When the Pirates set out to craft their most recent draft strategy, the one that has garnered rave reviews from around the sport, one of the most impactful conversations general manager Ben Cherington had was with his bosses, owner Bob Nutting and president Travis Williams.
Speaking Sunday on his 93.7 FM The Fan radio show, Cherington described the involvement and impact those two had on the Pirates’ draft preparation — not necessarily analyzing the mechanics of Henry Davis’ swing or Anthony Solometo’s delivery but more when it came to big-picture direction.
Think stuff like not spending full slot value on the No. 1 pick and saving that money to pursue a bunch of high school players the Pirates believe they can lure away from college. And, of course, the financial commitment to sign those players and pay the people charged with finding and evaluating them in the first place.
“One of the things I benefit from in this job is real engagement and access and consistent access to both Bob and Travis,” Cherington said. “Some of that, we can think about in terms of money and the support. Very confident we’re going to have the support and the resources necessary to sign the players we took in the draft. Of course, that’s really important. But it’s beyond that, too.
“It’s really the debate and the perspective that we can share going into the draft in terms of strategy. What I’m often doing, whether it’s the draft or a trade or any other decision is sharing a recommendation, trying to share some reasons why we’re making that recommendation, and then looking for feedback, in some cases pushback on that recommendation.”
That has happened plenty, Cherington said, using the term “stress-test” to see whether there are any holes Nutting or Williams can possibly poke in the idea. Sometimes, of course, the move, pick or trade makes sense, and the Pirates proceed.
Read More
Amid a recent stretch where the Pirates have been playing markedly better baseball, we’ve seen a couple of those gambles work out well. Ben Gamel, John Nogowski and Wilmer Difo have been a few of Pittsburgh’s most productive players of late, and they’re all recent Cherington acquisitions.
They were all designated for assignment earlier this season — in Difo’s case, by the Pirates — leading to a situation where some improvement was necessary.
That, Cherington said, is a must for a team like the Pirates. As much as they want to draft players like Davis and build a core via the draft, they also have to acquire players for nothing and have a process in place where players can actually get better here.
“Look at good teams, the teams that are getting deep into October,” Cherington said. “Sure, there are going to be plenty of examples of players on those teams that were drafted, come up through the system and become part of their core. We absolutely have to do that.
“But there are also always examples of guys who those teams acquired almost for nothing and were at a point in their careers where they needed a change of scenery, a change of opportunity, maybe a little different, fresh approach to coaching. Maybe they improve in some small way, and it’s enough to push them over the top. You need some of those examples, too.
“When we have opportunity in terms of playing time to give, we’ve got to be taking advantage of that by finding guys like that.”
It doesn’t seem like Nutting or Williams would have much to say when Cherington presents the idea of acquiring Gamel or Nogowski, but it’s easy to see them having input on the draft, specifically as it pertains to picking first overall.
Nutting told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette during spring training that “signability would not be an issue,” and that now appears to be a prescient statement. The only reason why the Pirates spent about $2 million below slot on Davis — his signing bonus was $6.5 million — was so they could use that money elsewhere, not save it.
In fact, the Pirates are expected to exceed their MLB-high draft pool, which has become a regular occurrence since the slotted rules came into place.
Through it all, Cherington said he appreciates how involved Nutting and Williams are in the entire process — pledging support, sure, but also understanding what’s happening enough to ask critical questions and ensuring that he’s thinking about things the right way.
“It makes the process stronger and our decisions better when we can have that collaboration,” Cherington said. “Their interest and engagement is really consistent. They’re available. They’re interested. They’re following the information closely enough to have really good thoughts and opinions, to be able to ask questions and push back.
“Again, financial or resource support is one thing. It’s important that we get that. But the dialogue and the opportunity to collaborate and be better through that is just as important to me.”
Around the horn
• Davis, as we’ve written, will start in the Florida Complex League. Cherington does not want to place any expectations on the No. 1 overall pick, but given the fact that he’s an advanced college player, it’s possible he could get into games soon and shift into affiliated ball.
“A college player who’s performed that way is probably going to move more quickly than a high school player, for example,” Cherington said. “But we don’t know that for sure.”
• As expected, Cherington said any substantive trade talks took a break around the MLB draft. It was intentional or happened out of necessary.
“I think collectively that kind of happened without even anyone saying it between maybe sometime Saturday through Tuesday of this past week. It felt that way anyway,” Cherington said. “GMs just sort of collectively decided, ‘OK, we’re hitting pause for 2-3 days, then we’ll pick it up after the draft.’ ”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.