BRADENTON, Fla. — Cal Mitchell paused for a second, looked down and composed himself before answering the question, careful to convey his thoughts in a way that’s both truthful and not offensive to his employer.
Sure, Mitchell would explain, he wasn’t happy about being left unprotected for the Rule 5 draft, a decision the Pirates made when they had to set their 40-man roster in mid-November, before the ongoing lockout and what seems like an eternity ago now.
At the same time, nobody with Mitchell’s career profile — 22, having just finished a productive season at Class AA and close to pushing for big-league time — would be thrilled at being left out, believing that exclusion doubles as a lack of confidence.
Mitchell also isn’t about to let any of that change his focus.
“Teams make decisions for all kinds of reasons,” Mitchell said this week at Pirate City. “I can’t pretend to know every single one of ‘em. Yeah, I would have rather been protected than not. But I’m gonna play as well as I can.”
It was a solid answer to a fair question, one that has a few layers to it. If the Pirates are going to carry out a successful rebuild, the back end of that is they can’t protect everyone; some good players will be exposed and poached.
Read More
Pirates prospect Cal Mitchell on spring training and next steps
From Mitchell’s perspective, it’s also fair to feel you’ve earned a 40-man spot. In 115 games last season, the 2017 second-round pick (50th overall) hit .279 with a .751 OPS, 20 doubles, 12 home runs, 62 RBIs and 44 runs scored.
Mitchell sliced his strikeout rate from 28.8% in 2019 to 16.9% last season and earned a late-season cameo with Class AAA Indianapolis, where he’s expected to start in 2022.
“I told myself before the year that I wasn’t gonna strike out as much,” Mitchell said. “I figured out how to do that from practicing training my eyes better, practicing setting my body up in a position where I could hold off on those pitches more often and changing any number of things.”
What Mitchell can’t change is the amount of talent around him — and he’s hardly complaining. Curve teammates Jack Suwinski and Canaan Smith-Njigba earned roster spots, and Mitchell is nothing short of thrilled for them. Travis Swaggerty, same deal.
Mitchell knows it’s a numbers game, that he’s hardly the only quality player who other teams will entertain taking, and he’s fine with that. He’s significantly more concerned with accomplishing his own goals, stuff like not settling for singles as much as he did in 2021 or generating more consistent power when he does sell out for a particular pitch.
“To try and pretend like there aren’t other good players who play my position in the system would be silly,” Mitchell said. “That doesn’t matter to me, whether they’re good or not. I know what I can do. I know what I’m working toward. Eventually, I’ll get to where I want to be regardless.”
Like a few guys — and assuming the MLB lockout is ever settled — Mitchell is absolutely one of the prime candidates to be selected in the Rule 5 draft, not only because of the flexibility the universal designated hitter rule would add but also because of Mitchell’s athleticism and professional approach.
Think about it: Tahnaj Thomas has an electric arm but made just 12 starts in 2021 while battling significant control problems. Sticking on an MLB roster might be tough.
Mason Martin has a ton of power but whiffed 171 times in 498 plate appearances last season. He also plays a position — first base — that isn’t historically isn’t very popular in the Rule 5 draft.
Cody Bolton hasn’t pitched since 2019, Eddy Yean regressed … you get the idea.
“It’s out of my control,” Martin said this week when asked about the possibility that he, too, could be selected in the Rule 5 draft. “The only things I can focus on are just showing up to the park every day with a great attitude, ready to get better, ready to have a great game and ready to have a great day.”
As for Mitchell, this upcoming season will be huge for the Rancho Bernardo High (San Diego) product, a left-handed bat who’s considered the Pirates’ 18th-best prospect by MLB Pipeline.
Mitchell has used the past couple of years to add weight, and that additional power has been noticeable when you watch him swing. There’s also a confidence to his movement in the outfield, a maturity not shown by every prospect here.
“I’m just trying to get better,” Mitchell said. “This time of year, you always want to make sure you start off healthy, set yourself up for those days late in the season and hone some skills that might’ve troubled you the year before.”
Mitchell thus far has looked very much like someone focused on the task at hand. It also seems like he’s ready to prove that he deserves a 40-man spot sooner than later.
“If I make it to the league with the Pirates, all good,” Mitchell said. “If it’s not with the Pirates, all the same.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.