contract extension could and should await.
What Keller did alongside Johan Oviedo was nothing short of remarkable, each making 32 starts and also shouldering a sizable load. The Pirates went roughly two months with only two traditional starters, often manipulating matchups and relying more than anybody else in baseball on their bullpen.
“We’ve had a lot of guys who were learning and who have taken their game to the next level by focusing and executing,” Oviedo said. “Next year is gonna be really fun because we’ve all done it.”
The on-field optimism has been reciprocated by fans frequenting PNC Park. The Pirates averaged 20,131 fans over 81 home dates, an increase of nearly 30% over last year’s mark of 15,524.
Another intriguing storyline over the final 2 1/2 months included the Pirates’ opponents, specifically on the club’s final road trip. They talked earlier in the month about embracing the role as spoiler, treating these games like the postseason as a way to prepare for next year.
They won all four of their division series and played the Braves, Yankees and Phillies, two teams who could easily meet in the National League Championship Series plus the American League’s hottest team at the time.
Inside of that, the Pirates enjoyed glimpses of what Davis and Rodriguez can become. Ditto for Triolo and his versatility, Peguero and his energy, and the reworked bullpen, aided by the emergence of Carmen Mlodzinski and even midseason addition Ryan Borucki.
"Guys have no fear out there," Borucki said. "It's been fun to see."
The hope, of course, is that the steps forward do not cease this winter.
As encouraging as the Pirates' closing kick might’ve felt — “I've never been as excited at the end of a season as I am right now,” manager Derek Shelton said — several key gears remain.
One involves the return of franchise legend Andrew McCutchen for another season. Another will be general manager Ben Cherington addressing roster needs via trade or free agency.
First base, for one. The return of Carlos Santana could make that simple. That would allow the Pirates to shift their attention to pitching. While it will be great to have No. 1 overall pick Paul Skenes here, as well as Brubaker, Burrows and maybe Velasquez, there's work to be done.
Unlike past seasons, however, meaningful baseball no longer feels miles away.
“I think we could add a few things here and there to bolster the team as a whole,” Reynolds said. “If it’s an older guy, great. If it’s a younger guy who’s gonna perform and help us, great. But I think we’re very close.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.