After Wednesday afternoon’s 3-2 loss to the Texas Rangers, the Pirates find themselves in the same spot they were May 1: still searching for their first series victory of the month.
The defeat dropped the Pirates’ record to 5-15 in May and just one game above .500 at 25-24 overall. The last time the Pirates were one game over even was following an April 4 victory against the Boston Red Sox.
While issues have run aplenty during an altogether miserable month for the Pirates, there are a few spots in particular that have stood out as problematic. To remedy those errors, there are some changes for Pirates manager Derek Shelton to consider.
Start Castro
Despite his drastic splits against left-handed and right-handed pitching, the platooned Rodolfo Castro is in need of more playing time. On Sunday, Castro was penciled into the starting lineup against a right-hander in the Diamondbacks’ Merrill Kelly, marking the first time since May 6 that Shelton had done so.
The switch-hitting second baseman went 1-for-4 on the day but had some excellent swings against a tough starter in Kelly. He ripped a lineout in his first plate appearance and singled in his second, with both balls coming off Castro’s bat at over 100 mph, per Statcast.
Read More
After Wednesday’s game, Castro said he’s been working on making more consistent contact against right-handed pitching. To his point, he’s struck out 23 times in just 64 at-bats against right-handers, including twice in the later innings of Sunday’s game.
But on Wednesday against a lefty in the Rangers’ Martin Perez, Castro went 2-for-4, raising his season-long OPS over .800 despite his poor numbers against righties. When facing lefties this season, Castro has been one of the best hitters in MLB, as evidenced by his 326/.418/.717 slash line with five home runs in 46 at-bats versus southpaws entering Wednesday.
Irregular playing time has started to take a toll on Castro, however. He’s hitting .229 in May as starts at second have come less frequently. Castro, who’s been moved between second and shortstop this season out of necessity with Oneil Cruz out, is hopeful his latest showing against a righty will buoy him to producing better results.
"The work we've been putting in, it's been showing up in the games, either against righties or lefties,” Castro said with major league coach Stephen Morales translating. “I'm just ready. Whenever the call comes, I'll be ready."
Bench for Bae
Of course, if Castro is going to get more starts against right-handers, that’ll mean the other half of the Pirates’ second-base platoon in Ji Hwan Bae will have to sit. Oddly enough, Bae’s splits this season in a small sample size are nontraditional, as the left-handed hitting Bae is hitting .324 against southpaws and .239 versus righties.
By no means has Bae been a bad hitter in May, considering he’s hit .286 overall this month, but his baserunning issues have started to become an issue for the Pirates.
Bae made a couple of costly blunders on the basepaths in the Pirates’ 6-1 loss to the Rangers on Tuesday, first being picked off at first base. He was later gunned down at second after making it halfway to third before retreating too late after an Andrew McCutchen single to right.
The blazing-fast Bae, who got off to a sensational start to the season on the basepaths by converting on 11 of 12 stolen base attempts in April, has now only converted on just three of his last seven tries. It’s all well and good if Bae is getting on base at a solid clip, but that point becomes moot if he’s no longer using his speed effectively.
“I think the biggest homework for me right now is really just reading the situation of the game and knowing when to use my speed and when to not,” Bae said on Tuesday with Daniel Park translating.
Not to mention, Bae and Castro have been relatively equal defenders, each producing minus-1 Outs Above Average (OAA). The unfortunate reality of the platoon for Castro is that Bae is receiving the bulk of the plate appearances and game time. But with the way Castro has shown signs of life against righties and Bae’s recklessness, perhaps Shelton needs to re-evaluate how he divvies up those reps at second base.
More sliders for Stephenson
Reliever Robert Stephenson has crafted a role for himself as one of the Pirates’ main options in the seventh inning as setup man Colin Holderman and closer David Bednar have handled the eighth and ninth innings, respectively. Like many Pirates, Stephenson’s May has been in stark contrast from his April, a month in which he produced a collective six scoreless innings and allowed just three hits.
In May, however, Stephenson has yielded six earned runs in 6 ⅓, including four runs in his previous two outings before Wednesday. Speaking before the matinee game, Stephenson said he found he was getting too predictable on the mound, often throwing outside to right-handed hitters and inside to left-handed ones, an assessment he said that pitching coach Oscar Marin seemed to be on the same page about.
“Oscar kind of agreed with me about being predictable and get back to using my slider just a little bit more heavily,” Stephenson said. “I think that would help, too.”
Shelton called upon the right-hander in the sixth inning of Wednesday’s loss after Johan Oviedo loaded the bases with two outs. To his word, Stephenson used his slider more, spinning it thrice in a row to the Rangers’ Marcus Semien, the last of which produced a strikeout.
“Went right after a really good hitter and was able to get the punchout to keep us in the game,” Shelton said postgame.
While Stephenson has struggled for much of the month, fellow right-hander Dauri Moreta has mostly excelled. After 1 ⅓ scoreless innings on Wednesday, he’s given up just one earned run in 10 ⅔ this month.
With Stephenson burned, Shelton turned to Moreta to finish off the seventh and handle the eighth in the Pirates’ latest loss, raising the question of which reliever the Bucs’ skipper should be reliant on in tight contests before giving the ball to Holderman and Bednar.
Scuffling Suwinski
For as effective as Jack Suwinski has been against right-handers this year, the Pirates’ everyday center fielder has struggled mightily against lefties. An 0-for-4 day against left-handers on Wednesday dropped his batting average to .167 against southpaws this season.
While Suwinski has seven home runs and 20 RBIs against righties, he has no homers and just two runs driven in against lefties. Suwinski fared worse against left-handers last season, too, in his season of drastic splits, hitting just .122 in 2022.
Suwinski’s defense also hasn’t warranted everyday repetitions, considering he’s 30th out of 34 qualifying center fielders for OAA. Although Suwinski’s bat should certainly remain in the lineup against right-handers, Shelton might need to shuffle up his defense a bit, perhaps to give Andrew McCutchen some opportunities in right field again and have somebody else serve as the Pirates’ designated hitter.
Justifiable for Joe
Of course, Suwinski is hardly the only Pirates outfielder who is subject to splits. Connor Joe, a platoon player for much of his career, has played his way into a regular role, thanks in part to injuries (see Ji Man Choi) but also because of his performance.
Joe cooled a bit in May, his batting average in the month sitting at .220 before going 1 for 2 with a walk and hit by pitch on Wednesday. He hasn’t been able to tap into his power terribly much, either, homering just once this month after going yard four times in April.
Still, Shelton has frequently penciled in Joe in right field regardless of who is on the mound for the opposition. While Joe has better stats overall in his career against left-handers, he’s hit a respectable .238 in 10 home runs in 474 at-bats versus righties in MLB.
Not to mention, Joe also seems to have turned a corner, having recorded hits in three straight games and batting .375 during his last seven games, perhaps warranting the extended opportunities he’s received as of late in the outfield to continue.
Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and Twitter @AndrewDestin1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.