With MLB’s ongoing lockout, the Post-Gazette will use this time to further examine the Pirates’ farm system with pieces reported during multiple visits to the team’s spring training home in Bradenton, Fla.

Whenever Derek Shelton discusses the Pirates’ future, he likes to employ a certain phrase: Development must be the lifeblood of the organization. Well, nowhere on a baseball field is development more important than with pitchers, something Pittsburgh has obviously learned the hard way.

But with the farm system gaining notoriety — no one has the Pirates ranked lower than sixth in MLB, while Baseball America has them as high as third — this exercise is designed to explore the depth behind guys like Quinn Priester (MLB Pipeline No. 2) and Roansy Contreras, their sixth-best prospect.

It’s also important to look deeper than Carmen Mlodzinski, Michael Burrows or Jared Jones, who might be more familiar in terms of talent, pedigree and production. This list focuses on pitchers who can become those types.

Advertise with us

Omar Cruz, LHP, 23, Class AAA Indianapolis

Have every Pirates pitcher stand in a straight line, and Cruz ... well, he might be mistaken for the bat boy. But he sure didn’t pitch like it in 2021. Acquired as part of the Joe Musgrove trade, Cruz fared extremely well across two levels: 3.44 ERA in 21 starts, 98 strikeouts, 36 walks and a 1.24 WHIP across 99 1/3 innings.

Cruz (6-0, 200) is a soft-tossing left-hander with a funky delivery — Google it; looks like his pants or shoes are on fire — and a solid changeup. He doesn’t throw terribly hard, but he does throw strikes and knows how to pitch.

The craziest thing about Cruz’s 2021 season might be that he was promoted to Class AA out of necessity … then never left. Survival mode worked. Now Cruz could easily start at Class AAA Indianapolis this season.

“There wasn’t a huge difference in Class AA,” Cruz said in December. “I wasn’t trying to strike out more guys; I was more focused on getting outs.”

Advertise with us

Logan Hofmann, RHP, 22, High-A Greensboro

Hofmann is hardly a household name when it comes to Pirates prospects. He’s not ranked, and you now may have used Google a second time while reading this article. But in a year, chances are you’ll know more about the fifth-round pick from 2020.

The right-hander’s velocity is fine. It’s mid-to-low 90s consistently, and he throws four pitches. But one of them is a knee-buckling curve with a high spin rate (around 2,700 rpm), which should only get better in the pros.

Not only that, Hofmann had a solid year (3.59 ERA, 103 strikeouts and 33 walks in 82 2/3 innings) for Low-A Bradenton while shifting into a starting role midseason and never completely having his legs under him.

Hofmann talked in December about feeling run down late in the summer, how he learned a lot about maintaining his arm and body and also consistently using his lower half to generate velocity; too often in the past he’d fly open early and cede both velocity and control.

Advertise with us

“Those are things you learn in your first season in pro ball,” he said.

Cam Alldred, LHP, 25, Class AAA Indianapolis

On a list with Priester, Contreras and others, why are we talking about a 25-year-old who was sitting in the high-80s last year? Because Alldred, one, is left-handed, and, two, he’s a classic late bloomer.

A 24th-round pick out of Cincinnati in 2018, there’s nothing eye-popping about what Alldred does, unless you focus on the only thing that truly matters: getting outs.

This past season across two levels, Alldred had a 2.18 ERA in 33 relief appearances with two saves. Opponents hit just .192 off of him, and he had a 1.14 WHIP.

Advertise with us

Like many lefties, Alldred had what he described as a “crossfire.” Put another way: He was throwing across his body. It’s great for deception, but not so much for consistency or throwing hard. So the Pirates had Alldred adjust.

The result has been better velocity and consistency and a smaller crossfire.

"I definitely think I'm on a way better track now in terms of where I want to be,” Alldred said.

Cody Bolton, RHP, 23, Class AA Altoona

Not having a minor league season in 2020 was costly for all players but especially Bolton, who also underwent right knee surgery in May 2021, meaning he hasn’t pitched in a game since 2019.

Advertise with us

It’s hardly ideal for a former top-10 prospect who was previously considered next up when it came to MLB debuts.

Bolton (6-3, 230) is healthy again and has solid tools — a 60-grade fastball, plus an above-average slider and serviceable changeup — but it’s anyone’s guess how he might come back from so much time off.

Last time anyone saw Bolton, in 2019, he put up some monster numbers with a 3.28 ERA, 102 strikeouts and 30 walks in 101 2/3 innings across two levels, finishing at Class AA. It’s likely where he’ll begin 2022.

“When I first saw him a couple years ago, my first impression was, ‘Man, this guy is gonna be something special,’” former Curve manager Miguel Perez said. “Unfortunately, he's had some bumps in his career. We’re all looking forward to watching him pitch again.”

The 2021 draft class

Advertise with us

OK, cheating some here, but how do you not put Anthony Solometo, Bubba Chandler and Owen Kellington on a list like this? It’s also hard to say who might have the most upside.

Solometo (MLB Pipeline No. 17) had the best pre-draft ranking, while Chandler, a two-way player, is the most athletic. And Kellington obliterated the weaker competition he faced in Vermont, producing a 0.22 ERA and recording 91% of his outs via strikeout.

Getting excited to watch Solometo is easy. He’s been compared to Madison Bumgarner and essentially slingshots the ball to home plate. It’s also cool that the Pirates are letting Solometo be himself and not trying to pound the clay into any sort of predetermined shape.

“If you watch him throw, you immediately know, ‘OK, that’s different,’” said coordinator of pitching development Josh Hopper. “We need to take time to learn him so that we can do the best job of making decisions that are not going to hinder or paralyze him but hopefully make him flourish.”

The biggest thing for Chandler aside from the logistics of handling two positions has been cleaning up his arm path and refining his slider, which has picked up steam lately as an offering that tunnels well with his fastball.

Advertise with us

Kellington said he and his dad bought a Rapsodo the year before he was drafted and began tinkering on their own with data analysis. He, like many pitchers, also obsessively follows Pitching Ninja on Twitter and joined Tread Athletics, a pitching development company that customizes training.

Yet nothing has compared to Kellington making this his entire life, which is why he said he can’t wait to measure himself against better competition in 2022.

“I had some good coaching back in Vermont, but nothing as high-level as this,” Kellington said. “I’m interested to see this next season how I stack up against some of the guys that I’ll be facing.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.