What started as a position the Pirates thought they addressed last offseason by signing Yoshi Tsutsugo to a $4 million contract ended with a resounding thud — one of the only loud noises anyone heard over at first base in 2022.
“We’d like to get more production,” general manager Ben Cherington said earlier this month. “We need to find more production. Don’t know what that’s going to look like. Not saying there aren’t guys here already that could be part of that, but it’s an area we’d like to add in the offseason. We’ll look at all kinds of options, I’m sure.”
It’s stating the obvious, sure, but it’s also a sizable item on the Pirates’ offseason to-do list: However it happens — internal, external or talking Clu Haywood out of retirement — they must get something from that position.
Anything beats the negative-3 Wins Above Replacement that group achieved per FanGraphs, by far the lowest among 30 clubs. Or the 59 wRC+ — where 100 represents the MLB average.
So, what now? Let’s examine the Pirates’ options.
On the inside
Read More
Among guys who spent time with the MLB club in 2022, there’s not much. Michael Chavis is gone. Diego Castillo isn’t moving the needle. It’s a waste of Oneil Cruz’s arm to use him there. Perhaps Rodolfo Castro could do it, but that’s hardly a sure thing, especially from a defensive standpoint.
A more realistic option — though not preferred — would be to consider first base a proving ground for prospects.
Malcolm Nunez, acquired from St. Louis in the Jose Quintana/Chris Stratton deal, is a converted third baseman with pop. He finished 2022 with 23 home runs and 88 RBIs in 119 games across three levels, including one in five games for Triple-A Indianapolis. He likely won’t be ready to start, but he also might not be a long way off.
Blake Sabol, meanwhile, hit .284/.363/.497 with 19 home runs in 513 plate appearances. His strikeout rate (25.1%) was a tad high, though the USC product’s 124 wRC+ in 98 Double-A games was plenty palatable. Catcher, first and outfield are all positions Sabol has played, and catcher might be occupied by some combination of Endy Rodriguez and Henry Davis.
Speaking of Rodriguez, he’ll be in Pittsburgh in 2023. The question is where. First base probably isn’t his best or most natural position, but it also might be where the Pirates can best stash his bat, which produced monster numbers in 2022 across three levels.
In 125 games, Rodriguez hit .323 with a .996 OPS. He filled out the stat sheet with 25 home runs, 60 walks, 92 runs, 39 doubles, four triples and 95 RBIs. Rodriguez’s 1.181 OPS from July until the end of the season was the highest in the minor leagues.
But if Rodriguez better fills a need at second base or corner outfield, the Pirates could also turn to Jared Triolo, another converted third baseman. A Gold Glover there in the minor leagues, Triolo is probably blocked by Ke’Bryan Hayes.
He also started slow, dropped off the prospect radar, then finished with a flurry, producing an .878 OPS and 140 wRC+ from June through the end of the season while playing for Double-A Altoona. Triolo walks a lot, has reduced his strikeouts and has the bigger frame that teams often covet. The defensive side of things could be really smooth.
The final one worth considering is Mason Martin. Earlier this season, he was a source of extreme excitement; however, he finished his Triple-A Indianapolis season with a .210 average, .696 OPS, 19 home runs, 77 RBIs and 194 strikeouts in 541 plate appearances.
That’s too many, obviously, but Martin is still only 23. He could still improve.
On the outside
Here’s where the Pirates should look ... and where fans are understandably expecting to go with this position. Signing someone starts here, and the good news is that there are enough available options.
Most realistic for the Pirates given how they (don’t) spend and who might actually be willing to come here could be Carlos Santana, whose surface-level numbers this past season weren’t great: .202/.316/.376 in 131 games, a .692 OPS, 19 home runs and 60 RBIs.
Santana makes sense for a couple of reasons. He’s coming off a two-year, $17.5 million contract, and considering his recent production, it’s probably hard to expect a raise when he’ll turn 37 in April.
At the same time, Santana has been a terrific clubhouse guy, had a positive influence this season in Seattle and tends to see a lot of pitches, a skill very much valued by this Pirates regime.
Santana’s walk rate was in the 97th percentile, per Statcast. Meanwhile, his strikeout rate was in the 74th percentile, his whiff rate in the 71st and his chase in the 87th. He also hit the ball hard, as evidenced by his 90.7 mph average exit velocity (81st percentile).
The issue: Nobody saw more shifts than Santana (98.3% of the time), and he became a predictable out. With the shift banned in 2023, it might be a chance to get a player at a discount, a guy with a solid track record who could help guide a young group.
Other intriguing options include Jesus Aguilar (35 home runs, 108 RBIs in 2018), along with Houston’s Yuli Gurriel. Given the Astros’ success, it might be pie-in-the-sky stuff, but we’re talking about someone who won the American League batting title in 2021 by hitting .319 and won a Gold Glove.
This season, Gurriel — who will turn 39 in June — regressed to the tune of hitting .242 with a .648 OPS in 146 games. Could the Pirates pounce? If the price is right, they should.
But there’s no better possibility than Santana, who would be a terrific mentor for fellow Dominicans Cruz and Castro. Considering Santana has been worth just 1.0 bWAR over the past two seasons, he might’ve fallen into their price range.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.