BOSTON — It’s nothing personal against Austin Hedges, whose health is obviously the most important thing at play here. After placing Hedges on the seven-day concussion injured list Tuesday, the Pirates catcher was in Pittsburgh’s cramped Fenway Park clubhouse, chatting with teammates and coaches. As concussions go, the prognosis looks good.
It’s also nothing against Tyler Heineman, who’s a perfectly serviceable defensive option, fared well with those numbers in 2022 and had his contract selected from Triple-A Indianapolis to take Hedges’ spot on the active roster.
No, this discussion runs deeper, much deeper. And while it’s a little surprising we’re having it this early, the presence of Endy Rodriguez — or in this case, the absence of him — was always going to be a storyline this season.
So, Pirates manager Derek Shelton, with the need for a healthy catcher on the active roster, why not promote Rodriguez, the Pirates’ top prospect per Baseball America and someone that publication considers the 22nd-best in all of Major League Baseball?
“I think it's a good question. I think it's a fair question,” Shelton said. “Response would be that over the last three years, he's caught 120 games and we need this guy to catch. Even last year, he caught like 70, 75 games. He needs the experience behind the plate.”
It’s not what the fanbase wants to hear, but there’s some truth to what Shelton is saying. For anyone who watched Rodriguez during spring training, especially drill work at Pirate City, no, he’s not ready.
Read More
His throwing was highly inconsistent, the same for his blocking. It’s hardly a knock against his physical talents, which are obvious: the rocket arm, the athleticism and a ton of power at the plate. But even the best players require some refinement, and we’re talking about someone who had a whopping six games at Triple-A prior to the season starting.
It’s OK to say that guy needs to catch and that those reps don’t need to happen in major league stadiums with major league ramifications.
Rodriguez is also just 22. His understanding of the sheer volume of preparation required for an MLB game is still developing, as it would be for anyone his age. It’s also a balancing act between wanting him to not feel overwhelmed on the defensive side while simultaneously wanting to bring out what he does so well: hit.
“Especially to come up here and handle the pitching staff, he needs the reps,” Shelton said. “We just felt, in the short term, it's not fair to him to do that. It's why he's catching primarily in Indianapolis this year and not bouncing around as much as he has."
Here’s the other thing about the Pirates, Rodriguez and roster construction: They need to know whether he should stick at the position. If he crushes the ball, they sure wouldn’t be the first team to move a catcher elsewhere, prioritizing the protection of an asset. That decision will come much easier if Rodriguez struggles over a high volume of games at Triple-A.
Those who disagree with what the Pirates are doing — which feels like the majority of the fan base — also have a valid point. The Pirates need offense, and Rodriguez (.997 OPS in 2022, fifth-highest in all of MiLB) would almost assuredly provide a boost. His abilities were also evident while hitting .412 in 10 games this spring.
It’s not the decision the Pirates had to make before selecting Heineman, but a solid argument could be made to promote Rodriguez and have him work alongside Hedges, who’s outstanding when it comes to understanding the nuance of blocking, pitch framing, throwing, controlling the running game and preparation.
There isn’t a young catcher alive who couldn’t learn a bunch from being around Hedges, and the Pirates could find ways to keep Rodriguez by bouncing him around to other spots. It would build positional versatility that could come in handy should the Pirates need to divide reps between Rodriguez and Henry Davis.
Those who want to see Rodriguez now are also quick to point out the business side of baseball, where delaying Rodriguez’s arrival two weeks or so ensures an additional year of team control and keeping him in the minors for two months and change avoids any potential Super-2 issues.
Not accusing the Pirates of doing anything nefarious, but it’s certainly convenient timing-wise for Rodriguez to need a little more seasoning.
Bottom line: The argument here will probably continue, even if/when Hedges returns and regardless of whether Heineman can find some offensive traction. He hit .211 with a .531 OPS in 52 games last season with the Pirates, then struggled to match those numbers in spring, hitting .136 in 11 games.
“I’m just trying to be stubborn to my plan,” Heineman said. “You see the best guys in the world — they’re stubborn to their plan. I’m trying to be somewhere around there and do the best that I can.”
Ironically, he’s not alone with that line of thinking.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.