Jason Mackey sits down with Sean Casey

Sean Casey has been thinking a lot lately. Maybe it’s because he’ll turn 48 in July, another year closer to 50. Or that the Upper St. Clair native and former MLB first baseman recently read a book by David Brooks called “The Second Mountain: The Quest for a Moral Life,” which talks about living purposefully and the true keys to personal fulfillment.

This also marks Casey’s 14th season out of professional baseball, which matches his time spent as a player during a career that included MLB stops in Cleveland, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, Detroit and Boston.

As Casey reflects on what he’s accomplished in and around baseball, most notably his charity work and (richly deserved) reputation as one of the sport’s nicest players, this much is clear: Casey is nowhere near done.

In fact, Casey feels like he’s only starting that second mountain, one that includes his popular podcast called “The Mayor’s Office,” as well as a budding interest in helping younger players navigate the mental side of baseball.

Advertise with us

“I always tell people, ‘Listen, there are a lot of talented guys who just can’t deal with the grind and failure of the game,’ ” Casey said over a recent lunch at Mediterra Cafe in Mt. Lebanon. “I’d love to pass on some of what I’ve learned.

“Life mirrors baseball so closely with grit, accountability and having a purpose. I think helping guys figure that out is going to be my next phase.”

Talking to Casey can be an uplifting experience. It’s akin to guzzling an energy drink, his enthusiasm for everything contagious, whether that’s helping to launch the Miracle League of the South Hills or throughout a playing career that included three All-Star appearances, hitting better than .300 six times and a trip to the 2006 World Series.

Yet in his mind, Casey remains that humble Pittsburgh kid who penned letters to more than 30 colleges and universities, begging them to recruit him, and the University of Richmond product who would chat up Tony Gwynn or Mark McGwire at first base, beyond grateful for everything he’s experienced.

Through it all, and especially now, Casey has to pinch himself when looking back on all he’s accomplished while simultaneously believing there’s plenty of work to be done.

Advertise with us

“When I got to the big leagues, there was so much of me that was always a fan,” said Casey, who has been with MLB Network since its 2009 launch. "I was always like, ‘If they realize I’m in the big leagues, man, I hope they don’t let me go.

“People have asked me why I give back. I give back because I think I’m the most blessed human being alive. I feel like I have to.”

How Casey has helped others is already a huge part of his legacy, probably more so than anything he did on a baseball field. Over an hourlong lunch, Casey opened up about his desire to help others and what life is like now as a father of four, TV analyst, podcast host and aspiring life coach.

Here are some excerpts from that conversation.

'Under the radar'

Advertise with us

When Casey was playing, he remembers hearing stories about his father pacing in front of the TV, Jim Casey exceedingly nervous for every one of his son’s at-bats. Sean Casey is the exact same way for his kids: Jake, an infielder at Kent State; Andrew, a first baseman/outfielder for Dayton; Carli, a sophomore volleyball player at Upper St. Clair; and Jillian, a sixth-grader who’s currently knee-deep into travel basketball.

“When you don’t have control of the situation, it’s way more stressful,” Casey said.

As a player, Casey was known for his strong work ethic and using a Tony Gwynn Solo Hitter to take an incalculable number of swings in the family garage.

Casey isn’t militaristic or obsessive with his kids, but especially on the baseball side, he’s always been a willing participant for extra work, emphasizing to them that playing sports at a higher level takes an abnormal amount of dedication.

At the same time, Casey also believes in the importance of staying loose and having fun.

Advertise with us

“I think we miss that sometimes, especially as parents,” Casey said.

Then there’s the humility.

One funny anecdote about Casey the parent is that he refuses to tell his kids much about his own athletic career, save for two things. Hitting the first home run at PNC Park and a 432-foot drive three days later that clanked off a speaker.

“I try to fly under the radar,” Casey said. “I’m more excited to be on the other end now and see where their journeys take them.”

'Fundraising my buddies'

Advertise with us

Whether through Big Brothers/Big Sisters, Make-A-Wish or various hospital visits, many of which came in private, Casey’s charity work was a big part of his identity with the Reds. But the practice has really been omnipresent throughout his life.

The abundance of charity work is done out of Casey’s gratitude for the gifts he’s been given. It’s also faith-based and tied to advice he received from his sister, Beth, who encouraged a younger Sean to get out in the community.

“At the end of the day, I feel we’re here to serve each other,” Casey said. “If it’s all for me, then what am I doing?”

In Pittsburgh, Casey's charity work is probably best demonstrated through the Miracle League, specifically the field at Boyce Mayview Park that opened in 2012.

Countless kids and parents have been afforded the opportunity to learn about baseball because of the generosity of Casey and others, including a concession stand that now mimics real, on-the-job training, with resume requirements and an interview process.

Advertise with us

But after 10 years, Casey said they’ve “pretty much run the clutch out” on the new field and must replace it. Cost: $300,000. So Casey has gone back into fundraising mode while also planning for the May 6 Miracle Bash at (Washington) Wild Things Park.

“I’m fundraising my buddies right now,” Casey said, laughing. “I just talked to Aaron Boone like, ‘Hey, bro. Can you send me a jersey?’ Jim Thome, same thing. You feel like that guy, but, hey, it’s for a good cause.”

The Miracle League isn’t all Casey does. He’s on the board for the Pittsburgh Kids Foundation and has volunteered at an orphanage in Haiti. Casey also regularly donates his time to the Light of Life Rescue Mission on the North Side.

“You don’t get anywhere by yourself,” Casey said. “So many people have helped me along the way, and I’m incredibly grateful for that.”

'Politics to comic books'

Advertise with us

Talking baseball with Casey can be a fascinating — and hilarious — experience. He considers Randy Johnson the “nastiest” pitcher he faced. Roy Halladay was “the most uncomfortable” at-bat because of his six pitches and heavy fastball.

“Even when you squared him up, it felt like a bowling ball coming off your bat,” Casey said of Halladay.

Through MLB Network, Casey can recite his lifetime averages against Johnson (.333) and Greg Maddux (.364) and said his favorite pitcher to face was the late Jose Lima, against whom Casey was 9 for 25 (.360) with five home runs.

“When he got traded to the American League in 2001, I was like, ‘No!’” Casey said, laughing again.

Jim Leyland was an obvious pick for favorite manager, while Lance Berkman is the player Casey got along with the best. Although he likely would’ve talked to a rock if it somehow reached first base, Casey said he and Berkman had similar personalities. It also helped that Berkman wasn’t a base-stealing threat.

Advertise with us

“If he singled with no outs in the first, we’d cover everything from politics to comic books,” Casey said.

A unique and gifted storyteller, Casey has myriad tales from his playing days. Like his rookie year, when Rickey Henderson ignored the youngster who might’ve been trying too hard, then bolted for second. (“When you’re Rickey Henderson with some schlep who just came up, you don’t talk to that guy,” Casey said.)

The best story might be one involving Gwynn, who was struggling — by his lofty standards — at the time, with Mr. Padre beginning that July 17, 1998 game at Cinergy Field in Cincinnati hitting .309. Gwynn homered in his first two at-bats and walked in his third.

When Gwynn reached first base, Casey complemented him on the bombs.

“He’s like, ‘No, dude. That’s not my swing. My swing doesn’t hit home runs. My swing is hitting that five-hole [between short and third]’ ” Casey said.

Advertise with us

“I remember thinking, ‘Wow, what a talent, to hit .310 and think you’re struggling.’ He was so pissed, and I was just like, ‘Yeah, good luck finding that five-hole again! Hope you don’t hit too many homers, especially against the Reds!’ ”

'Keep moving forward'

The Gwynn story, oddly enough, offers a perfect segue into more of Casey’s life.

Another time when the Padres legend reached first, Casey asked for a bat, something he routinely did during his career. Gwynn sent over his typical, 32-inch model, complete with the tennis-style grip that has become popular now.

That bat is now one of around 180 in Casey’s collection, along with 400 or so baseballs that he amassed. The massive haul shows Casey’s passion for the game and also how far he’s come from that kid who would attend baseball card conventions at the old Greentree Marriott.

Advertise with us

The wealth of memorabilia adorns the studio used to record Casey’s podcast, which is a must-listen for baseball fans of any age and has seen a sizable uptick in traffic, the show now averaging a few thousand downloads per week.

The All-Star lineup has included guests such as Johnny Bench, Berkman, John Smoltz, Dustin Pedroia and more.

“If you’re a baseball fan, it’s almost like you’re in the clubhouse because they really let their guard down, especially in this setting and with me being a former player,” Casey said. “It’s really cool. I’m looking to grow that.”

The podcast has also helped Casey channel his energy — and there’s no shortage of it, though he claims he rarely drinks coffee — into what else he wants to do, which is dive deeper into mental skills, specifically as they relate to baseball.

Casey recently took Twitter and Instagram off his phone, unhappy with the stranglehold he felt those apps had on him. He also worries about the difficulties that today’s social-media culture presents for players.

Advertise with us

Half-assed about nothing, Casey talks a lot about living in the moment, breathing and focusing on the task at hand, something he’s been able to do for a long time.

As for influences, Tony Robbins and David Goggins are two of the more popular ones Casey cited, although he’s quick to riff on his own experiences and how they’ve shaped him.

Like in 2006, when he misread a line drive and became the first (and only) MLB player to get thrown out at first from left field. Casey battled back to leg out an infield hit later in the game and hit .529 with a pair of home runs in the World Series that fall.

“I literally wanted to crawl in a hole,” Casey said. “But when life gives you tough times, you gotta flip the switch in your mind and go, ‘Bring it on. I’m not gonna go hide in a corner.’

“You keep showing up, keep moving forward, and good things are gonna happen.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.