Jason Mackey: Hi, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. Thanks, as always, for joining. Have some stuff going on this afternoon that may cut us short; so, we're likely going to get started before noon.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. We're just gonna get rolling now in case I need to take off early.
RS: Thanks for the chats! Is the rosters only expanding to 28 just a result of covid protocols? I understand that completely but will it return to 40 once we finally get past this? It would help teams like the Pirates to give a few more guys some MLB experience. Plus it gives us fans a chance to get a look at some Pirates that may still be here in a year or two.
Jason Mackey: Hey, RS. Yes, it's the result of COVID protocols. And, no, I don't think it makes sense. I also don't think the Pirates like it. I think there's a middle ground here. 40 was too many. 28 is too few. I would hope that after this season, as part of the new CBA, they settle around 35 or so. Enough to help small-market teams and not too many so the games aren't 4-hour slogs.
V. Fontaine: Do you have any sense that the Pirates are interested in bringing back Tsutsugo next year? He seems to have legitimate power, which the roster lacks. The fact that he had a lot of success in Japan would seem to indicate there's some there there, if you will. I'm not expecting him to be an All Star but possibly a nice bench or part-time starter for a team in transition.
Jason Mackey: No doubt. I think there's interest there. I also think there's time. Their play here is going to see more. My answer to this sort of thing has basically been John Nogowski. If Tsutsugo keeps up what he's doing, absolutely you have a conversation and see if you can get something done. You also need to remember that if Tsutsugo is really good, the Pirates won't be the only team interested. So then it becomes, what's his best offer? Does he want to be here? That sorta thing. But could there be a fit with him, absolutely.
Read More
V. Fontaine: We hear a lot about the top prospects hitting but I'm curious about any defensive shortcomings. To quote Casey Stengel, "I don't like them fellas who drive in two runs and let in three."
Jason Mackey: You've heard plenty about Oneil Cruz playing shortstop and some of his development there. I'm not sure what else you feel like is missing. Marcano is very good defensively. And versatile. His issue has been hitting. You've seen Castro. Bae is a solid defender, the same for Gonzales. I'm just picking out random guys, but I don't think there are glaring issues. The more important part is being able to hit.
Destiny: How many Pirate players on this roster do you think would be starters on the Dodgers?
Jason Mackey: That's a tough apples-to-apples question, but Bryan Reynolds is an easy one. I would have to think they would want Ke'Bryan Hayes, although the fact that they have Justin Turner shouldn't be a knock on Hayes. Stallings might be a platoon. So, maybe add 'em up and say 1 1/2 or 2?
Prince Bob: If there is a work stoppage next season what issues will be the big sticking points?
Jason Mackey: Good question, Gunner. Lots of stuff, honestly. I think baseball needs to drastically revamp its economic system, to be honest. A cap and a floor should be issues discussed. Revenue sharing, too. Probably how much players are getting, as well as division alignment, the use of the DH, sticky substances, roster sizes ... all kinds of stuff. But for me, the biggest has to be settling on a financial arrangement that benefits both sides. And I think it can be done.
Prince Bob: Do you think a stoppage is more likely, less likely, or about the same as you did at the start of the season?
Jason Mackey: Given what we heard from Tony Clark and Rob Manfred at the All-Star Game, honestly, I'm more optimistic than I was at the start of the season. They're talking. They seem to realize how bad a strike would look. I view that as encouraging. Definitely did not feel that way at the start of the season.
Justin R.: Hey Jason -- Saw a couple of your tweets re: the interview with John Baker. How fundamentally different is the development approach as compared to the last management group? The MiLB results this season seem mostly quite encouraging, but I want to temper my expectations.
Jason Mackey: Night and [bleeping] day. Honestly. John Baker is incredibly bright. How they're doing things under him, man, it's such a breath of fresh air. I really, really like him. And they have a bunch of good people under him, especially with the affiliates. If you're worried because of what the major league team has done in the past, I guess I get it. But I see no reason not to get excited about the farm system.
Ryan: jason what do you think about the play of yoshi recently and Bednar go pirates the rest of the season
Jason Mackey: Hey Ryan. How can you not love it? He's a DH. If it's in the NL next year, there's no way I play him in the field unless I have to. But, man, he can hit. We've seen that. I like the bat and power a lot. Bednar should be their closer. And probably will be. He's downright nasty. A back-end reliever with three pitches and a 98 mph heater with control and a great makeup? Yeah, that'll make you some money. Bednar is in the Hayes, Reynolds camp for me, future pieces who should be here awhile.
Jeff: What might a fair to both sides Bryan Reynolds look like?
Jason Mackey: With all due respect, Jeff, there are people who make a lot of money coming up with these valuations, for both sides. They're also nuanced. Would Reynolds take less because he really likes it here? How much does he value certainty and not doing this again versus wanting to maximize value? I hate answering these questions because it's so hard to be anywhere close to right. And I don't wanna be a jerk and say, "Well, whatever they agree on." I've said before somewhere between Polanco and Cutch, but, one, that's a wide range. And, two, it's probably unfair to Reynolds to base a possible contract for him on two different players.
Brendan: Hey Jason - random but kinda going off the question above about John Baker/player dev, do you have any idea why the Pirates insisted minor league players wore their socks high/were so anal about certain things in their lockers, etc? Always seemed strange from a group that was heavy on analytics, etc. Just a Kyle Stark thing? Thank you!
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure why they were so particular about that stuff, Brendan. It does seem like things are much looser now. Players are encouraged to be themselves and have some fun. Meanwhile, what they're doing -- I'm told -- is more baseball-specific and probably overall much more useful. Lastly, I think there are other things this group does differently in terms of placements and promotions that ultimately influence how players develop. I think they're also more ... I don't think pushy is the right word, but eager to integrate tech into what they do.
Joel: Hi, Jason. Great to see so much prospects coverage, especially the interviews. Please keep it up. I must say, though, I guess I’m old school and would prefer to have young guys who settle in and focus on one defensive position. Plus, in the majors we’ve seen way too many infielders with no power making a hash of playing the outfield while contributing nothing offensively. What are your thoughts on the extreme position flexibility that the Pirates seem to be promoting?
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Joel. Glad you've noticed. To me, that's the most important part of the organization right now. Numbers-wise, too, they do much better than staid, day-to-day coverage of the big league team. So, there will be more. ... To your point, I have no issue with it. I'm a big believer in his first, figure out a place to play later. For a team like the Pirates, they also need to be mindful of what position are open. You don't want a good, cheap prospect blocked because he only plays one position and the guy ahead of him on the depth chart only plays one position. So, you need to flexible. I also think some people do better sticking to one thing -- I'm not one of them -- and the Pirates need to identify those guys and leave them alone.
Jason Mackey: Not his first, hit first.
Canyon: Is the hitting coach going to be the only firing this season/offseason? Also why did they fire him at such a weird time?
Jason Mackey: I think it's still TBD, Canyon. I would say that just because they fired Eckstein, it does not mean everyone else is safe. I think it's just that they knew Eckstein was gonna be gone, so they figured they would get a jump on hiring a replacement, plus gain some info on the type of person they need to hire. There seems to be this narrative that they're doing something nefarious here. What sort of controversial thing could they be doing by firing the hitting coach of the league's worst offense for two straight years with a month left? If the Penguins did this, no one would bat an eye lash. But the Pirates do it, and it's like they're trying to cover up Watergate or something. I don't get it.
Prince Bob: Why do the Pirates keep sending runners from third home when a dribbler is hit to a drawn in infield?
Jason Mackey: Shelton runs the contact play a lot. I think he does it because he feels that runs are going to be at a premium, with which I don't disagree. Last night I thought was the wrong call. Tsutsugo on deck, Perez running. I'm telling him to hold. But that's just me. Generally speaking, I'm OK with Shelton being aggressive on the bases because they don't get a ton of chances to score.
Grasshopper: Is it concerning that Nick Gonzales has such a wide split between his home/road stats AND is K'ing over 30%? He is a college bat who should be doing well in High A, correct? Will Altoona be his true test before we get too excited about him?
Jason Mackey: I don't believe that home/road splits for a player in Class A in less than a full season should determine who he is or is not. I don't get the adhere to this stuff. What do we think is happening on the road? He forgets how to hit? Gets uncomfortable? Scared? Confused? It's a small sample and overblown, IMO. The strikeouts matter; even his 24% (roughly) since Aug. 1 is a little high. But he's also young. That stuff will improve. Minor league players strike out and make errors. it's why they're in the minors. Gonzales is about the last thing I'd worry about right now. He'll be fine.
Prince Bob: If Bednar seems like he'll be the closer, what do you make of having him as set up man with Stratton closing in the last couple(?) of games? And do you think Stratton will be here next year?
Jason Mackey: Shelton is playing the leverage. Bednar came in to face 3-4-5 in the eighth. Shelton would rather have that than Stratton goes 3-4-5 in the eighth and Bednar close. It's a way to let Bednar get more comfortable. And yeah, I could absolutely see Stratton being here. He's a quality reliever who can work multiple innings. Probably tradable next deadline, too.
Steven: I’ve been real impressed with Bryse Wilson. He’s not flashy but he gets out and gives you innings. So far it looks like we won the trade with ATL. Hopefully he keeps it up.
Jason Mackey: I think it's too early for win/lose on any trade, but I agree with you on Wilson; I like him a lot. I like how he attacks the zone. Has the stuff. Great makeup to the kid. He looks to me like a part of the '22 rotation, absolutely. A solid pickup.
Zach: Is the whole reason we're holding Gonzalez back from Altoona because of Greensboro's playoff push? I hope not, that seems stupid.
Jason Mackey: There's more to it than that. I will have more Thursday. Working on something I think you guys will enjoy. But, no. It's about building something together and a core group of players coming up together. I see value in that. What the Pirates have done in Greensboro this season has been cool, and I'm not even sure Nick wants to leave it. There will be time for that stuff.
Guest: When will the payroll reach the MLB average again? Currently
Jason Mackey: The average is skewed by absurd spenders, one. Two, I would say in 4-5 years -- probably less -- the Pirates will be spending significantly more than they are now. Last point: It doesn't matter as much as some people think. If they draft and develop well, they can pick their spots with where they spend. Yeah, they should spend more than they do now. A lot more. I'm not defending that. But I think there's often an over-adherence to that and not enough on the other stuff.
Guest: approximately $100M. Someone needs to ask Nutting.
Jason Mackey: Someone needs to ask Nutting what? Why he doesn't spend more? I have. Twice.
AustinTXPirateFan: Do you think Pirate Management tries to keep any of the guys they took a flier on say, Gamel, Yoshi, Shelby Miller, etc?
Jason Mackey: Well, Gamel is under contract. So, yeah, I would imagine they commit to going through arb with him. Tsutsugo depends on what he does the rest of the way and his market; I don't think they're against it. Same for Miller. They don't know enough about him at the MLB level yet.
Steven: Little late to the chat so I’m not sure if this has been discussed yet, but Yoshi looks decent! He’s got power but sucks at fielding. Do you think he’ll command some money this winter with teams looking at him like, “dang, there’s the power people have been talking about” or is it moreso, “I need to see more” so he’ll be affordable. I feel like a bigger market team can throw him a couple million just as a bench piece/DH whereas the Pirates most likely won’t and would strictly utilize him as a DH if it becomes universal.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it's just hard to say at this point. Depends on whether this continues. Remember Nogowski. If Yoshi hits like this through October, then, yeah, I think he probably played his way out of Pittsburgh. But I also think they could use him if the production falls somewhere in the middle.
Prince Bob: I have a really small sample size when I say this, but if they're going to run the contact play a lot, and I can see why they might, the runners need to get bigger leads.
Jason Mackey: I will make sure Shelton knows.
Steven: Piggy-backing off Yoshi, it’s been refreshing to see consistent power as of late. Sure Reynolds would hit some (ie 20+ like what he has now) but he’s moreso a contact hitter who has power. Hopefully guys like Chavis and Martin can add more so that way we’re not strictly relying on XBH with runners on to score runs and win games, HRs help the cause a lot.
Jason Mackey: No doubt. And they're never going to be a top-tier power-hitting club. But it has been really bad this season. Just imagine in a couple years, though. You could have Reynolds, Cruz, Martin, maybe even Castro. Henry Davis has some pop.
Prince Bob: Thanks. But I'll want a consultant's fee.
Jason Mackey: For what? Telling a runner on third base to get a bigger lead and thinking you fixed the problem?
Joel: Tiny sample size, but the Hayes in the lead off spot experiment seems to be going well. Both Bonds and McCutchen batted lead off early in their careers. What do you think of Hayes staying there for a bit, maybe even next season?
Jason Mackey: Joel, my man. I'm not committing to this for Friday let alone next season. I'm a big believer in not messing with a winner. I loved how Mike Sullivan would almost always keep the same lineup and lines after a Penguins win. Do the same. As long as they're winning, hit Hayes leadoff. I'm not thinking about it any more than that.
Prince Bob: Sarcasm maybe doesn't translate well.
Jason Mackey: It's all good.
Daniel Sametz: Hi Jason,
There is some hate for Newman but with the good defensive year he's having I do think he deserves another year in the team. Do you think he can turn around with the bat?
Jason Mackey: Hi Daniel. I think Newman is what he is at this point -- a solid defensive shortstop who's not gonna add a ton with the bat. Is he better than he's been this season? Yeah, I think so. Was 2019 probably a mirage? I think there's some truth to that as well. Big picture, I think Newman can start another year, and it's fine. But beyond that, I think the Pirates need to turn things over to Peguero, Castillo, Marcano or Cruz -- whoever winds up being their shortstop of the future and someone who adds more offense.
Prince Bob: I kind of thought you were being sarcastic when you said you'd pass my observation along to Shelton so... sorry if we got muddled.
Jason Mackey: I might bring it up to him. Who knows. We sometimes talk about random baseball stuff during BP. Just depends on if that conversation happens or not.
Steve: Did you see the interview in the booth with Cervelli last night? Such a class guy. He expressed interested in managing in the future. Hope he ends up back with the Bucs someday. Feel he would be a great manager all around.
Jason Mackey: Hi Steve. I did, yes. I was watching the TV feed from my seat, then I chatted with Cervy (along with other reporters) afterward. I thought he was terrific. On TV and the specific stuff he said about catching, managing, handling pitchers, etc. Such a smart dude, and I'm glad, most of all, that he's healthy. I hope he winds up with the Pirates as well. I think there's a lot of knowledge he can share with younger players.
MjB: I had a coach that once timed our shortstop's best jump throw against the plant your foot and make a good throw technique. You will never guess who the winner is by a landslide? If Kevin Newman plants his foot and makes a strong throw, Moran catches the throw, the inning ends, and we win a game. Why do managers tolerate that. I see it night after night in MLB. It's all about highlight plays instead of making an easy out.
Jason Mackey: I think it's hard to say, black and white, one is always better than the other. And I think as a manager, you need to trust your players to make instinctive, athletic players. You don't see Mike Tomlin telling Steelers receivers when to dive and when to keep running. You have to trust your players.
Prince Bob: Not to beat this to death, it's hard to see what runners at third are doing when you watch on TV. In some replays where the guy gets thrown out it looks to me like they were barely off the base when the ball was hit. But again, I've seen only a few of these situations.
Jason Mackey: I don't think their leads or secondary leads have been the problem. I think it's pushing a certain way of thinking -- always aggressive. With better players, it might be a good thing. We've seen them get burned playing their infield in as well. I also don't think it's hugely detrimental to the cause.
Phil in GA: With respect to the timing of minor league promotions, winning as a group, keeping them together angle, I thought I saw something from Baker that they may not do as much of that next year. Do you think some (not all) of it is waiting to see if the new CBA changes service time rules at all and then adjust appropriately? I know the organization would never admit it, but let's be clear, if, for example, they adjust service time so that anything before Aug 1 counts as a full season for a freshly promoted rookie, teams would take that into consideration with development time tables.
Jason Mackey: Was actually chatting about this with someone yesterday. I don't think you're seeing them manipulate service time at Class A. If this was Class AAA, yeah, I would have my suspicions. But man, we're so far away from that. We're not even at the point where we're guaranteed it'll matter about players' service time.
MjB: BTW, I would take Cervelli as a coach in a heartbeat after listening to him last night!
Jason Mackey: I would find a role for him in the organization, if he would be willing to do that. I don't know if he is. Pretty good life he leads right now.
Prince Bob: Thanks. I am now officially retiring that topic.
Jason Mackey: Thank you.
Cullen: Thanks for the chats as always, they're very insightful! I saw Nick Gonzales was taken out of the game yesterday, any word on why?
Jason Mackey: Have not heard anything. Tomczyk talks in a little. I will say, he had 5 PA in a 21-4 win, so it may have just been getting someone else playing time or giving Nick a rest. But should find out in a couple of hours if there's anything legitimately up.
Mark: Hi Jason. IMO, the Pirates should play the Cleveland Baseball team (nice huh?) every year. The Detroit rivalry is not very interesting. Why can't Cincy-Detroit be the rivalry? They can call it the Sparky Anderson classic.
Jason Mackey: I don't care, honestly. Detroit isn't a rival. Cleveland isn't a rival. But I think having that series matters for situations like the Yankees vs. Mets, Giants vs. A's and other interleague series that you want to have every year. If you wanna do Cincy-Detroit, that's fine. Pittsburgh-Clevaland. I'm still not sure you've created anything that's super captivating.
Phil in GA: Do you have any sense for how things play out with Chad Kuhl going into the offseason/next season? Trade in the offseason, keep but back to the rotation, etc. I had him pegged to finish starting this year and be traded in the offseason but no idea now that they put him in the pen.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I'm not sure, Phil. That's a good question. Have actually been meaning to check in with Chad about life as a reliever and what he thinks. Thank you for the reminder. I also think he could just maybe come back as a reliever and make a career out of this thing. He could be really, really good. I don't think Kuhl would be the middling type, and the Pirates could just give him important innings, hope he pitches well, then trade him next season. I do think he gets traded eventually. Just unclear when and what he'll be doing at the time.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's going to do it for me. I need to head outta here. Thanks so much for working with the funky timing. Let's do this again next Wednesday!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.