Lonnie White Jr. had a decision to make: sign with the Pirates after they selected him in the second compensatory round of the MLB draft this year, or fulfill his commitment to Penn State to play football and baseball.

Of course, there’s much more to it than that. Sure, going to the Pirates would give White an instant pay day and a guaranteed shot at playing baseball for his job, starting in the Florida Complex League this season.

It would also mean giving up the ability to play two sports at a prestigious university, the college experience and all of the things that come with that. That’s not even to mention that college players can make some side money now, thanks to legislation passed that allows college athletes to make money off their name, image and likeness.

Really, there was no way for White to go wrong — both are respectable options. On Monday, though, it became official. White traveled from the east side of the state, where he attended high school at Malvern Prep in Philadelphia, to PNC Park, undergoing a physical and ultimately signing on the dotted line to join the Pirates.

Advertise with us

“It was definitely very difficult, but I think the reason I decided this route was that it’s always been in my heart [since I was] a little kid,” White said Monday. “This is just a dream come true to me.”

White’s signing adds another impressive name to a heavy list of them in the Pirates’ 2021 draft class. He, first-rounder Henry Davis, second-rounder Anthony Solometo and third-rounder Bubba Chandler were all ranked among the top 32 players in the draft class by Baseball America. Now, all have signed with the Pirates.

As one would imagine for a player of his pedigree, White, ranked No. 32 by Baseball America, has the skill set of a pure athlete. He is big and strong, bringing some to project that he will be a corner outfielder in the future. For now, though, he is also quite fast and could probably be expected to begin his career in center field.

He also joins Chandler as two players who passed on playing Division I football, with Chandler holding a commitment to Clemson as a three-star quarterback and White to Penn State as a three-star wide receiver.

It may have been fortuitous that both fell to and signed with the Pirates, but the team feels it did the proper groundwork to have reasonable confidence that the players fit what they wanted and could be productive members of the organization moving forward.

Advertise with us

“I think our scouts and our people on the ground do a great job in getting to know them as people first,” said Pirates director of scouting Joe DelliCarri. “I think we get the opportunity on the ground with our area supervisors to learn more about them — what they care most about, their views about sport and competing. And then the draft only allows us the opportunity to select them. It doesn't give us the right to sign them going forward in that realm. But first and foremost is the people — how they look at and how they share about competing, and then the baseball part comes out in it.”

As for the Penn State side, Rivals ranked White as the Nittany Lions’ sixth-best recruit in the class of 2021. Obviously, they wanted him on their team.

Still, Penn State coach James Franklin was supportive of White no matter his decision, and that helped in the process.

“It meant a lot, knowing that [Franklin] wants the best for me, and it doesn’t matter if I went to Penn State or not,” White said. “He just wants the best for me personally. He wants me to be happy, which is awesome. He didn’t want to fight over me or anything like that. He’s just an awesome guy all around.”

Despite hailing from Philadelphia, White says he does have some familiarity with the Pirates, as he has some family from the area. He says he attended a game at PNC Park when he was little.

Advertise with us

The goal will be to return here in a few years as a big leaguer. That will take steady improvement, as White will focus exclusively on baseball for perhaps the first time in his life.

At the very least, his choice allows him to pursue something he loves and make money doing it, even if the journey ahead will be arduous.

“I guess it was doing baseball as a job for one,” White said of his decision. “I love to play the game. I could play it all year-round. And then you look at the school side, the school work, two sports — each side would have been very difficult ... and not many people can do it. And on this side, it’s just my love for the game.”

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak.