CINCINNATI — Jacob Stallings and Chris Stratton were chatting the other day when the topic of Bryan Reynolds’ defense was broached.
Not whether it was any good. Since transitioning from left field to center earlier this season, Reynolds has impressed teammates with some steady and often spectacular play at his natural position.
Stallings and Stratton were confused because they couldn’t wrap their heads around two stats that try to paint a picture when it comes to how Reynolds has fared as a defender.
Statcast says that Reynolds has been worth 8 Outs Above Average (OAA) this season, a total eclipsed by just eight players throughout Major League Baseball, regardless of position. Reynolds is tied for second among outfielders, trailing only Manuel Margot of the Rays (12 OAA).
Meanwhile, FanGraphs ascribed 4 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) to Reynolds. Of the 29 qualifiers among MLB outfielders, only eight have fared worse.
“I don’t understand how his Outs Above Average can be the best, then Defensive Runs Saved is not as good,” Stallings said. “I feel like he makes a lot of plays out there and takes really good routes.”
Read More
Anybody who has watched Reynolds play this season would require a head injury of some kind to classify him as one of the worst defensive outfielders in MLB.
That’s not a guarantee that Reynolds will win the Gold Glove, mind you, although his name belongs in the conversation. It’s more that the Pirates believe — and they’re right — that Reynolds has been more the Statcast version of himself than the one that shows up on FanGraphs.
“I go off of what I see,” said first-base coach Tarrik Brock, who works with the team’s outfielders. “I go off of how he reacts to our pitching staff. I see the overall picture, and I see the growth that you just can’t measure.”
The growth has been the most important thing for Reynolds this season.
Hired before 2020, Brock said one of his first tasks was to watch video of Reynolds and learn about him as an athlete. Next came devising drills to improve Reynolds’ first-step quickness, specifically with how he moves to his left.
Brock has also worked with Reynolds on the differences between throwing in center versus left, how sometimes his best play might not be a glamorous one where he cuts a ball off and makes a quick throw into second base, preventing a runner from moving up 90 feet.
“He’s just a good athlete,” Brock said. “He wants to be taught, so it makes it fun. He’s been working on things. Even when he played left field, I still talked to him like he was a center fielder. You still have to think like a center fielder.”
The area where that’s most noticeable involves the routes Reynolds takes to balls. Sure, he’s made a couple of highlight-reel catches, including one last series in Milwaukee. He’s extremely comfortable diving and seemingly never does it while losing control of his body.
But Reynolds’ best work often comes long before that final bit of action, when he’s following how the Pirates are trying to pitch a certain hitter, how the ball comes off his bat, where he should be positioned and how to most efficiently get from A to B.
“Since he’s moved to center, the ability to get good jumps, good reads … I don’t know metrically where it stands, but it looks to be once he’s got the jumps, his closing speed has really improved,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “I think that’s a credit to the movements he’s making prior to the pitch being thrown, then when the ball is contacted.”
Added Stallings: “I think he looks really comfortable out there, and he’s playing really well.”
Gamel sits
Ben Gamel was scratched from Thursday’s game because of a tight hamstring. Hoy Park played left field instead. Shelton said the move was more precautionary than anything.
Speaking of Park, who hit leadoff, his double Wednesday made him one of just four players to record an extra-base hit in each of his first three games as a Pirate, joining Cole Tucker (2019), Jack Wilson (2001) and Brian Giles (1999).
It also marks the fourth different position Park has played, along with shortstop, center field and right field. Before Gamel was scratched, Park was actually supposed to play second base but was subbed out for Wilmer Difo.
“I would like to get him in the infield a little bit more and get a look at him,” Shelton said. “We’ll probably do that moving forward, but the fact that he’s versatile and wanting to get him at-bats right now, it kind of helps us out that we can bounce him around.”
Line it up
Dustin Fowler was reinstated from the 10-day injured list at Class AAA Indianapolis. … Right-handed pitcher Justin Meis and lefty Nick Dombowski joined Low-A Bradenton Thursday. Meis, a Bethel Park native, was the Pirates’ 10th-round pick out of Eastern Michigan. The Pirates signed Dombowski as an undrafted free agent.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.