It’s a long-standing narrative, right or wrong, that Pirates owner Bob Nutting makes a substantial profit, in large part due to Major League Baseball’s revenue-sharing process.

It’s a long-standing fan criticism — and a perfectly legitimate one — that MLB would be better off with a cap-and-floor system, a way to simultaneously force owners like Nutting to spend while keeping financial sluggers such as the Dodgers, Yankees and Red Sox in check.

While that’s unlikely to happen, there’s a solution available, one that’s surprisingly not getting much run right now.

Instead of drastically overhauling the financial composition of baseball’s revenue-sharing system, which the MLB Players Association has advocated for and the owners have remained steadfastly against, all it might take is a little tweak, a change not terribly dissimilar from what happens in European soccer.

Advertise with us

If small-market teams receive a piece of the revenue-sharing pie and have success, cool. Don’t change a thing. The Tampa Bay Rays (fourth in wins since 2017 despite a bottom-three payroll in four of those five years) would be a shining example. But if those additional dollars don’t change anything, the team receiving them must pay some money back.

The Pirates, with the sixth-fewest wins during that stretch, could be a potential example of this second way of doing business. (Their payroll has gone from 24th in 2017, per Baseball Prospectus, to last each of the past two seasons.)

Would reshaping revenue-sharing in this way irritate some teams? Sure. And the Pirates might be one of them, although you’d have to build in some leniency for legitimate rebuilds and farm system overhauls, recognizing that this way of team-building does take more time than going buck-wild on the free agent market.

But it also might be worth it to address a couple things that baseball sorely lacks.

Much of the discussion surrounding the MLB lockout has involved preserving (more creating) competitive integrity. For a variety of reasons, including the lack of cap and floor, baseball lacks the parity seen in other sports, most notably the NFL.

Advertise with us

Eleven teams either won or lost 95 games in 2021, while the gap between the largest and smallest MLB payroll was $195 million, a figure seven times as large as what’s seen in the NHL.

Although it’s tough to boil the ongoing lockout down into one, singular issue, it might be possible when talking about the unevenness of the current playing field; no fan should feel as though their team has zero chance, and it’s a recurring problem in MLB.

So why not do something that might actually elicit some applause from both sides of the aisle?

Players contend teams like the Pirates are taking revenue-sharing dollars and making half-hearted attempts at winning by repurposing them into such things as player development (fancier equipment, coaching) or international academies.

On the flip side, small-market clubs argue that the best way to spend isn’t on one year of [insert overpriced pitcher’s name here] and instead by trying to recreate that performance for less while spending the savings on infrastructure and processes that are more sustainable.

Advertise with us

We’ll never know who’s right or wrong because MLB teams don’t make their books publicly available, but it’s also hard to believe that fans really care. They just want to see their team win, and they’re hardly wrong for feeling that way. Which is why this mechanism would conceivably help toward that end.

Creating some sort of penalty for repeated failure might sound harsh to some, especially if said small-market team was making a legitimate effort toward putting a winning product on the field and failed.

It’s also a bottom-line business. Good, well-intentional people lose jobs all the time for much less. But if the financial penalties were steep enough, do you think teams would try like hell to spend those dollars in a meaningful way to try and avoid penalties? Absolutely.

At minimum, it would show fans that MLB and its teams care, that the appearance of tanking or endless rebuilds were not OK, that incremental improvements would have to occur.

That, of course, doesn’t mean it’ll happen or address the entire issue. The Pirates, Rays and other perennial bottom-dwellers with puny payrolls — the Orioles, Guardians and Marlins, to cite a few — probably wouldn’t welcome this idea under any circumstance, but certainly not without some sort of accompanying impact on the bigger spenders.

Advertise with us

A current, contentious point has been the Competitive Balance Tax threshold, a place that must seem about as familiar as Jupiter to Pirates fans. Owners are willing to hike it from $210 million to $214 million, which would start a five-year stretch where it finishes at $222 million in 2026. Players cite $245 million as a desired starting point.

Yeah, good luck with that.

But with MLB’s previously stated desire to discuss nothing related to revenue-sharing and players sick of watching teams perpetually sit in self-mandated timeout, their payrolls and win totals alarmingly low, perhaps there’s room to compromise here.

All it would take would be some outside-the-box thinking.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.