The way the story has been told, Dave Cash looked up and down the line of Pirates players waiting to take the field for a night game against Philadelphia at Three Rivers Stadium on Sept. 1, 1971.

As Cash, who three years later would become a three-time All-Star with the Phillies, continued this process, he had an observation.

“I looked over to ‘Scoop’ [Al Oliver], and I said, ‘Man, we got all brothers out here,’ ” Cash said. “He said, ‘Yeah, that’s right.’ We never thought anything of it after that.”

What Cash saw, of course, was the Pirates making Major League Baseball history by fielding the first-ever all-minority lineup, with Black or Latino players occupying all nine positions on the field.

Advertise with us

It was, the rest of the world would soon realize and relish, a hugely important moment for the integration of baseball, nearly as important as Jackie Robinson breaking the color barrier. But to this particular Pirates team — one that featured more than a dozen Black or Latin players and took great pride in its diversity — this was also somewhat routine.

More than anything, the Pirates had won seven of nine to erase the sting of a losing August, they held a slim-but-not-insurmountable lead for first place in the division, and they didn’t want the ship to veer off course over the final month against the cellar-dwelling Phillies.

“I didn’t notice that it was a real big deal until after the game,” said center fielder Gene Clines. “The writers came in and started asking us, ‘Did you know you made history?’ We didn’t look at it that way. Our No. 1 objective was to win the game.”

With the 50-year anniversary of that game — where Dock Ellis struggled and didn’t make it out of the second inning, where Manny Sanguillen homered and Luke Walker finished the game with six innings of one-run ball out of the bullpen — coming this Wednesday, it’s not hard to see how much things have changed.

In baseball, obviously, but more so with who’s playing it. When Cash surveys the situation across his favorite sport now, he sees an alarming dearth of Black baseball players, too many of them lost to football or basketball, sports with a much easier path to prominence.

Advertise with us

“We’ve lost a lot of good Black baseball players to other sports,” Cash said. “Guys coming out of high school or college, they don’t want to go to the minor leagues. In baseball, there are very few guys who can step off the college campus and right into the major leagues. I think that’s a deterrent in our sport.”

‘That’s my dream’

The first time Clines began to think something felt different was that afternoon, when a bat boy said something about the Homestead Grays. Clines knew plenty about the old Negro Leagues team, but he wondered what applicability it had here.

It wasn’t until the Pirates and Phillies lined up for the national anthem that Clines began to understand what the bat boy had meant.

“I think he realized it before a lot of us did,” Clines said. “I look to my left, there’s Stargell. Look to my right, there’s Clemente. I look around more, and I started thinking, ‘Holy [expletive].’

Advertise with us

“I take a lot of pride in being a part of that.”

The Pirates lineup that day featured Rennie Stennett leading off and playing second base; Clines hitting second in center; Roberto Clemente batting third in right; Willie Stargell in left; Sanguillen catching; Cash at third; Oliver at first; Jackie Hernandez at shortstop; and Ellis pitching.

With Bob Robertson, Richie Hebner and Gene Alley nursing injuries, Oliver shifted from center and took over at first; Cash went from second to third; Rennie Stennett — a rookie who started 33 games that season — played second; and Hernandez filled in for Alley.

Perhaps the bat boy who Clines referenced received a tip from manager Danny Murtaugh, as his intent or knowledge of the lineup remains one of the great controversies surrounding this event. Did Murtaugh know what he was doing? Did he start that group intentionally to try and make history?

Sanguillen doesn’t think so, which tracks with Murtaugh’s comments that appeared in a United Press International story that was picked up across the country. With Pittsburgh’s newspapers on strike at the time, Murtaugh was quoted as saying he’s “colorblind” when making out his lineup.

Advertise with us

“Danny Murtaugh was a genius,” Sanguillen said. “He would say, ‘Sangy, I put nine guys in the field, and I want to win the game. I don’t see color. I write down a lineup, and I know that lineup is going to win the game.’ ”

The all-minority lineup also fulfilled a lifelong dream for Clemente, said Sanguillen and Luis Clemente, one of Roberto’s sons.

The iconic right fielder, who was never shy about advocating for Latin ballplayers, had been talking privately for years about this happening, where the Pirates could make history — and a hugely positive statement — with their diversity.

“Clemente would say, ‘That’s my dream. Someday we’re going to play with nine [minority] players in the field,’ ” Sanguillen said. “And we did it.”

As for the baseball side of things, that was a completely different challenge. Ellis walked the first two men he faced, Hernandez committed an error at short, and Oscar Gamble knocked in a run for a 2-0 Phillies lead in the first.

Advertise with us

The Pirates, though, answered with an offensive onslaught in the bottom half, as Clemente, Stargell, Cash, Oliver and Hernandez all drove in runs. But two more walks wrapped around a home run allowed to Ron Stone ended Ellis’ day, as Murtaugh replaced him with Bob Moose.

Moose gave up a homer to Deron Johnson, pushing the Phillies ahead by one, before the Pirates stormed back in the bottom of the second, scoring one on Stargell’s sacrifice fly and again via Sanguillen’s two-run blast.

“It looked real bad in the beginning,” Cash said. “But we came back like we normally did.”

“We all worked together,” Sanguillen added. “I’ve never caught a better game in my life.”

‘Matters more now’

Advertise with us

Oliver played nearly 20 MLB seasons, winning a World Series, a batting title, three Silver Slugger Awards and making seven All-Star appearances. He’s since become a licensed minister and is an ardent public speaker and advocate for diversity.

Naturally, being part of the first all-minority lineup is something Oliver says he’ll never forget — a career milestone bigger than any number — but he does wish MLB would do more to celebrate what he believes is a Jackie Robinson-level moment for the game.

“No one has ever really publicized it the way it should be publicized,” Oliver said. “It’s part of baseball history. Jackie Robinson was No. 1. The all-minority team should be No. 2 and something people talk about every year.”

It sounds like Oliver will be getting his wish. With this year being the 50th anniversary, there will be no shortage of things happening.

Pirates players and coaches will wear specially designed T-shirts, complete with the lineup and a new logo. Although the Pirates are in Chicago, the event will be recognized and celebrated throughout the AT&T SportsNet broadcast.

Advertise with us

Also that night, there will be an event at the Heinz History Center featuring a panel discussion with the four living members — Cash, Clines, Oliver and Sanguillen — as well as Roberto Clemente Jr., plus the unveiling of a special commemorative piece of art that will remain on display.

When the Pirates get back to Pittsburgh, there will be a pregame recognition and remembrance prior to the Sept. 6 home game against the Tigers.

“I know Dad had a lot of pride with this,” Luis Clemente said. “Dad always fought against racism. That was his proudest moment. And I don’t think they’ve given those guys the attention they deserve. Now, it’s more relevant than ever, too.”

Oliver and Clemente are right that this event hasn’t been celebrated enough, but the parties involved also hope it spurs a larger discussion about how to better integrate baseball, specifically among Black Americans.

Just consider that, in 1971, MLB featured 15.5% Black players. That number topped out at 18.7% in 1981 but hasn’t been above 10% since 2004, according to the Society for American Baseball Research. The past few years, MLB has had 7% to 8% Black, American-born players.

Advertise with us

While the Latin population in the game has grown considerably — from 10.6% in 1971 to 29.5% of players on 2021 opening day rosters born in Spanish-speaking countries — the number of Black athletes lost to other sports is not lost on the members of the all-minority lineup.

Baseball is too cost-prohibitive to start, they argue, and then the path to the pros is entirely too long.

“If I go to college for a couple years, I go right to the pros and make a lot of money right away,” Clines said, talking about football and basketball. “In baseball, I have to go to the minors for four years. Which one would you take?”

Cash believes the problem starts before high school.

The Pirates are active with their RBI (Reviving Baseball in Inner Cities) program and, by all accounts, do a tremendous job. But these guys would like to see MLB do more to advertise the sport and make it more accessible to those who might struggle to fund certain startup costs.

Advertise with us

Basically taking all clubs’ RBI programs and turning them up a few dozen notches.

“You have to buy a lot of equipment, and a lot of people can’t afford that, especially some Black families,” Cash said. “They can’t afford to participate unless they have funding from some outside sources.”

There are things happening, of course. Six-time All-Star CC Sabathia has been a tremendous role model. The work The Players Alliance has done has been nothing short of incredible. Even MLB showcase events such as the Breakthrough Series or Hank Aaron Invitational help players from urban communities get noticed.

But as momentum (hopefully) continues to build up around baseball’s need to look different than it does now, it’s important to remember that one of the greatest examples of diversity in baseball happened here in Pittsburgh.

“Absolutely, I take a lot pride in being a part of that,” Clines said. “And it matters more now.

Advertise with us

“I look at it like setting a record. It stands there, and you look back on it 50 years later, and you’re still a part of it.

“But I think the bigger part is that, back then, we had so many games where our lineup was loaded with good Black or Latin players that when we had nine, it really didn’t even seem like that big of a deal.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.