BRADENTON, Fla. — The Pirates have drafted better and improved player development. They’ve fared well internationally while executing trades netting plenty of talented prospects, enough for a top-five farm system.
Which is why how they’ve handled Bryan Reynolds makes zero sense. And why it’s also scary when trying to predict when PNC Park might once again house a winning baseball team.
As a way to further assess what happened between the Pirates and their best player — the two sides $650,000 apart in salary arbitration figures filed Tuesday and now facing an in-season hearing — let’s ponder a few questions before the dust settles.
And no, to quickly address the elephant in the room, this doesn’t look good for Reynolds’ long-term future with the Pirates. If such a thing ever existed in the first place.
What are the Pirates thinking?
It’s hardly uncommon for teams to haggle with this stuff, believing it’s their job to keep costs down. Pitcher Lucas Giolito with the White Sox, for example, filed for $7.5 million, his employer $7.3 million. They’re headed for a hearing.
Read More
It’s obvious that the Pirates ($4.25 million) and Reynolds ($4.9 million) have differing views on his value. It’s also obvious the Pirates are not the White Sox (or like most other MLB teams).
The Pirates could have a payroll one-seventh the size of MLB’s largest; they’ve produced four winning seasons in the past 29 years and have a .388 winning percentage over the past three; and the largest contract in franchise history, Jason Kendall for six years, $60 million in November 2000, is old enough to legally purchase alcohol.
Suffice to say, this was an odd time to draw a line in the sand with money.
Especially when you consider the (admittedly minor) amount of goodwill they’ve built with their fans recently through those small-ball principles they’ve legitimately done a good job to improve. All of that is a much tougher sell than it was a few days ago, because of this.
What about Reynolds’ long-term future here?
This part of the equation is scary. Or maybe just sad.
For anyone who saw video of Reynolds answering questions Wednesday or read between the lines of his quotes on the topic, it certainly seemed like he was a little hacked off. That he doesn’t think he should have to deal with this given his production, value and place on the Pirates.
He wouldn’t be wrong for feeling that way.
Reynolds outperformed all but about four players in the National League while doing it on a bad team with no lineup protection. The player above him in FanGraphs’ Wins Above Replacement (Fernando Tatis Jr.) has a $340,000,000 contract. The player with the same amount of fWAR, Brandon Crawford of the Giants, received a two-year, $32 million extension last season and has made nearly $70 million over 11 seasons.
Reynolds couldn’t get his employer to pay him an extra $650,000 after he started in the MLB All-Star Game, received MVP votes and was a Gold Glove finalist.
Does this mean Reynolds will be traded?
It certainly feels more likely than a contract extension, which Reynolds said was never seriously discussed during this process. More than that, the truly concerning part here involves trust, something general manager Ben Cherington talked recently about wanting to build with players.
It’s hard to see how this helps that.
Say Reynolds magically has a respectable offer presented to him, and he’s left with a decision. Is there enough trust built up for him to sign it and believe the Pirates are going to change their ways? Doubtful.
Same deal for players on other clubs. Think they’re itching to come here knowing this could happen?
It also sends the wrong message to fans who worry whether owner Bob Nutting will financially support a rebuild whenever the ongoing prospect push pops.
Which is why haggling with your best player over such a small amount of money (relatively speaking), especially in this market, simply isn’t worth it.
Right, so he’s gone?
He probably should be, as much as that hurts to type. How else to interpret what the Pirates did? (Are fans supposed to be excited by the Pirates fighting the good fight to keep arbitration costs down? Please.)
This also may have tipped their hand when it comes to how they view Reynolds’ future here.
Think about it: If extension talk has never gained traction and the Pirates were OK doing something like this — they had to know it would produce a reaction on Reynolds’ end — their actions speak louder than words.
If they seemingly don’t see a need to build trust and would rather go this route, perhaps they don’t believe they'll be good again by the time he reaches free agency.
How else to interpret failing to sign your best player to a market-value contract, then taking him to an arbitration hearing over $650,000?
Could a trade be imminent?
No, that's too aggressive, although multiple sources have confirmed that they are listening and the ask on Reynolds is extremely high (as it should be).
But while the Pirates technically don't have to do anything for a few years, it’s also important to consider years of control; Reynolds has three more after this season, which is a ton for someone with his profile.
As such, the frustrating reality is that the clock is ticking assuming they’re not serious about extending him … and their recent actions would indicate as much.
The A's just got a haul for first baseman Matt Olson — arguably Atlanta’s top two guys and four of the top 15. Olson has a slightly better résumé, but Reynolds’ ticket to netting a similar return is the amount of club control.
Can’t say it enough: The preferred solution is to keep Reynolds and extend him. It's just hard to see how that happens given what the Pirates chose to do here.
Why is that?
Arbitration hearings, using Reynolds' words, can get “messy.” There are reasons both parties prefer to avoid them. It's also often hard to come back from hearings.
Scan a list of recent ones, and you won’t find many long-term deals. Eduardo Rodriguez declined a qualifying offer and signed for five years, $77 million with the Tigers. Jack Flaherty had a hearing in St. Louis, and it has led to a strained relationship with the Cardinals front office. Josh Hader in Milwaukee has worked on a bunch of one-year deals and will soon become a free agent.
Phillies catcher JR Realmuto went to a hearing and later signed a long-term deal, but he's the exception rather than the rule.
Could they fix this?
Short answer: yes.
The Pirates, like most teams, operate under what’s called a file-and-trial system. Essentially they file figures as they did on Tuesday, and if there’s no agreement, they refuse to negotiate again (aside from a long-term deal) and turn their attention toward a hearing.
They are, however, still permitted to offer a more palatable one-year contract and avoid the arbitration process. But it would require breaking precedent.
That could be a short-term solution, and it might help to establish some goodwill with the player and fans. Although if what has happened in the past serves as any indication, that happening is far from likely.
What’s left to think?
Nothing, really. Barring some sort of seismic change, what’s done is done. Reynolds has said several times how much he loves Pittsburgh, but it’s hard to see him playing here for any length of time.
It also doesn’t appear the Pirates care much about how they’re perceived by players or fans, who obviously want to see Reynolds playing at PNC Park for as long as possible.
Without Reynolds, it really means just one thing: Their ongoing youth movement — the prospect push and growing from within — better work. Because somehow winning baseball games is the only thing that will negate questionable business decisions like this one.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.