DENVER — In theory, the Pirates would like Jack Suwinski to follow Cal Mitchell’s lead.
Mitchell was optioned to Class AAA Indianapolis back at the end of June after scuffling in 26 MLB games. He immediately went on a tear, recording hits in 11 of his 12 games back in the minors, and now, he’s back. Mitchell is replacing Suwinski on the big league roster, with the Pirates optioning Suwinski on the heels of an 0-for-29 streak at the plate.
One would think Suwinski’s demotion would not be anything close to permanent. After all, he’s the rookie home run leader in the National League, socking 14 dingers in his time with the Pirates. That’s actually the second-best mark on the team.
For some, that will serve as reason Suwinski should have been given more leash in MLB. The Pirates, clearly, view it differently, perhaps believing Suwinski has shown enough value in the majors that he shouldn’t be left to struggle when there is a conceivable alternative route. The last thing the Pirates need is to Suwinski to change a bunch of things and lose what made him special in the first place.
“Jack’s really important to us,” manager Derek Shelton said Friday in Denver. “He’s a good player, and he’s going to be a good player for us, but it’s important for us to let him get his bearings underneath him a little bit. He started to tinker with things a little bit mechanically, and we need to make sure he stays solid.”
Mitchell, of all people, understands what Suwinski is going through. While he can only really speak to his own experience, the Pirates will hope it tracks with Suwinski as well.
Read More
“For sure, everyone wants to get to the big leagues and stay forever,” Mitchell said. “There were a couple of different realities that got me sent down. I took a second to be upset, naturally, but only a second. Just continued to use the tools that I have in Indy to help me understand that phase of baseball that’s new to me and how to come out of that successfully. I’m glad that I was able to do well and get back up here.”
For his own part, Mitchell’s goal now is to make this call-up a long-term stay. As frustrating as the first one went, when he slashed .193/.227/.325 in 26 appearances, he does feel like he learned some valuable lessons.
That manifested in the minors. Mitchell emphasizes the game is relatively similar to him in Class AAA and MLB, but he still felt more equipped to handle that level after testing the big leagues for himself.
Now that he’s back up, he also feels more prepared.
“Deep breaths are important. Deep breaths are definitely important,” Mitchell said with a smile. “You’ve got to make sure to take those, recognize moments where they feel big or they might feel like it’s catching up to you, just to recognize that moment and slow myself down.
“There’s some nerves involved, of course. New team, new guys, do I know the signs? All of it. At least I’m a little bit acclimated now with the time I had.”
In addition to the more high-profile outfield situation, the Pirates activated catcher Tyler Heineman from the family medical emergency list before Friday’s game, optioning catcher Michael Perez to make room on the active roster.
Perez’s option is a sneakily surprising move. The catcher, who spent all of last season with the Pirates, never really got his feet under him in 2022. He did have a jaw-dropping, three-homer game, but the Pirates opted to keep rookie catcher Jason Delay on the roster instead of Perez. To be fair, that might be warranted, considering Delay has hit .292 with a .737 OPS in 10 games this season.
“It shows you that we feel really strongly about how Jason Delay’s caught the baseball,” Shelton said. “He’s done a really nice job, he’s executed at the plate, got some big hits for us and just thought he deserved a little longer runway to continue catching here.”
Heineman, on the other hand, returns to the roster having impressed with his defensive capabilities. The Pirates will have to decide how to juggle the rotation there, though Delay’s right-handed bat mixed with Heineman’s switch-hitting abilities could make it more of a straight platoon.
Around the horn
Left-hander Cam Alldred was added to the taxi squad for this trip and left-hander Eric Stout was sent to Indianapolis.
Alldred appeared in one game for the Pirates earlier this season, tossing a scoreless inning with one strikeout. In the minors, he’s continued tearing it up, with a 2.72 ERA in 39 2/3 innings, walking just 12 batters. Alldred was designated for assignment on May 24 to clear a 40-man roster spot for Mitchell, who was needed at the time with designated hitter Daniel Vogelbach hitting the injured list.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.