The Pirates are coming up on the quarter pole of their season, so now seems like a good time to identify some of the team’s analytic trends that have developed so far and analyze what they might mean moving forward. Here’s a look at four players you should monitor in the weeks ahead. Note: All numbers are accurate through Monday’s games.
Connor Joe — It’s the question that matters more for this team than pretty much any other right now. Can this former first-round pick — who was once unceremoniously dumped only to return to Pittsburgh as a grizzled veteran — continue putting up borderline MVP-caliber numbers? If he can, the Pirates really might be in business in 2023. If he can’t, then the team around him will likely fade from its hot start, as well. One key number suggests the answer is no. Batting average on balls in play, or BABIP, typically hovers around .300 for most players, regardless of skill level. Anything dramatically above or below that number suggests a player is either luckier or unluckier than average. And as you might have guessed, Joe is way over .300 at .375. That implies he’s enjoyed quite a bit of luck and will see his numbers fade as he regresses closer to .300 over a larger sample size. However, not everything under the analytics hood is bad. Joe has made noticeable changes to his approach since returning to the Pirates. Specifically, he’s become a lot more patient. His O-swing percentage, which measures swings at pitches outside the strike zone that tend to lead to less favorable outcomes for hitters, is at a career-low 18.3%. And that discipline has led directly to harder contact. His hard contact rate entering Tuesday stands at a career-high 40%, while his soft contact rate is coincidentally at 18.3%, as well. Add it all up and Joe seems destined for some regression. But if he stays as choosy with his pitches as he’s been to this point, Pirates fans have reason to hope that regression won’t resemble him falling off the proverbial cliff.
Roansy Contreras — The prized 23-year-old starter has been all over the place so far in 2023. In his six starts, he’s allowed two earned runs or fewer four times but four runs or more twice. That includes a seven-run outing against Houston on April 10. And two key stats point to things remaining bumpy from here. The first is his extremely low home run to fly ball ratio of just 2.6%. That is unsustainably low. It is inevitable that he will regress to something closer to his 8.6% career mark between the majors and the minors at some point. When that happens, his bottomline numbers will almost certainly get noticeably worse. That’s evident in his 5.15 xFIP, a stat that predicts ERA based on outcomes a pitcher can control independent of defense, such as strikeouts and walks, plus his expected home run rate. Contreras’ walk rate also isn’t helping either. Right now, he’s giving free bases at a rate of 4.36 per nine innings. That’s a career high between the majors and minors and is a dangerous trend when paired with the home run rates because the only thing worse than home run regression is home run regression with a surplus of runners on base. Contreras needs to find the strike zone soon or things could get ugly quickly when the homers finally start coming at a more regular rate.
Carlos Santana — The hope when the Pirates signed this 13-year veteran in the offseason was that baseball’s ban on the infield shift as we’d come to know it in recent years would benefit him as a heavy pull hitter. Fewer infielders on the right side would lead to more of his batted balls sneaking through for hits. And that’s exactly what we’ve seen so far. Santana’s BABIP has surged from .209 a year ago and .227 in 2021 to .309 in 2023, putting him much, much closer to the league average. As a result, his numbers have become quite useful again. His .345 on-base percentage is only slightly lower than his career average of .359. And his .267 batting average is more than 20 points better than his career number of .243. The Pirates would certainly like to see a bit more pop in his game. His isolated power rate — which measures hits for extra bases by subtracting batting average from slugging percentage — currently sits near career-lows at .149. But in general, their thesis has proven correct. Santana does have production left in his bat when opponents can’t position themselves to stop him like they used to.
Vince Velasquez — Not to be too much of a bummer about the Pirates’ pitching staff, but this 30-year-old free agent signing seems primed to take a step back from his sparkling 3.06 ERA, as well. Like Contreras, he’s thus far enjoyed a home run rate of 7.3% that’s well below his career average of 14.1%. His strand rate of 80.5% is well above his career average of 71.5%. And his ground ball rate is down to 29.7%, a career low compared to a lifetime number of 35.4%. Throw in a BABIP of .258 that’s probably 40 points lower than where it will even out and the numbers he’s posted to this point look pretty unsustainable, though the size of the coming step back is debatable. His hard contact percentage is down to 26.1% compared to a career average of 36.8%. If he can maintain those rates, that should help with the coming homer regression. And his slider is really working well so far. Fangraphs gives it a pitch value — which measures the runs the pitch saves above average — of 6.7 compared to a career value of minus-11.3. So whatever adjustments pitching coach Oscar Marin has made there are definitely working. Altogether, an ERA closer to the upper threes or lower fours seems like the proper middle ground between his current numbers and his 4.61 xFIP.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.