General manager Ben Cherington and the Pirates’ front office will have their own method of taking stock of their farm system, but one of the easier ways for Pirates fans to keep track is through various rankings. Baseball America has given a midseason update to their own prospect rankings, including a new top 30 for the Pirates.
The top five is essentially the same, with one new entry. Shortstop Oneil Cruz (Class AA Altoona) is first, followed by newly drafted catcher Henry Davis (Florida Complex League), right-hander Quinn Priester (High-A Greensboro), infielder Nick Gonzales (Greensboro) and his middle infield partner Liover Peguero (Greensboro).
As for the rest of the list, there are some surprises and names of note. Here are the highlights:
New faces (ranking)
C Henry Davis (No. 2), UTL Tucupita Marcano (No. 7), RHP Bubba Chandler (No. 13), C Endy Rodriguez (No. 17), SS Maikol Escotto (No. 18), LHP Anthony Solometo (No. 21), OF Lonnie White Jr. (No. 22), C Carter Bins (No. 24), OF Matthew Fraizer (No. 26), OF Rodolfo Nolasco (No. 30)
Much of this group was acquired in the last month or so. Davis, Chandler, Solometo and White were 2021 MLB draft selections. Marcano and Bins were acquired at the 2021 trade deadline in deals with the San Diego Padres and Seattle Mariners, respectively. Rodriguez and Escotto were acquired in offseason trades after last year from the New York Mets and New York Yankees, respectively.
Read More
That’s a lot of new blood, and this group is really a large part of the reason that the Pirates’ farm system is trending upward in a major way. When folks discuss that the Pirates have made their system deeper under Cherington, this is why. Only Davis and Marcano cracked the new top 10, but there are a whole bunch of names in the 15-30 range who are new to the organization, and that’s the aforementioned depth.
As for Fraizer and Nolasco, they’ve just been tearing it up — especially Fraizer. He was recently promoted from High-A Greensboro to Class AA Altoona. He leads all Pirates minor leaguers in hits this season and is 6-for-15 with two doubles and a triple since joining Altoona.
Off the list (former ranking)
3B Ke’Bryan Hayes (No. 1), RHP JT Brubaker (No. 16), RHP Nick Garcia (No. 17), RHP Jose Soriano (No. 18), RHP Wil Crowe (No. 20), 1B Mason Martin (No. 21), RHP Braxton Ashcraft (No. 22), LHP Omar Cruz (No. 23), OF Jared Oliva (No. 26), RHP Blake Cederlind (No. 28)
There aren’t many huge surprises here. Hayes, Brubaker and Crowe, at least, have graduated from the list and are current members of the Pirates. Soriano and Cederlind have been out all season with Tommy John issues, though Soriano was on track for a comeback before suffering a major setback and needing to undergo a second Tommy John surgery. He may end up out of the organization entirely soon, since he was the first overall selection in this last offseason’s Rule 5 draft. Ashcraft is about to undergo Tommy John surgery himself and be out for the next year or so.
Oliva also isn’t all that surprising of an omission, as he has struggled to catch on this season in both Class AAA Indianapolis and the majors, hitting .236 in 22 games at the former level and .175 in 20 games at the latter.
Martin, Garcia and Cruz are the surprises. Martin, specifically, was on fire earlier this season, hitting homers left and right for Class AA Altoona. He has cooled down as of late, going without a long ball since July 24. He actually has just one extra-base hit since then and has seen his average drop to .256 on the year. Garcia has a 3.75 ERA in Bradenton, though he has struggled a bit with walks this season. Cruz recently made the jump to Altoona himself and possesses a 3.75 ERA himself at the new level.
Biggest risers (new ranking)
RHP Roansy Contreras (No. 6, up 7 spots), RHP Carmen Mlodzinski (No. 8, up 4 spots), RHP Michael Burrows (No. 10, up 14 spots), OF Cal Mitchell (No. 20, up 5 spots), INF Rodolfo Castro (No. 23, up 6 spots), RHP Max Kranick (No. 25, up 5 spots)
Contreras is the breakout star of the minors this season. He’s been set back by forearm discomfort recently but was on fire at Altoona before that and should be back in action soon. The same goes for Mlodzinski and Burrows at High-A Greensboro, who are both currently on the shelf with injuries.
Mitchell has a .754 OPS and a clear path to the majors if he can continue to hit. Castro and Kranick have both made somewhat unexpected leaps to the majors, with both experiencing limited success before cooling off a bit.
Biggest fallers (new ranking)
RHP Cody Bolton (No. 15, down 8 spots), RHP Miguel Yajure (No. 16, down 6 spots), 2B Ji-Hwan Bae (No. 19, down 8 spots), RHP Eddy Yean (No. 27, down 8 spots) RHP Brennan Malone (No. 28, down 19 spots)
Bolton has not pitched at all this season with a knee injury, so that’s understandable. Malone took a big step back, starting the year in Low-A Bradenton before going back to the Florida Complex League for development purposes. He recently returned to action after an injury of his own and struggled, allowing three earned runs in just 1/3 of an inning.
Yean hasn’t been as dominant as might have been expected, given his overpowering stuff, but he has righted the ship a bit recently. Meanwhile, Bae and Yajure could be considered surprising drops. Bae is hitting .270 in Altoona this season and has found some power recently, hitting six homers since returning from a knee injury of his own. Yajure has shown real promise in both Indianapolis and the majors, though he was out for a couple of months with a right arm injury. He did return in a rehab assignment with Bradenton last week, throwing 1 2/3 innings without allowing an earned run in 31 pitches.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.