CINCINNATI — Over the past seven weeks, while the Pirates bullpen has struggled to find traction, Wil Crowe started to take his season in a different direction, showing signs of consistent production.

After pitching to a 7.12 ERA in his first seven starts, Crowe had a 3.98 ERA over his previous eight, allowing two or fewer runs six times.

As for the bullpen, which has been decimated by injuries, trades and other dips in performance, only the Diamondbacks (6.56 ERA) were less effective than the Pirates (5.93) during that stretch.

But as the Pirates and Reds opened a four-game series on Thursday at Great American Ball Park, those roles were reversed during a 7-4 Pittsburgh loss.

Advertise with us

Crowe struggled early, allowing seven runs on three homers during the first two innings. And before the bullpen enjoyed an encouraging performance — allowing one hit, no runs or walks and striking out five over four innings — Crowe showed some maturity and toughness by finishing his outing on a positive note.

“At 7-0, you only have one way to go. That’s to put up zeroes, or you’re gonna get pulled,” Crowe said. “To me, it was to work down and make ’em hit my pitches instead of leaving pitches up over the middle.”

The outing for Crowe was tough because it follows what has easily been his best stretch of the season, allowing two runs over 11 1/3 innings during his past two starts.

What happened Thursday sort of felt like a continuation of the Pirates’ season-opening road trip and second series of the year, where the Reds swept them in a three-game set by a combined score of 30-8, hitting eight home runs.

The Pirates (41-68), who are now 1-3 on this trip and 5-12 in their past 17, have dropped 14 of their past 17 against Cincinnati dating back to last season.

Advertise with us

As Crowe explained, his issues stemmed from his inability to use his changeup low in the zone. It forced him to rely on other pitches, throwing him out of rhythm, and he also made a couple mistakes to Jonathan India and Eugenio Suarez.

Joey Votto, who hit the second of the two three-run homers, actually hit a decent pitch from Crowe: a high-and-inside fastball.

The India at-bat, which opened the bottom of the first, was telling. Crowe got ahead, 0-2, but couldn’t finish the job. He stayed away from his changeup and stuck with sliders and fastballs, running the count full. India crushed an elevated heater into the upper-deck in left.

“That one kind of cut back over the middle instead of it staying true,” Crowe said.

Suarez entered the game with a .176 average, though he did have 21 homers and 58 RBIs at first pitch. He got No. 22 by driving another full-count fastball the other way.

Advertise with us

Votto put the Reds ahead by a touchdown with his homer over the fence in right-center.

“One of our zones to get Votto was up and in,” Crowe said. “I think if you watch it back, you’ll see where [Jacob] Stallings is even visibly upset that he got that homer because that was probably the best pitch I threw all night. Sometimes guys get you on really good pitches.”

To Crowe’s credit, he gathered himself and retired seven of the final eight he faced, five via strikeouts.

“It’s really the first two innings,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “Got a little bit frustrated and missed with some fastballs in the middle of the plate. You cannot do that with that lineup in this ballpark.

“He was able to settle down. Even though it’s a four-inning outing, the fact that he gave us the third and fourth scoreless was very important.”

Advertise with us

Trailing 7-0, the Pirates mounted a push in the fifth.

With runners on second and third, Phillip Evans made it 7-1 with an infield single before Kevin Newman found just enough space through the left side, the ball bouncing off the glove of Reds shortstop Kyle Farmer, allowing another run to score and cutting Cincinnati’s lead to 7-2.

Next came Bryan Reynolds, whose grounder to short allowed Evans to score before Ke’Bryan Hayes, hitless in his previous 19 at-bats, shot a single through the middle on a low fastball to make it a 7-4 game.

The Pirates had the leadoff man on in the seventh and eighth, but Hayes and Gregory Polanco both hit into double plays.

After Crowe exited, Duane Underwood Jr. kept things close with two scoreless innings of relief. Anthony Banda, making his first appearance with the Pirates, worked a 1-2-3 seventh before Nick Mears struck out the side in the eighth.

Advertise with us

The play of the game came when Reynolds took a home run away from center fielder Tyler Naquin in the fifth, leaping and snaring the ball at the wall.

“It feels good to be on the defensive side of it,” Reynolds said. “I had it offensively one time, and that’s not fun. Being able to return the favor is something that’s cool.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.