“The Pirates are a young team.”

It’s the convenient caveat that critics of general manager Ben Cherington’s regime are given any time they point out the team’s shortcomings. Bad results are dismissed at the altar of potential. Good results — however limited — are held up as proof that we’re just around the corner from player development carrying the club to the promised land.

But at the season’s quarter pole, “young team” is not a fair characterization of what the Pirates actually are, especially when you narrow the focus onto the guys who’ve meaningfully contributed to the team’s better-than-expected — albeit wildly inconsistent — 22-20 start.

Entering play Monday, the average age of a Pirates hitter was 26.3 and the average age of their pitchers was 27.3. On paper, that certainly fits the profile of a young team, as the hitters are the second-youngest group in MLB while the pitchers rank third-youngest.

Advertise with us

In practice, the encouraging record is propped up almost entirely by hot starts from veteran names including Bryan Reynolds, Connor Joe, Andrew McCutchen and Mitch Keller. Yes, there are young players technically on the roster, dragging its average age down. But very few of them are producing.

Through Monday, just two qualifying hitters under the age of 28 — Jack Suwinski and Rodolfo Castro — had OPS marks of .700 or better.

That’s it. Everyone else is dealing with something. An extensive injury in the case of Oneil Cruz. Inconsistency in the cases of Ke’Bryan Hayes and Ji-Hwan Bae, who have OPS marks in the .600 range. Or a lack of meaningful at-bats in the case of Tucupita Marcano, who has a .752 OPS mark in 64 plate appearances.

On the pitching side, 23-year-old Roansy Contreras is the only qualifying starter under 27 with an ERA below the 5.00 mark, and he just barely qualifies at 4.40. And Jose Hernandez is the only qualifying reliever in that category. Cody Bolton and Luis Ortiz have thrown fewer than 10 innings each.

That’s a total of four young players one can reasonably argue are producing on the positive side of the ledger, with Hayes and Bae treading water thanks to the value they add with defense and base running, respectively.

Advertise with us

Of course, it is still fairly early. The sample sizes are small enough that a one-week hot streak from a young player could vault them into productive status.

Already, however, positive labels of the Pirates as a plucky young team have started to stick. But the plain truth is that this team does not stack up well even with the 2019 Pirates, who got general manager Neal Huntington fired for being too old and too stale.

That group had Reynolds, Jose Osuna, Josh Bell, Kevin Newman and Colin Moran with OPS marks of .750 or better. All four were 26 or younger. If we lower the bar to a .600 OPS, we can add Cole Tucker to the list. And on the pitching side Kyle Crick, Joe Musgrove, Dario Agrazal and Michael Feliz were pitchers 26 and younger with ERAs under 5.00.

That’s a total of nine young players who made real contributions, nearly double what today’s Pirates are getting from Cherington’s roster that’s being sold as some kind of youth movement.

Granted, the 2019 group played 162 games while the 2023 team has played 42. Prospects will be promoted to the big club over the course of the year and have chances to make an impact. Guys like Endy Rodriguez, Quinn Priester and Henry Davis could easily assert themselves by September and make the numbers look more healthy.

Advertise with us

But that possibility doesn’t make the Pirates’ principal contributors any younger today.

Not to put too fine a point on it, but Cherington was sold to Pirates fans as a builder instrumental in the success of the 2018 Red Sox — who won the World Series with four guys 25 and younger in their lineup — and the Toronto Blue Jays of more recent vintage, who made the 2020 playoffs with a lineup that had six guys age 26 or younger.

Four years later, he isn’t fielding a team that looks anything like those. It’s not old overall, but it’s old where it matters — in the regular lineup and in the vast majority of innings thrown.

That’s not a great sign for a franchise that subjected its fan base to the equivalent of three 100-loss seasons in the name of building a young foundation.

That puts pressure on guys like Rodriguez, Davis and Priester to perform when they arrive. Because what’s already here isn’t adding up to much so far.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.