With the designated hitter finally in the National League on a full-time basis, the Pirates enjoyed a rare luxury: They had someone in Daniel Vogelbach who handled the job extremely well. Using primarily Vogelbach in that spot, Pirates DHs had a .769 OPS, which was good enough for third in the NL prior to Friday’s game.
They also led the league in walk rate (14.4%) while producing a weighted runs created plus (wRC+) — an all-encompassing stat where 100 is considered league average — of 118, trailing only the Bryce Harper-led Phillies.
Now, the calculus has changed. Vogelbach is a member of the Mets, and the Pirates must figure out how to best handle the DH.
“We'll have to look at it,” manager Derek Shelton said. “But I don't think we've decided anything right away.”
The Pirates have a few options, though none of them will be like Vogelbach, who didn’t offer much in the field but took his four plate appearances per game extremely seriously. Most helpful, he didn’t need the diversion of defense to balance out his brain — a mentality or routine that plagued Josh Bell and Colin Moran in that role during the DH’s cameo in 2020.
Finding a new DH is also complicated by the poor performance of Yoshi Tsutsugo, who was signed for $4 million this offseason but has hit just .173 with a .500 OPS, his most recent woes creating the legitimate question of not whether the Pirates should DH him but whether they should designate Tsutsugo for assignment and move on.
Read More
Before he made his 2022 season debut, it was believed Oneil Cruz might benefit from some time in that spot, easing the defensive load on the young shortstop, but thus far his fielding has been far from the biggest concern.
Keep digging, and the Pirates don’t really have a steady option. The best they can probably count on is that position adding additional roster flexibility, a spot to stash another young bat or a way to offer rest for regulars such as Bryan Reynolds (when he returns from an oblique injury) or Ke’Bryan Hayes.
“I’m not too sure what they’ll do,” Hayes said. “We’ll probably do a platoon of righties and lefties. It’s a bummer losing [Vogelbach]. He’s a middle-of-the-order guy. You know what you’re going to get out of him every day.”
The look of the Pirates’ lineup will be changing independent of the DH spot, too.
Before Friday’s game, Greg Allen did not have a locker in the Pirates clubhouse. He did postgame, and he was also technically active for the contest against the Marlins, though Allen did not make it to Pittsburgh from Indianapolis in time.
One would imagine he’ll be there for Saturday’s game. The arrival of Colin Holderman will likely bump out a pitcher, too.
Allen, a speedy outfielder who seemingly nailed down a starting job in spring, only to have hamstring issues disrupt his season, has hit .429 with a 1.286 OPS in four rehab games with the Indians and will almost assuredly get a look before the MLB trade deadline.
Reynolds should also return in the coming days, meaning it could be those two, plus Ben Gamel and Jake Marisnick in the outfield rotation. Trading Gamel would seemingly hasten the return of Jack Suwinski, who homered twice for Class AAA Indianapolis on Friday.
For his part, Gamel isn’t thinking that he could be next.
“I've been traded a few times,” Gamel said. “It’s nothing I can control, so I try to eliminate the noise and just go out and play.”
Filling the DH has other ripple effects, too. If they do try Tsutsugo there, Michael Chavis would become the regular first baseman, which is probably the best alignment from a defensive standpoint. If that happened — or if the Pirates DFA Tsutsugo — they would likely search for more first-base depth.
That could mean Bligh Madris continuing to learn the position or, if he gets hot, Mason Martin getting a shot, though he hasn’t done much to earn the chance: a .136 average, three home runs and 59 strikeouts in 135 plate appearances (43.7%) over his last 36 games.
Martin also isn’t defensively deficient or anything like that; the inconsistent offense and crazy amount of swing and miss is a much larger concern.
Bottom line, the Pirates need not create the picture-perfect version of the DH that they had with Vogelbach. Given their personnel, that’s impossible. They don’t have a true DH on their roster.
But what they have are players like Suwinski, Ji-hwan Bae, Madris and even Travis Swaggerty — prospects who should get a chance in the second half, in Bae’s case an initial opportunity to produce in the big leagues.
There’s simply no reason for veteran players who aren’t part of the franchise’s future to play every day, save for Hayes, Reynolds and Gamel, if he’s here.
The Pirates should use the newfound lineup spot to get creative, to turn things over to some younger players and allow them to show what they can do, much like a couple weeks ago when injuries provided a more substantive opportunity.
In the meantime, the loss of Vogelbach will surely be felt.
“He’s into every at-bat,” general manager Ben Cherington said of Vogelbach. “He’s into every pitch. He loves the game. Studies pitchers and is always talking about that.
“The really good offenses I’ve been around have a lot of that in the clubhouse, in the dugout, just talking about hitting, talking about the pitcher that you’re trying to beat. That’s something ‘Vogey’ did a lot of. Hopefully it rubs off. You need that on a good team.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.