Francisco Cervelli hasn’t sat down and watched a baseball game all year.

In fact, Wednesday at PNC Park was his first time inside a stadium since the 2020 season, his final one before retiring last October. Yet few players have Cervelli’s perspective on the Pirates’ current situation and what’s necessary to bring winning baseball back to Pittsburgh.

Speaking before the Pirates’ series finale against the Tigers, Cervelli described the chemistry that existed around the club during its last brush with success, the expectations created and the culture cultivated under former manager Clint Hurdle — things Derek Shelton and his players are trying to build now.

“I believe chemistry becomes your culture,” Cervelli said. “You figure out how you can have chemistry when the majority of guys are pulling one way. A new one comes in, and you tell him, 'This is what we do here. This is how we do it. We don't move from this path.’ ”

Advertise with us

That happened to Cervelli shortly after the Pirates acquired him from the Yankees for pitcher Justin Wilson on Nov. 12, 2014. Russell Martin was leaving to sign a five-year, $82 million deal with the Blue Jays, and Hurdle called Cervelli into his office to talk.

The conversation wasn’t just about taking over for a tremendous catcher in Martin or what the Pirates felt like Cervelli could do at the plate.

It was also about what was expected of Cervelli when it came to handling a pitching staff, how the Pirates went about preparing for games and what sort of culture had been established here.

That talk broke down barriers before they even developed, Cervelli said. It also set the stage for more success, with Cervelli ultimately becoming a perfect fit, beloved by pitchers, and enabling the Pirates to continue what Martin (and others) had started.

“You start opening the doors for you to open yourself,” Cervelli said. “And then sometimes when you’re struggling, you look for that person, and you fix your life real quick. It takes time, but you’ve got to keep the same group to build chemistry. If you just keep changing, it's not gonna happen.”

Advertise with us

The change that occurred post-2015 certainly isn’t news to Pirates fans, but Cervelli admitted that it hit the team particularly hard — specifically the organization’s decision to trade Neil Walker for Jon Niese and non-tendering Pedro Alvarez that November.

“That was a big hit for us because Walker was a fan favorite, and we all loved that guy,” Cervelli said. “Pedro could fix the game in one swing. It was very tough for us to adapt."

It's hardly breaking news that the club never fully recovered. Finishing 82-79 was their only other time over .500, and Cervelli said frustration was inevitable. It also didn't help that he was hurt a lot, performances dipped, and the Pirates endured their fair share of off-field shortcomings — a smaller payroll, lopsided trades and problems drafting and developing.

What the Pirates had before it all came apart is the same sort of magic they’re trying to discover again, with the need for clubhouse leaders to emerge, better players to arrive and the prospect push to pan out.

But no matter what happens on the field, Cervelli said he’s a big believer that a club’s chemistry absolutely has to start at the top.

Advertise with us

“Whatever you do upstairs, you feel it downstairs,” Cervelli said. “There should be no filter.”

While he hasn’t spent a ton of time around Derek Shelton, Cervelli said he has heard a bunch of good things about the Pirates manager from his former teammates, some of whom have also left Pittsburgh. “I hear Shelton is amazing,” Cervelli said.

He’s also in a tough spot, with the Pirates trying to compete and create that culture while lacking enough talent at the major league level and again finishing at the bottom when it comes to spending on their MLB payroll. But regardless of the situation, this is where the groundwork should be laid, Cervelli said.

Echoing something general manager Ben Cherington has talked about recently, the Pirates need to focus on putting the right processes in place so that when they do finally start to get more talent up here, that winning culture and the proper way of doing things has already been established.

“They’re trying to rebuild,” Cervelli said. “You’re going to see a lot of mistakes, but that’s the only way they’re going to learn. You’ve got to make those mistakes now, then it gets to a point where everybody is on the same page, they know what to do, and they know how to win games.

Advertise with us

“What they have to create now is a winning environment. Even if you don’t win, the mentality needs to be there.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.