With every swing Henry Davis takes at Double-A Altoona — many of them incredibly powerful hacks that have resulted in baseballs traveling a long way at fast speeds — the Pirates inch closer to a catching crossroads.

It’s a good problem to have, to be sure.

Between Davis and Endy Rodriguez, two of their top three prospects are catchers. At a premium position, they have two guys who will almost assuredly impact the major league club this season. But an important decision nonetheless looms.

At present, Davis and Rodriguez — who are actually good friends — are separated. The thought process behind doing this was simple: The Pirates wanted both to play. A lot.

Advertise with us

“These guys need to catch every day,” Pirates director of coaching and player development John Baker said Tuesday at PNC Park. “They’re gonna impact Pittsburgh in the not-too-distant future.”

What the Pirates did here isn’t dumb.

Davis and Rodriguez are plenty talented, but they’ve struggled with consistently keeping balls in front of them, accuracy on throws down to second and the nuance of calling a game. Normal stuff for catching prospects, honestly, facets that experience can address.

They’ve also improved.

That should be music to Pirates fans’ ears, especially given the team’s recent offensive downturn. While losing eight of nine prior to Wednesday’s series finale, the Pirates amassed just 12 runs while hitting .179 and striking out 82 times. They were batting just .125 with runners in scoring position during that time.

Advertise with us

Like many things, though, it’s not as simple as bringing the hot-hitting prospect up to the major leagues and counting on that player to turn it around. There are steps. Important steps. Especially with this particular discussion.

Start with the Pirates’ move to split Davis and Rodriguez. Back then, the idea was that the two stud prospects would inform the organization how this should ultimately go. If you look close enough, well, they pretty much have.

Rodriguez, who’s probably the best pure hitter among Pirates prospects, has battled a cranky right elbow. Davis, meanwhile, has flat-out mashed Double-A pitching, like someone dropped him in a junior varsity game.

Entering play Wednesday, Davis was tops among all Double-A players with a 1.175 OPS and had reached base safely in 20 of 21 games. Looking specifically at the Eastern League, he was tied for second in home runs with eight — including two more Tuesday — plus tied for sixth in RBIs (17), first in on-base percentage (.464) and first in slugging (.711).

“Henry likes to make things really difficult, for sure,” Baker said, smiling. “He’s swung the bat so well. He’s run the bases so well. And his catching has improved. I think that’s the toughest part.”

Advertise with us

The solution here is actually simple: The Pirates must better test Davis’ bat and advance his development by promoting him to Triple-A. In doing so, they ultimately need to pick a primary catcher between the two — which, again, should be Davis.

Not because Rodriguez isn’t good. Far from it, actually. He’s incredibly athletic and can play first base, second and some outfield. The 22-year-old loves to catch, for its every-pitch action and how it requires him to bring the most out of pitchers. But this decision should really be about aligning the Pirates in the best way possible for the future.

It’s also nothing that needs to be set in stone. Rodriguez will catch some. Just not as much as Davis.

The strategy is actually really smart, in that the Pirates can leverage the backup catcher spot on a roster into more than a Chris Stewart-sized offensive black hole. More practically speaking, they can play Davis five times a week, Rodriguez twice and find something else for Endy to do in the interim.

But as silly and obvious as this sounds, when Davis and Rodriguez inevitably arrive, they can’t both catch. Someone must either serve as the designated hitter and likely play another position. So why not have that player be the most athletic of the two ... and the one who has experienced a scare with his throwing arm while playing every day?

Advertise with us

Where to put Rodriguez outside of catcher shouldn’t be hard. Pittsburgh’s primary first baseman, Carlos Santana, is 37 and on an expiring contract. Their top two minor league options, Malcom Nunez and Mason Martin, have struggled to match consistent contact with occasional power.

Second base could be an option, perhaps bumping Rodolfo Castro to first, but the Pirates also must be mindful of Nick Gonzales, Termarr Johnson and other potential second-base prospects behind Rodriguez.

Bottom line, as Davis obliterates pitching that’s seemingly below his level, Rodriguez (.260 average, .760 OPS and three homers in 19 games) works to rediscover a level that was among MiLB’s best last season and the Pirates (hopefully) assess the need for reinforcements, it’s important to plant seeds in the proper spots.

That doesn’t include Davis at Double-A and will inevitably mean committing to one over the other behind the plate.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.