Two months in, and the Pirates are a half-game out of first place and a game over .500. Quick show of hands: Who predicted that? You're lying. With a miserable May behind us, the focus becomes June and the water theoretically finding itself level. After that ... well, that leads us into this week's mailbag. As always, you can tweet me (@JMackeyPG) or drop me a line at jmackey@post-gazette.com.

Kurt Wineman (via email): If this continues, will the Pirates be buyers or sellers at the deadline?

Nick Hayes (@nickhayes): If they make any moves at the deadline, who gets moved and to where?

Jason Mackey: I’d love to know how many people laughed at the idea of the Pirates being buyers at the deadline. I’ll admit: It was nuts the first time I considered it, too. Then I looked at the standings.

Advertise with us

A third of the way through the season, the Pirates are one game out of first place. The Cardinals are five games back and playing better baseball, but the Cubs have faded and Reds starters have been really bad, pitching to a 5.77 ERA. Not sure any team is all that intimidating, and someone has to win it, right?

If this continues is obviously the key qualifier, meaning if the Pirates remain one game out of first place in another month-plus. Even if that happens, I’d have a tough time seeing them becoming buyers — at least not aggressive ones — but it presents some questions when it comes to selling.

Do the Pirates, after two straight 100-loss seasons and one more played at that pace, eschew potential trade return and keep Rich Hill, Carlos Santana, Connor Joe, Ji-Man Choi, etc.?

Doubt Austin Hedges would net much. Vince Velasquez isn’t healthy. They better not trade Andrew McCutchen.

Prior to JT Brubaker, Mike Burrows and Velasquez going down, I might’ve been OK trading a veteran starter. Not now. I’d rather keep Hill — assuming he pitches well enough, which he has — and not sacrifice pitching depth for a fringe prospect.

Advertise with us

If the Pirates found someone to take Choi, sure. Santana and Joe would depend on return. They do add value, but if it’s going to make my team significantly better next year, I’d at least consider it.

Split on Hedges. Have talked to him a lot about his prep work. I want the young guys here to see and experience that. Of course, why they’re not here is a different discussion.

Dominic Kurn (@KurnDominic): On a scale of 1-10, how worried are you about Roansy Contreras?

Jason Mackey: Hi, Dom. Not very, honestly. I was encouraged that his velocity returned in his last start. It’s not everything, but I think it’s at the root of many fan concerns with Contreras.

I see a pitcher who’s not quite letting it fly the way he used to because he’s thinking too much about his delivery/mechanics. I believe that’s one of the reasons they wanted to give him a spell in the bullpen — to speed up his delivery and allow him to attack, without the pressure and restrictions inherent to being a starter.

Advertise with us

If I had to put a number on it, it’s not above a three or four — only because he tends to struggle with consistent fastball command and doesn’t always have a good plan B when that’s the case.

Bob Carvella (@BCarvella): Is Kyle Schwarber a good comp for Jack Suwinski?

Jason Mackey: Certainly don’t think the Pirates would mind if it worked out that way, Bob.

There are certainly plenty of similarities between Suwinski and Schwarber when it comes to their power and streakiness. I also believe Suwinski is a better defender, though I would rather see him in right and Bae in center.

Let's compare what Suwinski has done thus far with basically the first two seasons of Schwarber, who only played in two games in 2016 before returning for the World Series.

Advertise with us

Schwarber 2015-17: 200 G, .222/.329/.471 (.800 OPS), 46 HR, 70 XBH, 12.6 BB%, 30.0 K%

Suwinski 2022-23: 153 GP, .214/.316/.441 (.757 OPS), 30 HR, 51 XBH, 12.2 BB%, 31.6%

None of this surprises me, honestly. If you gave Suwinski 47 more games at his pace, and especially at Schwarber’s or a blend, the countable numbers would be close.

They’re also Midwest boys who debuted relatively early and didn’t really spend a lot of time in Triple-A. I do think Suwinski could eclipse Schwarber’s .228 career average, but for right now, yeah, that’s a pretty solid comp.

MPZ (@Pens4ev): How much longer until Nick Gonzales, Endy Rodriguez and Quinn Priester get called up with the corresponding releases of Chris Owings, Austin Hedges and Vince Velasquez.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I picked this one to make a couple points.

And I will preface my answer with this: I can’t give you a firm date. Nobody can. But we can look at what will determine when that date might be.

With it being June 2, one factor we have to consider is Super 2 status. Right or wrong, they’ve made it this far. What’s a little longer?

Secondly, opportunity. Tucupita Marcano and Ji Hwan Bae have been very good. I wouldn’t cut bait on Rudy Castro. Shoot, I’d probably play him most days and bounce Bae around.

I wouldn’t expect Gonzales to be up until that changes.

Advertise with us

Similar story with Priester, who had a 1.13 ERA in his first four starts this month but was roughed up (eight runs, six earned in 1 2/3 innings) his last time out. I’m also not moving Mitch Keller, Rich Hill, Johan Oviedo, Luis Ortiz or Roansy Contreras at the moment. They need to pitch.

Lastly, I might consider rotating three catchers, bouncing Rodriguez around the diamond and putting him next to Hedges to learn about game planning and such. At the same time, he's hitting just .234 with a .727 OPS. Don't feel a ton of urgency there.

That said, I can’t imagine Owings is still here on Friday. Velasquez will go on the 60-day injured list but was really good when healthy. Hedges really does add defensive value. They’re also paying him $5 million, so they might as well get something out of it.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.