A second opinion could only hold off the inevitable for JT Brubaker for so long.

On Thursday, the Pirates’ right-hander spoke with reporters for the first time since Dr. Keith Meister performed reconstructive surgery on his ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) on April 12. A secondary assessment confirmed that getting Tommy John surgery was the correct course of action for Brubaker, whose latest ailment was separate from the UCL injury he suffered back in 2019.

When he went down with an elbow injury four years ago, Brubaker got a platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injection, which he credits for helping him already get 61 starts in the big leagues under his belt.

“It’s hard to say if I had [Tommy John] surgery back in 2019, would I be where I am today?” Brubaker said. “It’s a question that can’t really be answered. I’m extremely grateful that the PRP worked because I am where I am today. I had gotten three years of experience in the big leagues and it’s helped me to become the pitcher that I am and it helps me to learn to continue to be a better pitcher than what I currently am.”

Advertise with us

Brubaker, who sported a nifty brace on his right arm that prevents him from overextending it, will hang in Pittsburgh for the time being to do his rehab. He’ll wear the arm brace for six weeks.

Beyond that, nothing much is set in stone for the right-hander who could miss 14-16 months with his first Tommy John surgery. After Brubaker got the PRP injection in 2019, he spent time around Pirates pitchers recovering from their respective Tommy John surgeries like Chad Kuhl and Jameson Taillon, an experience he’ll lean upon as he embarks on his own journey.

“When I rehabbed with Chad when he went through it, it’s kind of like a mentor without being a mentor,” Brubaker said. “I watched how he went about, how he did his stuff, his throwing program because he was at the point of building up from his TJ. So I didn’t get to really see much of the beginning process of the rehab. I kind of got an idea of how he went about it to handle mentally, body feeling-wise, in that throwing aspect when you start to throw.”

Brubaker is certainly a long way from beginning to throw, but that doesn’t mean he can’t still impact the club. Manager Derek Shelton, who had chatted and texted with Brubaker ahead of his surgery, was appreciative of his presence in the dugout earlier in the season, which he assumes will continue for most home games.

“It's important,” Shelton said. “During the last series here, there were a couple of times that he picked up some things that were important just by sitting on the bench. So I'm happy that he's here, and it's good to see him in good spirits.”

Advertise with us

The vantage point Brubaker will have from his couch for Pirates road games will be different from his usual perch at PNC Park, though. The behind-the-pitcher view of his own team’s hurlers on TV isn’t one he’s unfamiliar with but something he’s usually had after games rather than during them.

“You get more of an advantage to watch it and be able to see stuff in real time instead of having to wait for it to be looked at, go back and look at it on your iPad,” Brubaker said. “So to be able to break down a game is a bonus.”

Brubaker has yet to reach out to either Shelton or pitching coach Oscar Marin during games to share his thoughts, which he credited in part to the Pirates starters holding up on their end lately and then some. Pirates starters have produced nine straight quality starts, including Johan Oviedo’s six innings of one-run ball on Wednesday.

“They’re going out there, they’re dominating. They’re attacking hitters,” Brubaker said. “Right now, it’s just texting them, ‘Hey, keep doing you. You’re looking great.’ More of a morale, pat on the back, just trying to be like I would be there in the dugout.”

Limited to these kinds of shows of support until he can start rehabbing down in Bradenton, there’s no question this will be a trying time for Brubaker, who showed flashes during spring training in anticipation of what could have been a breakout season for him.

Advertise with us

Instead, fresh off Tommy John, Brubaker will have to put on hold what he aspired to accomplish this season, lessons in hand that he hopes will come to him naturally once he’s cleared to go.

“The stuff that I did in spring and everything, I think I’ve ingrained that into my mind enough to where it’s like when I do start throwing or off the mound, that type of attack and mentality that I was carrying in spring and in the games will still be there,” Brubaker said. “It’ll be more building confidence, building the arm back up when I get to that stage. That’s where I’m gonna have to really grasp and trust that this process is gonna be long and that the arm is healing.

Around the diamond

Speaking through translator Daniel Park, Ji-Man Choi said he hasn’t heard anything specific yet regarding his rehab process for returning from the left Achilles strain that landed him on the 10-day injured list.

Right-hander and set-up man Colin Holderman, who did not take the mound in any of the Pirates’ victories over the Rockies after pitching thrice against the Cardinals, said the team simply wanted to rest him in the Mile High City.

Advertise with us

“I was available the last day in Colorado, but we were up and it was an extra [day of rest] that I appreciate and definitely will take early in the season because you’re not going to get those later on,” Holderman said. “There was nothing behind it, just a little bit of rest.”

Andrew Destin: adestin@post-gazette.com and Twitter @AndrewDestin1.