When Cole Tucker stepped up to pinch-hit for the Pirates against the Los Angeles Dodgers on Monday, it didn’t make much sense strategically.
The Dodgers had left-hander Julio Urias on the mound, who dominates left-handed hitters. Tucker is a switch-hitter, but he was pinch-hitting for outfielder Jake Marisnick, a right-handed hitter himself.
Even more curiously, Tucker stepped into the left-handed batter’s box, setting up an unfavorable left-on-left matchup.
As it turned out, Marisnick had injured his left hand on a tremendous diving catch in the top of the fourth inning, so Tucker was required to sub in defensively. But it still begged the question: Why step in left-handed?
Turns out it’s a permanent change for Tucker. He is a career .192 hitter from the right side, and at a certain point, enough was enough.
“I’m tired of getting the bat shoved up my butt right-handed, bluntly,” Tucker told reporters Tuesday. “I just want to give myself the best chance I can to succeed, and right now I think that’s left-handed.”
Read More
Manager Derek Shelton conceded that the situation was an awfully tough ask for Tucker, especially against Urias, but Marisnick’s injury forced his hand. It just so happened to be the debut of Tucker’s new left-on-left approach.
To be fair, something has to give with Tucker’s offense if he’s going to carve out a future role with the Pirates. Even left-handed, he’s hit just .218 over his career. The positive stretches he’s experienced have been few and far between since he made his debut in 2019.
The decision also wasn’t an easy one to make for Tucker. He began switch-hitting in high school, around the age of 14 or 15, he said. At the time, he was just trying to emulate some of his favorite MLB players, like Jose Reyes and Chipper Jones.
Over the years, he said he’s considered switching to hitting exclusively from the left side. Then he would go through a stretch where he felt good from the right side of the plate and would vow to keep going as a switch-hitter.
Eventually, though, a breaking point came, and Tucker decided enough was enough.
“Just like baseball, the results dictate and change everything and change how you feel on a day-to-day basis,” Tucker said. “The last time I seriously tried to quit hitting right-handed was probably when I was in like Double-A. So it’s been a few years, but the game was kind of showing me that that might be the right decision, and I just feel like going for it.”
The goal now will just be to craft Tucker’s left-handed swing. After all, things haven’t been going too well for him from either side of the plate. It’s difficult enough to monitor the intricacies of one swing as a player, let alone two.
Tucker added that the move doesn’t have to be permanent. If things go poorly from the left side, he can always go back to switch-hitting. Tucker is just trying to foster some confidence in what has been another tough start to his season.
“You’ve just got to go into it with that attitude and that mindset of confidence and coming at it from a place of power,” Tucker said. “It got to the point where I was feeling like, man, I kind of feel like I would feel better hitting left-handed against this guy than right-handed. That’s kind of how we got here.”
Marisnick to IL
Speaking of Marisnick, the diagnosis on his hand turned out to be worse than originally thought. Marisnick immediately winced and grabbed his glove hand after securing his circus catch in the fourth, but went on to take an at-bat in the bottom of the fifth, when he bunted back to Urias.
After leaving the game, the Pirates discovered that Marisnick had, in fact, come down with a thumb injury. Prior to Tuesday’s game, he was placed on the 10-day injured list, with right-handed pitcher Max Kranick called up to take his spot on the active roster.
Marisnick will mostly be missed defensively. Entering play Tuesday, he leads all MLB outfielders in recording five outs above average this season. His diving grab Monday was just the latest of a host of highlight-reel plays he has made this season. In his stead, it appears likely that Ben Gamel, Bryan Reynolds and Jack Suwinski will man the outfield in most games moving forward.
Whenever Kranick enters another game for the Pirates, it will be his second appearance this season after he pitched two scoreless frames Saturday against the Cincinnati Reds. He was the 27th man on the roster, called up for that day’s doubleheader. Kranick pitched to a 6.28 ERA in 38 ⅔ innings last season.
Around the horn
Right-hander Duane Underwood Jr. seems poised to return to the Pirates in the near future. On Monday, he was in Pittsburgh, going through a workout for trainers. On Tuesday, he was sent to Altoona for a rehab outing, where Shelton said he would pitch one inning.
Catcher Roberto Perez is still meeting with doctors, with no official prognosis for the severity of his left hamstring injury. Shelton again confirmed that Perez will “miss significant time.”
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.