More than 30,000 fans packed PNC Park on a gorgeous Friday night. It was Roberto Clemente Day, with MLB Network broadcasting live from the North Shore. The Pirates’ former ace, Gerrit Cole, was also facing his former team here for the first time.
The atmosphere was not a small, quiet or insignificant one, as the Pirates opened a weekend series with the vaunted Yankees. Until the ninth inning, it looked like the Pirates might snag an impressive win ... until an implosion that spoiled the ending.
With the Pirates protecting a two-run lead, the Yankees took advantage of some Pirates miscues and escaped with a 7-5 victory. Colin Holderman tried to notch the save with David Bednar unavailable, but it didn't work out.
“I wanna win," Holderman said. "So walking away with a loss hurts."
This one stung more than others, for a few different reasons:
• There’ll be questions regarding manager Derek Shelton's bullpen usage after he pulled Mitch Keller following eight scoreless innings (92 pitches) Thursday. Had Shelton allowed Keller to try to finish it, Bednar would've been available.
Read More
At the same time, Keller's velocity had been dropping and the right-hander means too much to take any unnecessary risks now. The Pirates might’ve also needed Bednar.
What happened Friday was hardly isolated to a missing closer.
• The Yankees loaded the bases with nobody out, and Holderman walked center fielder Estevan Florial after starting with an 0-2 count. Can’t happen.
"Tried to do too much," Holderman said. “That's what happens."
• Most costly was a routine double play that the Pirates could not convert because Ji Hwan Bae, playing second base, threw wildly to first. Two runs scored on the play, which produced a 6-5 Yankees advantage.
"I think I was in a little rush, trying to turn it and throw as soon as possible," Bae said. "I've got to slow down."
No arguments here. At the same time, let's zoom out. It was still a somewhat makable play for Alfonso Rivas, who entered the game late for his defense. As a lefty, he had a better angle but still couldn't come up with the scoop or keep the ball in front enough to prevent the go-ahead from scoring.
Hitting just .202 this season, the Pirates need those plays out of Rivas and didn't get one in a key spot. It also hurts because they got Gold Glove-caliber defense from Carlos Santana over there for much of the season.
Speaking of light-hitting infielders who are here for defense ... Alika Williams watched this one from the bench. With a .566 OPS through 40 MLB games, Williams has done little with the bat, though his defense has been OK.
Still likely not enough to block 2021 first-round pick Nick Gonzales, who has been productive at Triple-A. But if you're going to keep Williams on the roster, this was his time to shine. Bump Liover Peguero to second base and have Williams enter to play shortstop.
"A lot of emotions," Bae said, still shaken up from the poor throw. "It’s part of the game, so it’s up to me how I handle it after this.”
Hard to blame Bae for feeling bad, but good or bad, there was plenty of blame to go around.
SCARY MOMENT
The Pirates (69-79) took a 5-3 lead during a breathtaking sixth inning — and not necessarily because of what they did on offense.
Bae lined a two-strike curveball up the middle at 100.6 mph. It struck Yankees reliever Anthony Misiewicz on the left side of the head, near the temple or ear, and ricocheted into right field.
Misiewicz went down in a heap. The crowd silenced. Athletic trainers rushed out to the mound. At one point, a Yankees athletic trainer applied a towel to stop the bleeding. At first base, Bae was clearly distraught.
The Pirates later announced Misiewicz was examined by a Pirates team doctor, alert and oriented. He was taken to Allegheny General Hospital for further testing.
"I've seen that too many times," Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. "That's a scary sight. Thoughts and prayers go out to him, first and foremost."
Two batters after Bae’s comebacker, Ke’Bryan Hayes picked up his third hit of the game, the ball fortuitously bouncing underneath the glove of second baseman Gleyber Torres.
ON THE MOUND
For parts of this one, it looked like it might be unsalvageable for Johan Oviedo, who once again struggled with his control and wound up walking five in five innings. But a credit to him, he pulled it together midway through.
Toward the end of his start, Oviedo had found a rhythm and retired 11 of the final 12 he faced. However, he also needed 96 pitches to get through five innings, so that was it. One positive was the seven strikeouts for Oviedo.
"The last three innings, I was feeling really good," Oviedo said. "I got the command of my fastball after the second inning."
Cole, who despite being traded in January 2018 had somehow not pitched here, called it an "odd" experience. He seemed a little jittery early, walking three in the opening frame for the first time in his career, but he settled down to allow two runs over five.
"It was a humbling experience," Cole said. "It was a really special evening. I'm glad everybody's doing alright and I'm glad that we got the win."
AT THE PLATE
Bryan Reynolds, who entered this one hitting .339 in 15 games since Aug. 29, stayed hot by shooting a Cole curveball into right field for a 2-1 Pirates lead in the second inning.
Entering Friday, only three players in that time had a better batting average than Reynolds: Philadelphia’s Trea Turner (.393), San Diego’s Xander Bogaerts (.377) and Seiya Suzuki (.350) of the Chicago Cubs.
Peguero also finished with a pair of hits.
QUOTABLE
"It's something that our guys have to learn. That's a tough one because we battled back. We did a lot of good things. We just have to finish games like that." — Shelton
UP NEXT
Luis Ortiz will start for the Pirates. He has allowed four earned runs over 16⅓ innings in his last three outings.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.