Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Been a few weeks since we did one of these -- the logistics of covering minor league camp prevented it -- but I thought it would be a good time to get back on the horse ... right before I fly back. Ha. You know the drill. Leave 'em now. Will be back around noon to answer.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Let's do this.

Greg: Jason, Hope all is well. With the pitching being so unsettled do you think that we will have more openers than usual this season? And do you think this is a make or break year for Mitch Keller?

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Greg. Same to you. ... I'll handle the second part first: absolutely. I think there's a fair amount of skepticism that Keller will ever deliver on the considerable hype that came with him. Maybe he will, maybe he won't. But it has to come this year. If not, in my opinion, he will surely be labeled a bust.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: And re: openers ... I think you could see some of that, yeah. More possible, though, I'm expecting to see shorter starts and possibly piggyback situations.

Marc: Hi Jason, enjoy your work as always. I've been following the CBA negotiations all winter and I just don't see any benefit with what's being discussed for the Pirates. It's insane to me that there's virtually no discussion of implementing a system like the NFL where teams are required to spend at a certain level (salary floor) and capped to ensure there is economic parity. Baseball has lost so much of its relevance over the past 30+ years, not because games are too long but because there are too many teams who cannot compete for the best free agents or cannot retain their best players.

Jason Mackey: FWIW, I agree with you, Marc. I'm 100% behind a cap-and-floor system. People who aren't haven't looked closely enough at the other sports, to see what's possible. Are good players in the NFL hurting right now? The NBA? Didn't think so. And those leagues hold fans' interest because there's parity and, at least most of the team, all entrants have a shot. Said from the beginning, I think they'll scurry to get something done, and it won't be what's best for the sport. Looks like that's what we have here.

John in SC: Good morning Jason. Thanks for the chats. I love the game, but MLB is a mess. Why is there such an objection to a salary cap/ floor? A cap would prevent the high revenue teams from “hoarding” the top players. Really, what difference does it make if G. Cole gets a $350M contract or a $300M contract? A floor would force teams like the Pirates to spend more and maybe even keep some of their players instead of becoming a training ground for other teams. MLB would ultimately become a more competitive sport. Isn’t that a good thing for us lowly fam

Jason Mackey: I know, John. You're preaching to the choir. And if MLB becomes more mainstream -- it's so far away right now it's scary -- then everyone would win; money would certainly be more plentiful. Like I said before, I don't get it, other than a fear of the unknown, not wanting to give up what MLB (and its players) believe is a better system (I disagree) and prioritizing the immediate over the big picture.

Advertise with us

PrinceBob: It's good to see you still seem to be the Pirates' beat writer. When I saw some of your stories about Penn State I wondered if you'd found a new career.

Jason Mackey: Ha. No. You're still stuck with me, Gunner. I don't like inactivity. I would rather be writing and doing things. I think it adds perspective to my full-time job (this), makes me appreciate what I have (access) and also indulged what became a passion: college football. Oh, and I got to go to Tampa for a week, so that didn't suck.

PrinceBob: My question is if you like the rule changes that seem to have been agreed on. I despise the DH so we can let that go. But how do you feel about eliminating the shift? Do you think it will affect better teams more than weaker ones? It seems to me that it was a way for a team with weak pitching to hide a bit of that weakness.

Jason Mackey: Honestly -- this might be surprising -- I'm fairly neutral on the shift. I can make arguments for or against it. What I really like is the pitch clock. Hugely for that. I think that will help with pace of games. Bases are whatever. I don't think it'll do anything substantive. And DH, I don't love it, but I'm like you, I made my peace with it a while ago. Baseball, IMO, needs to be a hell of a lot more interesting than it is now. If that helps even a little -- I don't know if it will or not -- then fine.

Jeff: Good morning. I know the lockout is dominating the news these days. When an agreement is reached, do you think we'll have a fixed economic system, or will we still have our haves and have-nots? In my opinion, we would need some radical changes for that to happen. I don't know if the MLBPA would go for it.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Based on everything I've read and heard, sadly, I don't think this new CBA (whenever it's finalized) will produce the necessary amount of change.

PrinceBob: And how much faster will having a time limit between pitches speed up the games? What I've read is that in the minors it did so very, very, slightly and if so, what's the point of doing it in the majors? I think all of the tweaks they make to speed up games won't have much affect as long as we have the "homer/walk/strike out" game they play today with nearly every batter going deep into the pitch count.

Jason Mackey: The pitch clock they want has sliced 20 minutes or so off of minor league games. Is that enough? No. But it's also not nothing.

Wayward: Jason, thanks for the chat! Other than SP(S), where do you see the Bucs looking to add to the roster once spring training starts? Also do you think there will be any spring training trades of someone like Stratton, etc., or will they wait to closer to the trading deadline like normal.

Jason Mackey: I would expect them to keep Stratton, at least up until the deadline. The need some solidity, and Stratton provides that. Now, do they try and trade Newman, Gamel or someone else? Potentially. A place where they're better equipped to back-fill. I could still see them adding a pitcher or two. Not sold on Perez as a backup C. Someone with position versatility -- basically what Phillip Evans appeared to be at one point but wasn't -- also wouldn't hurt.

Advertise with us

Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus: Just a comment. I was watching clips on YouTube recently of games from the late 70s. It's amazing to see how few times batters left the box between pitches and how often pitchers were ready to throw after receiving the ball. It wouldn't fix all of pace of the game issues but if players were more ready to hit and pitch, it would speed up the game.

Jason Mackey: I've thought the exact same thing while watching old games. I respect their desire to change batting gloves, breathe, etc. But they're not the first people in the world who have been asked to make decisions in a shorter amount of time than they'd like. It is possible.

Guy: Why did the Pirates cut Colin Moran other thanthe usual save money transaction? It makes no sense how they operate and give away players with value.

Jason Mackey: Because his skill set was redundant with Yoshi. And you can't always divide playing time and expect each guy to produce the same; in other words, DH is a learned skill. They tried to trade Moran. If the return would've been halfway decent, they would have gone that route. But he's been hurt a bunch, and Yoshi probably does offer greater offensive upside. Not sure I see the problem with that move that you do.

Frank: If and when the lock out ends what do you think Cutch would sign for and would he be a fit for there DH?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No, no, no and no. Oh, and no. This has been addressed by both parties. It's not happening. Cutch is coming off a decent year. Why would he want to come here to lose 100 games when he doesn't have to? The Pirates are in the middle of a full-scale rebuild. Why would they sign a rental outfielder who maaaaay be OK -- he's also not young and coming off major knee surgery, as much as I like Cutch -- and best-case could be dealt for a so-so prospect at the deadline. People are gonna scream, "But the fans! Gesture of goodwill!" A better one would be not screwing up the rebuild.

Murry: Hi Jason. Assuming no progress in negotiations, will the minor leaguers be playing spring games in Bradenton (or are they already), or is it just a training camp exercises to get in shape for when the season starts in Altoona, etc.? If yes on games, anywhere I can go to get a schedule? I wouldn't mind seeing the young guys play a few games.

Jason Mackey: They already are doing this, Murry. And there's been progress in talks. The lockout could end today, although the idea of an international draft seems like a pretty big issue right now. Workouts at Pirate City are closed to fans, unfortunately. Pirates are one of roughly 10 teams that have chosen to go this route. I don't make the rules, but I will say they've been logical through COVID, and it probably isn't worth risking your players' health so someone can watch Henry Davis take batting practice. I've asked on a schedule and have not gotten anything back to this point.

John in SC: Hi Jason. Glad the chats are back. My question is why can’t the owners and union agree on a salary cap/ floor? The high revenue teams are going to spend anyway. Low revenue teams probably can’t spend to the cap but a floor would force them to pay the players more. The current system awards only the highest paid players and the owners, but us lowly fans get left behind. A more competitive MLB only helps in the long run..

Jason Mackey: I wish I had an answer for you, John. I don't. Best attempt is that players want to make all they can; they don't want to be limited. Meanwhile, large-market owners have the CBT threshold and don't want another thing ... unless the small-market teams are forced to spend more.

Advertise with us

ev: Hi Jason, Regarding Jason Martin, your article mentioned that some team may take him in the Rule 5 draft. Although that is common practice, would it not be a failure of their building with youth approach should they lose anyone to rule 5?

Jason Mackey: No, it wouldn't. If anything, it would be a compliment. It would mean they have too many talented players to fit on their 40-man roster. FWIW, I don't think they're going to lose Martin. He strikes out a bunch, and first baseman have historically not been popular Rule 5 adds. But losing someone in the Rule 5 doesn't mean your player development program stinks. Probably the opposite.

Justin: Who do you think the Steelers will bring in to be the week 1 starting QB, if anybody?

Jason Mackey: Oh, God, no. I beg of you: Please no more talk about the Steelers quarterback situation. The pervasiveness of this on sports talk radio in this town is obnoxious.

Justin: Do you think the Pirates bring in a guy to DH, or does that become a spot to give guys rests + get more existing guys as much PA as possible?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't think they will bring in strictly a DH. Now, I do think they could fold that spot into an acquisition. Like if New Guy bounced around and DH'd some days, cool. Or maybe New Guy plays first, and Yoshi DHs more. Also possible. But I don't see them bringing in someone strictly to DH.

Ryan: good afternoon Jason how has Henry Davis looked at minor league camp

Jason Mackey: Hi Ryan. Like a man amongst boys, honestly. Got a ton of power. Cannon arm. Works his tail off. Acts like a leader, always talking to people, etc. My only "knock" or concern would be the length of his swing, but I also don't think it's automatically an issue. I just wanna see how it plays. Kid could rise quick, though.

Austin: If and when the lockout ends, what do you think the pirates do as far as trades and FA acquisitions go? No negotiations with Reynolds makes me think there’s a chance he could be dealt…

Jason Mackey: I don't think they will trade Reynolds, at least not now. I think they're holding out hope -- and maybe they're insane for thinking this, I don't know -- that they can re-sign him. But they want to see more data on the type of player he is. It's also true they don't have to do anything now. So, I mean, there's a chance, if GMBC gets some absurd package. But I wouldn't say it's a good one.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: FA-wise, they need pitchers, a backup C and some utility help, potentially a fourth OF.

Logan: Hi Jason! When do you think we will find out the Pirates’ minor league assignments? And where do you expect Henry Davis to start the year?

Jason Mackey: Couple weeks for assignments. They're only starting into games. My feeling at this point is High-A. Obviously that could if he dominates in Florida. I also think the stay could be short. But given his lack of pro time last year, that makes the most sense to me. Then if he shows he's ready, move him up.

Wayward: If you had to guess, which of the young guys do you think makes the most strides this year?

Jason Mackey: "Young guys" is a broad term, but I'm guessing you mean among those I saw at Pirate City for minor league camp? I watched Brennan Malone throw. Not sure if "making strides" is the right term, but someone who could come out of semi-nowhere and impress? He would be my guy for that.

Advertise with us

Drew: A question away from the dollars and cents of the CBA...Each minor league team has someone designated as "general manager," but does that person have any oversight of the baseball operations or is that all controlled by the Pirates? So, for example, if Altoona's starting catcher and the backup get injured on consecutive nights, is it up to the Pirates to fill those roster spots or can the Altoona GM sign a journeyman like the fictional Crash Davis of Bull Durham fame?

Jason Mackey: Good question, Drew. It is up to the Pirates to staff those teams. The GM of a minor league team is more on the business side -- in charge of selling tickets, growing the brand, that sort of thing. The machinations on the baseball side are the Pirates' responsibility, obviously handling a couple different ways.

Justin: Prediction for opening day middle infield?

Jason Mackey: Newman and Chavis. I hope I'm wrong and we see Oneil Cruz at short.

Justin: Hearing of any particularly impressive performances from camp?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I was down there for 10 days, so I saw a bunch of them. Brennan Malone looked good, as I said. Jared Triolo is an awesome defender to watch live. Henry Davis comes as advertised. Nick Gonzales, so smooth, sneaky pop. Really like what I see out of Quinn Priester. Those are the biggest ones, I think.

Realist: Since K Rates are at an all time high and the need/want to add more excitement to the game…why is adjusting the mound never suggested? When P was dominant in the late 60’s, precisely that change brought about a resurgence in hitting. Why not make this adjustment again?

Jason Mackey: You mean dropping it, I assume? It's an interesting thought. And maybe they would consider it. Would imagine it has to be bargained, and not sure how much pitchers would want that. I know I would fight it.

Drew: I echo Tiberius' comment about the batters today not staying in the box. I have the 7th game of the 1960 series on DVD and if you watch that game the only time the batters left the batter's box between pitches is if they fouled one off and lost their balance. And that game (10-9 with multiple pitching changes made) was played in 2 hours and 36 minutes!

Jason Mackey: I'm well-aware, believe me. And to me, that's a big part of what baseball needs to do here: police itself. Baseball for a long time has posited the no-clock-on-this-thing idea. Cool. But if people aren't watching because a 2-1 game takes 3:45, and it's a damn snoozefest, we have a watchability problem.

Advertise with us

Justin: Do you like the concept of doing "ghost wins" for higher seeded teams in a 14 team playoff? I personally kinda do.

Jason Mackey: No, I don't. And I don't like the concept of a 14-team (or 12-team playoff) period. 162 games to eliminate 16 teams? That's silly. You play that many games for a reason. Then to subject something to the randomness of a three-game series? I get that some of that has to happen. You can't play an 80-game playoff series. But I want less, not more with this stuff.

Wayward: If the two sides reach an agreement within some framework of what is on the table do you think the players are getting enough? Increased luxury tax level, higher minimum salaries, bonus pool for pre-arb guys and a lottery for the first 6/7 draft picks. The owners would be getting higher luxury tax penalties, expanded playoffs, and an international draft. To me this is a win for the owners (again).

Jason Mackey: I think it depends still, on a lot. Hard to say. I think Papi's comments re: international draft need to be taken seriously. I, too, a, in favor of one, to improve the situation in the DR. But if doing it immediately won't accomplish that, then let's adjust. I also don't think what they're doing here makes the most sense for the sport big-picture. But comparing just straight financial asks, yeah, I mean, it's not horrible. I could make an argument that each side got some key stuff.

Justin: Do you think the Rule 5 is cancelled this year? Do you think it particularly matters if it doesn't? Seems to me like the most important function of the Rule 5 - the protection of the most deserving guys - has already occurred. Obviously the guys who would get picked are affected negatively, but that's just a handful of guys.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No, I don't think it gets canceled. You need to think about this from a player perspective: Some of these guys -- they might not say this publicly -- want to get drafted. It exists for guys who are blocking re: playing time. Cal Mitchell might be an example here. To get that player in a better spot to earn playing time. So, assuming there's a new CBA, I expect the Rule 5 draft to happen.

Tom: Hey Jason hope you are doing well! What moves do you think Pirates may make once lockout ends? Sign anyone? Trade anyone? I saw the report that the Marlins were ready to give up a large package of prospects for Bryan Reynolds but Jeter vetoed it at the end, but since Jeter is no longer with the marlins maybe that trade will he revisited?

Jason Mackey: I still haven't seen this mysterious report that Poni asked me about re: Reynolds. But please remember this: A team wanting to package a bunch of prospects for Reynolds isn't insane. Many teams have had those conversations. Cherington has listened. That doesn't mean they're trading Bryan Reynolds. And, hey, maybe someone with the Marlins did want to drop two top-100 guys, plus some stuff around that. If that was the case, Cherington should make that move.

Jason Mackey: Anyway, got this before: I expect them to address pitching, plus maybe some utility/depth stuff and another outfielder.

Logan: Do you think teams have still worked on trades/signings during dead period “secretly”. Once the lockout ends maybe teams already have agreements in place and we will see a flurry of moves?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think you will see a flurry of moves, Logan. Was actually joking about that with a front office exec this morning. But, no. It's not because they've back-channeled things. Both parties have been pretty careful about staying apart from one another during this time.

Justin: What are a few of your favorite snacks to eat

Jason Mackey: Yes, Justin! You win the prize for asking something non-baseball. Ha. ... Right now I've been on a big pistachio kick, for whatever reason. I'm also a huge popcorn enthusiast and tend to munch pretzels with my beer. Occasionally some chopped up veggies. And pro Double-Stuffed Oreos, Ben & Jerry's ice cream and cereal of any type.

Jeff: Interested to hear how Burrows has looked during spring training

Jason Mackey: Like a top-of-the-board pitching prospect. I think he can be something special. That said, I didn't see him face hitters, so obviously my comments here should be tempered. But I like Burrows a lot.

Advertise with us

Dean: Will the Rule 5 draft happen this year?

Jason Mackey: I think so, yes.

Justin: Better career going forward: Cole Tucker or Kevin Newman

Jason Mackey: Oh, boy. I'm gonna go Newman. If nothing else, I think he showed this past season that he can hold down a job as a defense-first SS, a Clint Barmes type. And there's nothing wrong with that. I don't know what Tucker is at this point.

Guest: Have you seen much of Hudson Head in camp? How did he look. You see the body type and think of Christian Yelich, but his results obviously don't.

(I liked the Crash Davis reference earlier, but it makes me laugh any time I see that movie. A good defensive catcher who handles pitchers well and has some power--that guy gets a 10-year career in the majors; he's not someone stuck in the minors)

Jason Mackey: I think a Hudson Head > Christian Yelich comp is a big aggressive. Nothing against Hudson, but that's a pretty big leap. Didn't see a ton of him working out, honestly. We talked to him. He has stopped tinkering with his swing and has tried to tamp down the strikeouts through better plate discipline. Has a decent arm. Can generate pop. But need to see much more consistent contact out of him once games start.

Wayward: There seem to be some reports that MLB wants to implement the international draft in 2024. What your thoughts? Also, is an international draft good, or bad, news for the Bucs?

Jason Mackey: I'll take the second part first, if you don't mind. I think it would be good for them, honestly. You can knock the Pirates for not spending enough, and that's certainly fair. But they are pretty decent internationally, especially on the scouting end. Would think an international draft jibes with those abilities. And I like the idea. I would just listen to Big Papi and those in the Dominican if they tell me it's better to do a slow rollout. You wanna get this right. Doesn't have to be immediate.

Robert Nutting: This labour stoppage of my Baseball company is all my doing. Not the other Baseball company owners. Not the Commissioner. Not the Baseball company employees or players as you non Billionaires call them. All on me. You're welcome poor people

Jason Mackey: Of all the questions & comments I've received during this chat, this is one.

john sweeney: Jason, the 2021 Pirates were the worst team in baseball, can they do it again.

Jason Mackey: Very possibly, John. They don't have a lot of depth. I'm iffy on their pitching and power. Their bullpen has more question marks than steady contributors. The good thing is I think they will be interesting this year. A lot of guys making their MLB debuts. Maybe they surprise. But, yeah, challenging for the worst record wouldn't surprise me.

They stink: Even if they only play 120 games, the Pirates still lose 100+. Agreed ?

Jason Mackey: You really think they're gonna go 20-100? I don't see how they win 20. ... Nah, I'm just kidding. It's not gonna be that bad!

1960: Why is there so little interest in MLB to protect small-market teams? Is it a decision at the top that that's where they make their money or is it that small-market teams are raking in cash regardless of whether they win, so the small-market teams are content with that?

Jason Mackey: Good point, 1960. I think it's more the type of thing where, the more money you have, the greater influence you have. And I don't even know if that's wrong. But someone, or a group of people, should have the sense to realize that the best thing for the group is to put some rules in place like a cap and floor. But I don't see it happening.

Wayward: Jason, thanks for the chats, you do the best job of any of the PPG staff of answering any and all questions thoroughly! Also we as subscribers need some spring training as we are off our game! Only a handful of sign Cutch and no "Nutting is cheap", "Nutting needs to sell the team", "fire everyone" or "I am not paying money to watch this" questions/statements. We''ll do better once the games start!

Jason Mackey: Haha. Thanks, Wayward. I really do like these. And yinz are the reason I get to do what I do for a living. I always try to appreciate and remember that. ... Also, it's spring training for everyone, me included.

Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus: I'm fully supportive of a cap and floor system. But that's going to require the owners to open their books. And I've seen no indication that any of these owners are willing to divulge their true financial picture to the players. Call me nuts, but I think if the owners would come clean the players might actually go along with a capo and floor.

Jason Mackey: You could do a cap-and-floor system without a total opening of books. I know what you're saying -- and you're right. No way they'll open 'em if they don't have to. But I don't think that's the issue preventing a cap and floor.

Why ?: Why are the local government leaders so in love with the owner that they refuse to demand he open his books ? He gets tax money. I guarantee there are financial misdeeds occurring. Don't boycott. Call your State Reps and demand they make him accountable. Hell force him to sit in front of State government hearing and answer questions

Jason Mackey: What power would local government leaders have over Major League Baseball? Believe me, I wanna see the Pirates open their books. I wanna see all teams open their books. But as Peduto told me a couple years ago, they have no legal authority to do anything about it: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2019/10/17/bill-peduto-pit...

Jason Mackey: And again, I'm not defending Nutting or the Pirates. By all means, call away, take up government officials' attendance over baseball spending, doesn't affect me. But it's not like Ed Gainey is gonna walk over to PNC Park and be like, "OK, Bob. People are pissed. Gotta show 'em."

Why ?: He gets taxpayer money. He should be required to open them

Jason Mackey: I agree he/they should be required. But should be required and having a legal mechanism to do something are different. I think it's in the article, but Peduto/Gainey can't just demand Giant Eagle open its books because they don't like how much they're charging for milk. That's not how government works. Or shouldn't work.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's gonna do it for this week. Have a Thursday story to work on and a lockout to monitor. I may have to pack and fly to Florida for a month tomorrow, which is nuts. But in any case, thanks so much for doing this, as always. Talk to you next week from ... well, somewhere.