BRADENTON, Fla. — Pirates manager Derek Shelton is as competitive as they come. Once again in-person, his interactions with reporters are often light-hearted and fun, featuring practical jokes, plenty of music talk and discussions over family. But when the cameras and recorders turn on, Shelton doesn’t really give much, careful not to tip his hand.
With his players, however, Shelton is different. They consider him open, honest and engaging, traits that are undoubtedly important to a young and developing club, with Shelton cognizant of creating a clubhouse culture and not carrying himself like some curmudgeon who’s walled off from his players.
“A lot of guys I talk to around the league, players my age, sometimes they don’t even talk to their managers,” Ke’Bryan Hayes said. “They don’t feel comfortable. I think [having a more person relationship with Shelton] is really big, especially when you have a young club and everyone’s still learning, trying to find their way.”
That desire to make players feel comfortable or welcome is done a couple ways for Shelton. With stuff like approving Liover Peguero’s speaker, for one, but also having a series of individual conversations with players (often about stuff other than baseball) and otherwise making himself approachable via jokes, small talk or his general demeanor.
If a player has something to celebrate off the field — marriage, the birth of a child or rehabbing an injury — he’ll probably receive a phone call, text or a bottle of bourbon from Shelton.
At the same time, Shelton embraces a leadership style where he invites players to come into his office and talk to them about anything. A problem at home. Thoughts on something the Pirates could do better. Concern over a slump. Restaurant recommendations. All fair game.
Read More
“I wouldn’t say I go in there every single day, but I’ve gone in there and talked about different things — bourbon, whatever it may be,” Reynolds said. “His door is always open. He’s definitely approachable.”
Hayes, too, has taken Shelton up on the standing offer, especially last season when the young third baseman struggled with his health and was unable to rediscover the same sort of power he had in September 2020.
“I went in Shelty’s office a lot of times last year to just talk about family, anything,” Hayes said. “Any time you want to go in there, as long as that door’s open, you’re welcome to come in. You can talk about anything in the world with him. That’s been really good.”
Chris Stratton played for Bruce Bochy with the Giants and Brad Ausmus during his brief stint with the Angels. And while the Pirates reliever certainly liked both men, especially Bochy, it wasn’t the same experience as he has with Shelton.
In fact, the first time Shelton called Stratton — one of the club’s veteran leaders — into his office, Stratton was a little confused.
“He asked me a question about something really simple, and I was like, ‘So ... you have nothing else?’ ” Stratton explained, saying he thought he was in trouble for something. “He was like, ‘No, I just wanted to know that.’ I was like, ‘OK, cool.’ That was a pleasant surprise.”
The questions and conversations run the gamut, Stratton said. They could involve the previous day’s game, a recent trend with the team or how the Pirates are practicing. All of it is designed to solicit feedback.
“When he says he’s transparent and open, he’s being completely honest,” Stratton said. “That’s the way he wants to run things, and I think that’s the way he has. He’s said multiple times, ‘If you don’t think that I’m being open and honest, please call me out on it because I want this to be a clubhouse where everybody feels like they can come talk to me about anything.’”
Shelton said the approach comes from a couple different places — Eric Wedge in Cleveland and Joe Maddon in Tampa, likely a little John Gibbons in Toronto and also inspired or shaped by his time with Paul Molitor and Rocco Baldelli in Minnesota, as well.
Shelton loves the back-and-forth. His only rule is that players aren’t allowed to get offended by honesty.
“It's their careers. We want them to articulate what they're feeling,” Shelton said. “But if you're going to ask a question, we're going to provide an honest answer. A lot of times, it's not about baseball. It's about other things. But just having the ability to have a conversation with someone is really important.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.