So much for Andrew McCutchen taking it easy on his former team.
The ex-Pirates star entered Thursday's game hitting just .136 with a 31.5% strikeout rate and three RBIs in 17 career games against them. McCutchen’s surprising run of futility against his former club ended in a few key spots during a 3-2 Brewers victory over the Pirates on Thursday afternoon at PNC Park, which completed a three-game sweep.
In addition to homering on the first pitch of the game, McCutchen lined a two-run single over a leaping Josh VanMeter with the bases loaded in the top of the ninth inning to push Milwaukee in front for good.
McCutchen finished the game with three hits and three RBIs while the Pirates lost for the sixth consecutive time to Milwaukee this season. Pittsburgh is 6-23 against the Brewers since sweeping a three-game series in Pittsburgh Aug. 21-23, 2020.
“I haven’t done much against my old team,” McCutchen said. “It was good to sleep in my own bed, show up and get a win [Thursday].”
Andrew McCutchen
The homer was the first for McCutchen here since a significant one earlier in his career, a towering shot to center on Sept. 26, 2017, that delivered his first MLB grand slam and was part of an eight-RBI day.
Read More
This one was a little quieter than that, although McCutchen might chalk it up to the different baseballs purportedly being used this season, which was another topic of his postgame media session.
“We know they’re not the same,” McCutchen said. “We saw that [Thursday]. Balls are hit well. There’s nothing to show for it.
“We can complain all we want about the balls and how bad they are, but you just have to scratch away and try and score runs. Mine barely got out. Thankfully, it did.”
McCutchen’s home run came on a fastball from Jose Quintana that was a little up in the zone. It traveled 355 feet, with Ben Gamel crashing into the left-field wall while trying to run it down.
McCutchen closed his banner afternoon by going down to get a Chris Stratton curveball and shooting it the other way. If VanMeter was 6-foot-3, he might’ve snared it. He’s not. He’s generously listed at 5-11. As it stood, the ball ticked off his glove, and the two runs negated the two Pittsburgh scored in the bottom of the seventh.
Stratton took over for David Bednar, who pitched a 1-2-3 eighth while working through the heart of Milwaukee’s order. It’s a succession of relievers the Pirates have used often this season. The only problem was, this time, Stratton allowed three consecutive singles before McCutchen singled for the Brewers (13-7).
“We did exactly what we wanted to do,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said when asked about the move to take out Bednar. “We got the exact people in line. I think today it ran about as well as it could have scripted. We just didn’t complete the game.”
Pittsburgh’s rally started with a Gamel single and Michael Chavis double, putting runners on second and third with nobody out. Jack Suwinski hit a grounder to short that Willy Adames booted, leading to one run.
Diego Castillo drove a fly ball to center, the sacrifice fly scoring Chavis and pushing the Pirates in front for a brief period.
Also important in this one was an impressive start the Pirates got from Jose Quintana, who looked solid while featuring a three-pitch mix.
Quintana has fared well against the Brewers throughout his career and did so again on Thursday, giving the Pirates (8-11) five innings of one-run ball.
What’s more, Quintana didn’t walk a batter and struck out nine, the most in a game for him since he whiffed the same amount May 3, 2021 against the Rays. The last time Quintana walked none and struck out nine was Aug. 30, 2017.
With a changeup that has improved each time out, Quintana generated 16 whiffs (seven on his changeup) to go along with 14 called strikes.
“I thought he was good,” Shelton said. “I thought his changeup was really good. In control of the game. Was able to execute his fastball when he had to and use his changeup off it. I thought it was a really solid outing.”
Despite not factoring into the decision, Quintana dropped his career ERA to just 2.74 in 19 games (18 starts) against Milwaukee.
After the McCutchen homer, Quintana regrouped nicely, striking out the side and scattering three singles the rest of the way.
Meanwhile, Miguel Yajure followed Quintana with a bounce-back outing. The young right-hander has struggled this year but faced the Brewers' best hitters without allowing a run, striking out two.
“I don’t think he had his best stuff,” Shelton said of Yajure. “But he was able to pitch with it and execute pitches.”
Around the horn
Pirates starting pitchers do not have a win in 19 games. The only team that has gone longer to start a season, per the Elias Sports Bureau: the 1988 Orioles, who lost their first 21 games. … Andrew Knapp was a late scratch at catcher with an undisclosed illness. Roberto Perez took his place.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.