Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. Thanks for stopping by. We'll get started here shortly.
Jason Mackey: OK, let's get going ...
The Real TP Hunter: Hi Jason. Sorry you couldn't pull out a game 7 win for the Penguins while you were moonlighting. I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I believe in the past you suggested that Sidney Crosby might have been a very competent baseball player. Is there anyone on the Pirates of the present or recent past who you think might have been a good hockey player?
Jason Mackey: Ahhh ... a fun question to start. Yes. Thank you. ... Not a player, but I know Ben Cherington has played a decent amount of hockey. Player-wise, I could maybe see Suwinski -- a Chicago kid -- being good on skates. Maybe Ben Gamel, although he's from Florida and probably isn't much for ice. ... I also wonder how David Bednar would fare as a stay-at-home, thumping defenseman. Probably not terrible. And can you imagine how tall Oneil Cruz would be on skates? Love it.
The Real TP Hunter: Just one other hockey question if I may. Did you cover the last game that the Penguins Big Three will play together?
Jason Mackey: I hope not, but yeah, I think I probably did. I think Letang or Malkin could be back, in somewhat of a surprise, but I don't know how either returns. Doesn't make sense for either party.
Read More
The Real TP Hunter: As for baseball, what's with nobody hitting? I know the answer is there isn't much talent there, but is it time to start worrying about Hayes and Reynolds yet?
Jason Mackey: Hayes, no. He's been fine. Reynolds ... we're getting there. My general rule is June. If a guy is still awful in June, I think it's kind of hard to ignore. As for whether I'm actually worried about Reynolds, no, I'm not. Maybe I'm nuts, but I really do think he's gonna be fine.
The Real TP Hunter: The Steelers are expanding their museum at Heinz Field. Wouldn't it be appropriate for the Pirates to have a similar display at PNC? Old timers know the rich history of Pirates baseball, but maybe the newer fans would benefit from learning more of the team's heralded past. For a very long time, the Pirates and Pitt football were the big boys in town.
Jason Mackey: They are doing that. That's part of why Jim Trdinich -- their longtime/exemplary PR man -- is moving to a new role. I've talked to Jimmy about his plans for this and how cool he wants to make it. I think fans are gonna be thrilled when it starts to come together.
Sammy Khalifa: Do you think that there are any infielders besides Hayes currently on the 40 man roster better than me.
Jason Mackey: I know you're kind of being a wise guy, but that question got my creative juices flowing.
PrinceBob: How does money work in AAA? Is there a scale? Is a guy like Michael Perez who's had a fair amount of time in the majors but is on a minor league contract get paid differently than guys who have never or very rarely been in the majors?
Jason Mackey: I think it works the same as it does here. Pennies, nickels, dimes, quarters, bills. I don't know about NFTs, sorry. ... No, seriously. Guys with MLB time can make more than your run-of-the-mill minor leaguer; that said, it's not much. Still ridiculously low. Not like Perez was making anywhere close to what he is now while he was in the minors.
PrinceBob: And if an MLB player who is out of options get a minor league contract have options again because he's on a minor league contract?
Jason Mackey: I'm not quite sure what you're asking here, but I think my answer is no. Not like you can just tear up a contract and sign a new one to get options back.
Ken: Will this Pirates team win more than 50 games this season?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I think it will. These past two games have been bad, obviously. But more than 50? Come on. I have them at 62-100. I've seen nothing to change my mind off of that.
Paul r: Why is there a need to rest a player for a game
Jason Mackey: They put a lot into this -- and I think it's overcooked, if we're being honest. But they monitor rest, recovery, etc. Do they overreact because these players are viewed as investments? Absolutely. And I hate it. But I would caution that professional baseball isn't easy; that seems to be a misconception by fans, that these guys are just hanging out, having a good time. Days start at like 1 or 2 and end at, what, 10 or 11? There's usually an off-field workout, BP, fielding and other work pregame, the game, etc. It's not nothing.
Chris: Tyler Beede starting as an opener tonight?
Jason Mackey: It wouldn't shock me. Him or Peters.
Jim H: Hi Jason, how does MLB report attendance these days? On the daily box score, attendance and Time Of Game have been omitted. Let me know? Thanks!
Jason Mackey: I don't know what you're talking about Jim. I'm looking at our e-edition right now, and it has attendance and time of game listed in every box score. They report attendance as tickets sold and not bodies in ballpark, which to me is ridiculous.
Matt: Is Roansy getting the call to start tonight?
Jason Mackey: No, he's scheduled to start for Class AAA Indianapolis tonight as far as I know.
Pirate Parrot: Will the Pirates win anything in my lifetime?
Jason Mackey: Ha. Good one. One would think. Although I don't know how long parrots are supposed to live. Hopefully a while.
PrinceBob: Who do you think the Pirate All Star will be? Can it possibly be anyone but Bednar?
Jason Mackey: Has to be Bednar. Quintana, Gamel and Vogelbach have been very good, but I'm not sure I'd put any of them above Bednar in terms of chances or league-wide, if that makes sense. Lot of competition for those spots.
ev: Hi Jason, Zach Thompson, Conner Scott, and Kyle Nicholas were acquired from the Marlins for Jacob Stallings. Stallings' replacement, Perez, is out (not sure how long,,..). Thompson is 2-3 with a 5.47era and I believe the other two players are deep in the minors. Has this trade helped the Pirates or the Marlins? Stallings is still active/playing and we have Van Meter playing catcher until we were able to find a free agent signee.
Jason Mackey: Thompson has thrown 11 scoreless. If he's that version, it's different than the one you cited. That said, I think the Pirates are better off long-term. I didn't mind the trade at all when Perez was healthy. Scott and Nicolas are solid prospects. The issue here is them -- for whatever reason -- refusing to acquire legitimate catching help. Them not doing that doesn't mean the trade sucked, pardon the double negative.
Justin R.: A number of top position prospects have gotten off to very slow starts (Cruz, Gonzales, Fraizer, Swaggerty). Is there a developmental approach explanation for this or is it just coincidence?
Jason Mackey: I think it's just a coincidence, honestly. Gonzales has been better over his last 5, hitting .474 and looking much better. Cruz has been all over the place. Has obliterated some balls and has also looked bad. I don't think they helped things by how they handled his situation. Swaggerty was making some swing adjustments and has again been hurt. Not totally sure what's up with Fraizer. But they've also had guys who've been outstanding early -- Davis, Scott, Martin, Mitchell, etc.
Guest: excited for Roansy Contreras getting the nod today. What’s your prediction of his line today?
Jason Mackey: In Indy? He's not coming up to the big leagues. Probably goes 4-5, allows one run or none, walks one or two, and strikes out 6 or more.
MjB: OMG...stop the madness. The national embarrassment starts and ends with these ridiculous lineups. Put the same lineup in every day for a week, and play everyone at their natural positions. Using starters is a gimmick that does not work. Honestly, I can handle growing pains when you can see the future unfolding. What is the plan?
Jason Mackey: Using starters is a gimmick? Do you mean openers? Also, who's not playing at their natural position? I agree VanMeter doesn't need to play as much as he has. Guys get too many days off. But it's also true that some of the Pirates' best hitters have been in prolonged slumps, and Shelton doesn't have enough talent to work with in the first place.
Matt: Hi Jason, any word on Roansy starting tonight in Chicago? Slated to start for Indy today at 1:35pm and the Indy website currently has no listed pitcher for todays game. Says "TBD"
Jason Mackey: No word. I've checked on it with a few people. Nothing yet. Will let you guys know if I do, but as of now, I have nothing to indicate he's coming up.
MRP: Is there any reason DS continues to start Yoshi T. despite his persistent ineptitude?
Jason Mackey: One, I think they need to give him a larger sample size. Fans will disagree with that, but it's true. Secondly, there aren't many better options. You can play Chavis, sure. But then who plays second or third?
Dan: Jason -- Don't forget Nyjer Morgan. Played pro hockey before baseball.
Jason Mackey: Who could forget Tony Plush? But I was considering only active members of the organization.
Q: Any word on today's starter?
Jason Mackey: Just announced: Wil Crowe.
Benson DuBois: Should we have faith that Oneil Cruz will figure out the OF?
Jason Mackey: Umm, tough one to answer because of how it's phrased and what we've seen. I think Oneil has all the tools to succeed out there. I also don't think he has any interest in doing it. That said, if he establishes himself as a big leaguer and we get to a position where his shortstop work is bad, Peguero is here and someone has to move, I think we might see a different motivation and result.
Wayward: Jason, as always, thanks for the chats. Is this stretch of bad baseball just that or do you as a sign of what this team really is.
Jason Mackey: I mean, nobody is this bad. Said before, I have them at 62-100. I think that's what they are. It'll be an interesting road to get there, I'm sure. But, no, I don't think they're one-run-in-three-games bad.
Benson DuBois: Any hope to extend Quintana?
Jason Mackey: No way. The way he's pitching, why on Earth would he do that to his career?
Hunter: Hey Jason. Obviously there are plenty of people who have been disappointed by the rebuild results so far. Although it’s still quite early… what are your thoughts on how the pirates have gone about their current rebuild?
Jason Mackey: I love the minor league stuff. I think their farm system has improved in all sorts of ways -- talent, approach, coaching, tech, etc. How they're trying to win makes sense to me, too. That said, doing that well and doing something at the major league level don't have to be mutually exclusive. Spend some money at the top AND do what you're doing at the bottom would be my thought.
Guest: Hi Jason! Someone pointed out yesterday that Lonnie White was added to Bradenton’s roster, though he also appears to be on the 7-day IL. Have you heard anything about an injury for him, and do you think this is a sign he may be skipping the FCL this year?
Jason Mackey: Have not heard about Lonnie White's injury, but we talk to Todd Tomczyk today and will ask.
Bucs23: Who do you think will be the next position player called up from a group of Cruz, Martin, or Mitchell. And why?
Jason Mackey: Cruz, because he's on the 40-man roster. Martin and Mitchell have been better, frankly. They also play positions where there may be more of a major league need, but they're not on the 40-man. Need to have more certainty in both directions before that happens.
Jason P: What’s going on with Cole Tucker? Has yet to appear in a game for AAA since being optioned.
Jason Mackey: He's there. They're just letting him get away from it for a bit. I don't think that's the worst thing. Let him do some -- oh, no, here it comes -- skill development work before jumping back into games.
Guest: Have you heard anything about when Quinn Priester might return from injury since the medical staff revealed that he is working on mechanical adjustments?
Jason Mackey: Couple weeks is the expectation. I expect to hear more later today when Todd Tomczyk talks. He's throwing off a mound, so it shouldn't be too terribly long. I expect them to ease him back into it, though. Slow build.
Justin: does any player stick out as being the funniest on the team?
Jason Mackey: Vogelbach. And it's not close.
Jason Mackey: Well, I shouldn't say that. He's the most outwardly funny. Reynolds might have the best sense of humor, but it's obviously understated and dry. Gamel is pretty good, too.
Wayward: When considering the Bucs minor league players from a depth standpoint, which positional group have you seen the most improvement in over the past 2 years. I am beginning to think catching.
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree. Although the initial bar was awfully low.
Matt: Following up on Roansy...Indy plays at 1:35pm today and their website has no listed started. It shows as TBD
Jason Mackey: Wil Crowe is starting today. Have not heard of Roansy being called up. For the 19th time.
Jim M: Jason, What’s with all the resting of KeyBryan Hayes? Are they being cautious with his wrist injury from last season? I don’t get it with all the open dates (next 3 Thursdays) and rainouts. Thanks
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it's a little strange. I wonder if he's battling something that nobody will say. Either that or, with him being such a long-term investment, they're more cautious with him than anyone else. It has been a lot, though. I agree.
john: Do you believe in the rebuild?
Jason Mackey: I do, yes. Got a little into this earlier, but I like what they're doing in the minor leagues. I just think the major league team could be made a little more competitive/interesting in the meantime. You're still a business and need to get people in the ballpark. There hasn't been enough of a reason for people to go.
Dave: I’m not a this team is terrible move them type of guy. I’ve been a diehard for 40 plus years. That being said I see no value in being invested in this current team (it’s just a bunch of also rans + Hayes/Reynolds). Plus I’m not sold on the prospects. Can you give me any reason to change my mind?
Jason Mackey: I mean, I don't work for the team, and it's not my job to sell you on them. Either you wanna care about what they're doing or you don't. I will say, they talk a lot about bringing fans along for the ride. But they don't actually do much of it. Manager doesn't talk about much detail-wise. The president hasn't talked since last February. Neither Williams nor Nutting has talked since the new CBA. Nutting hasn't taken questions from reporters since hiring Williams. I know Cherington is kinda dry, but he's at least available and gives people something about what they're doing. Bottom line, if you didn't believe you were getting a return on investment when it comes to paying what it costs to see games on AT&T SportsNet or MLB.TV or go to them with the cost of tickets, parking, food and beer, I certainly couldn't argue with you.
RS: Was there ever a reason given for Mason Martin not to be included on the 40 man roster? I would think with the lack of power throughout the organization he would be valued a little higher. I know he is a first basemen but I think they dodged a bullet by the rule 5 draft not happening this year. There may be a few guys on the 40 now who may be a little more expendable than a power hitting first baseman who bats left handed at PNC park.
Jason Mackey: Back in the Rule 5 days, I think the belief was that they could sneak a first baseman through the draft, because that position is generally occupied by better more established players on other clubs. Also, his strikeout issues.
Wayward: Jason, just fyi, Indianapolis is showing their starter tonight as TBD.
Jason Mackey: The notes they just sent out say Roansy Contreras.
Hank: How long will the pirates give chances to guys like Vanmeter, Yoshi, and Hembre? I don't understand why they continue to give regular at bats to Vanmeter and Yoshi when we have guys who are apart of the future knocking on the door in AAA.
Jason Mackey: I think you have to get into June, especially on Yoshi. I'm fine with VanMeter as a utility/backup type. He doesn't need to be playing every day.
Justin: What's the main criticism you have of the current leadership / decision making group over the past few years, or specifically this year, if anything?
Jason Mackey: That they haven't insulated themselves enough at key positions -- not enough pitching, mishandling of catching, etc.
Dave: At what point do we question what Ben Cherington is doing. I see no tangible evidence that the organization has changed or improved from the last regime. In fact it seems worse.
Jason Mackey: Really? Have you checked the farm system? You can blame Ben for the lack of success at the major league level if you want. He is the GM. But no progress anywhere? Henry Davis and their entire last draft? The year before with Gonzales and others? How much they've changed coaching-wise and with player development? Hiring Baker? Their push with analytics? How do you just ignore all of that?
ev: Jason, Regarding Cole Tucker. He has given up switch hitting to hit left handed (?) exclusively. Back in the stone age, when I was young, switch hitters were few and far between in MLB. There seems to be an emphasis on switch hitting league wide now. Is this a metrics thing?
Jason Mackey: Not really no. You either can or can't. I think teams would rather have a good hitter from one side than a mediocre hitter from two. For Cole, I see the reasoning. Simplify.
Jim M: Jason, Do you think all the changing of lineups is hurting defensive consistency ? I realize Newman’s injury necessitated it but why not leave Castillo at ss?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. Doesn't the Rays or others or do it. Don't see why it would affect the Pirates more than others.
Justin: If you were able to have a few drinks with Ben Cherington and he got into a totally-honest state, do you think he'd say he prefers a 2022 season that got him, say, the #3 overall pick in 2023, or the #13 overall pick?
Jason Mackey: I think it would depend how it happened. Does that first option include guys actually getting better -- and maybe at a team-friendly time? Does it include players like Gamel and Quintana playing well, then fetching prospects?
Dan: is Shelton l, in your eyes, managing this team to its potential? Or is he so handicapped by BC he has no choice whom he plays?
Jason Mackey: It's tough to say. They've changed a lot this year, and there hasn't been enough time to get an accurate sample. I'll say this: I don't think they're losing games because of Shelton's managing.
john: Wil Crowe on the bump tonight? What do you think of shelty starting the middle relievers?
Jason Mackey: I'm fine with it if it works. I think Keller is going to follow him, and I'm more interested to see how Mitch handles that role.
Canyon: Is there a chance we can see Davis next year?
Jason Mackey: Taylor or Henry?
Chris R: The Cubs won 97 games in year 4 of their rebuild. And of course the Cubs helped with high price FA’s when the time was right. It took the Astros until year 5 to have a winning record for their rebuild. So are we following the longer, Astros like road? And if yes, is the current Bucs team about right where we should be, as frustrating as that seems?
Jason Mackey: I don't think they're following one more than the other. I think the bulk of their horses are in Class AA Altoona, as I said last week. When they get up to the big leagues and begin to become regular contributors, that's when you're truly gonna see this thing turn.
Soggy: What are the odds the Pirates trade Bednar at the deadline if he continues to dominate? Thanks for the chats Jason. I appreciate your patience with the questions & your candor!
Jason Mackey: 0.00%.
Dan: Any hope for pirates catching? Who do you have your eye on in Indy?
Jason Mackey: There's nobody there who I think can help the MLB soon. They should be looking outside for help.
Hunter: Jason. Which pittsburgh team do you enjoy covering the most?
Jason Mackey: Not sure, Hunter. It has less to do with the team than the beat. Baseball is a lot when you have young kids, which I do. Haven't done much football outside of my 8 months at DK. I loved covering hockey and sorta miss it. I actually wish I could have a role where I had involvement with all three, but I'm not sure if that's possible for me here.
Justin: What are some things in the minor leagues that the Pirates are doing that other teams haven't already been doing for a handful of years?
Jason Mackey: Pirates-wise, they're not trying to make everybody the same -- I.e. what they did to Meadows or Glasnow. They're using tech a ton. Also, it's not always about doing something new. Sometimes it's just actually getting through to players to identifying shortcomings and earning trust to fix stuff. The relationship side down there has improved a lot.
Wayward: When he is ready does Newman slid back into the starting SS or do you think he moves around and plays some 2B?
Jason Mackey: For now, SS. But I think it depends on what happens with Cruz. If he hits, I think he comes up, then Newman bounces.
Bill: Another NHL Q, which non-Pen FA's would you like to see them sign?
Jason Mackey: I don't have my feet under me enough on that to give you a reasonable answer. Sorry.
Danny: Is Juan Yepez the next Pujols?
Jason Mackey: Might be a wee bit aggressive there.
Guest: Looks like the Mendoza line is about to become as respectable as a .250 batting average back in the late 20th century. What is the new Mendoza Line, .180? Maybe you can try to get the name changed to the Yoshi Line?
Jason Mackey: Man, Yoshi has yinz guys fired up today.
Lost in WV: Will a Pirate pitcher ever have a complete game with Derek Shelton as manager and his ridiculous pitch counts?
Jason Mackey: No, I can't see it. It would have to be from, like, Quintana and essentially a Maddux.
GPT: I know Keller gets compared to Glasnow a lot, but he shouldn't. Glasnow was outright dominant in the minors, then was shoehorned into Searage's one-size-fits all methodology in Pittsburgh. Keller was decent in the minors, but not spectacular by any means. If he stinks, and he sure seems to, then stop putting him in ballgames.
Jason Mackey: You bring up some good points. I think Glasnow was held back here. I don't think that has been the case for Mitch. That said, I think the comparison exists because we're talking about electric stuff and substandard results.
Matt: Jason, what ever happened to Jose Soriano? (The Rule 5 pick)?
Jason Mackey: Lost him to the Angels.
Guest: I think Nick Gonzalez should be brought up and left to play everyday at second by the end of June. Seems to me a pure hitter like him can learn at the pro level just as well as at AAA. Agreed?
Jason Mackey: Nope, I don't. Let him develop. He's not ready. The major league team's shortcomings should not cause development issues for prospects.
Fan: When are your predictions that we see Cruz Contreras And Martin
Jason Mackey: Contreras soon. Cruz when he starts hitting. I still think it'll be a bit for Martin, to give Yoshi more run and make sure there's nothing there. (I don't think there is personally.)
Dan: Hey Jason first time here. Is Shelton managing this team or is he being managed and told who and when to play who?
Jason Mackey: It's not either/or. It's collaborative. He makes the decisions, but they're usually in consultation with game-planning/analytics/front office.
Ray Guy: Does Cole Tucker get DFAd / traded / otherwise jettisoned this year? He has never really performed at any level, even in the minors. Change of scenery candidate, I would think.
Jason Mackey: They don't NEED the 40-man spot. I don't know what you would trade him for or why you would do that. You don't trade stocks at their lowest point. I think you send him down and see what happens. If you need the 40-man spot, maybe you do something. But that day is not today.
TooTall21: Jason, the high rankings our farm system are not reflected in the current W-L records of the top 3 teams: Indy 17-17, and both Altoona and Greensboro at 14-19. Should this be a concern for what we’re hoping to see in a couple years?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. Win-loss records for minor league teams are nice, but they don't paint a complete picture. I barely pay attention to them.
Justin: Why do you think 2b is never discussed as an option for Cruz? That's where just about every other questionable-fielding shortstop goes, and would maintain at least some of the up-the-middle value that he has. And his arm can still be used on cutoffs there.
Jason Mackey: He wants to play shortstop. I'm not sure how that gets fixed moving him to shortstop. The only thing you're doing at that point is wasting his arm.
PrinceBob: I'll try again on the question about options. I've been in the majors and am at the point where I'm out of options. Then I become a free agent but I can't get a deal with a major league contract so I sign a minor league contract with someone and eventually get called up. Can I be sent down again because I was signed to a minor league deal or do I still go through the DFA process before I can play in the minors? Hope that's more clear.
Jason Mackey: You still have to go through the DFA process. Believe once you're out of options, you're out. Hence why they had to handle Alford the way they did.
Brendan: Hey Jason, have you heard anything on what Henry Davis is dealing with in Altoona? The quotes from the Curve manager made it seem really suspicious and non-specific as to why he’s not been in the lineup.
Jason Mackey: It's a left wrist contusion. He's on the seven-day IL.
Justin: (For the record, I want Cruz at shortstop. I'm just saying that the *team* seems hellbent on moving him to LF... and 2b just seems like it'd be a much better compromise)
Jason Mackey: He doesn't want to move. Again, I would ease off the position stuff, let him play SS and hit, then revisit later.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks so much as always. Gotta run for now. Will talk to yinz from Wrigley. Always appreciated you reading and following along.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.