Roansy Contreras wasn’t his typically dominant, unscathed self Tuesday, and in some ways that’s a good thing.

The 21-year-old right-hander is ranked the 20th-best Pirates prospect on MLB Pipeline, and that’s probably underselling his abilities. In a recent Q&A, Baseball America’s Josh Norris said Contreras was close to breaking into their top 100 prospects in all of minor league baseball when they most recently reshuffled their list.

“He has a good chance to be in there at midseason or before,” Norris wrote.

The Pirates currently have five players on that top 100 list, to give you an inkling as to how much Contreras’ stock has risen this season. That’s good news for Contreras, who has dominated for Class AA Altoona this season, with a 2.18 ERA, 0.879 WHIP, 47 strikeouts and eight walks through 33 innings and six starts. Four of those starts have been shutouts.

Advertise with us

Tuesday, however, was not. Contreras blew through his first three innings against the Akron Rubberducks, then faced some trouble. He allowed a run on two singles and an RBI groundout in the fourth inning, then allowed a double and a walk in the sixth before exiting after 5 1/3 innings. Both of those runners on base scored, giving him a final line with six hits, three earned runs, two walks and five strikeouts.

By his standards, that’s a pedestrian outing right now.

“It’s funny, man. The guys in the dugout that know him pretty well were like, ‘Is something going on? There’s something going on today,’ ” Altoona manager Miguel Perez said after the game. “And actually, three runs is not a bad outing. It’s just one of those things. He’s been so good this year, this season. He’s been dominating so much that it kind of seems to be rare and weird for the guys.”

While that’s true, what’s impressive is the composure shown even on one of his rougher days. That run in the fourth inning came on a two-strike, hanging breaking ball hit for a single, then another single following it up. He then induced a weak fly ball to right, a weak groundout to first base that scored the run, walked a batter on four pitches then induced a chopper back to the mound to end the inning.

Even in the first few innings, before any sort of damage began, Contreras was working around a few baserunners without a care in the world, still using his full arsenal out of the stretch and blowing away hitters with all four of his pitches.

Advertise with us

“It’s the poise, man,” said a scout familiar with Contreras’ work this season. The scout emphasized that you don’t expect to see that sort of poise from a 21-year-old playing above his age level.

On opening day, he was the ninth-youngest player in the entire Class AA Northeast League. Credit should go to Contreras, who took the canceled 2020 season and used it to improve his arsenal.

In 2019, still in the New York Yankees’ organization before the Jameson Taillon trade brought him to Pittsburgh last offseason, he was in the low 90s with his fastball and had yet to incorporate his slider, going with a three-pitch mix at the time. He’s expanded that now, pumping his fastball velocity up to 96 regularly and 98 when it’s needed.

The first flash of Contreras’ stuff came in MLB spring training this year. He pitched just two innings over two outings in the spring, but struck out five batters. After his second time on the mound, Pirates manager Derek Shelton praised him for his execution at an advanced level.

It’s hard to take those spring training appearances too seriously, but in hindsight, perhaps we should have. As impressive as Contreras’ poise on the mound was Tuesday, it shouldn’t overshadow his stuff, particularly in the first few innings.

Advertise with us

The first batter of the game got on base thanks to a fielding error from Contreras. The next batter hit a hard fly ball to right for an out. Then Contreras locked in, inducing a weak groundout before ending the inning with a nasty breaking ball to get a swinging strikeout.

In the second inning, he didn’t wait for his punch out, throwing his fastball and changeup for strikes on the first two pitches, then bending another filthy breaking ball into the zone for a called third strike. He ended the inning with another swinging K.

It was more of the same in the third frame, starting off with a strikeout looking on the breaking stuff. After allowing a weak bloop single, he faced a battle to end the inning. He started off Akron’s No. 3 hitter, Alex Call, with three straight balls. He then fired a 95 mph fastball for a strike and kept firing fastballs, with Call fouling a pair off. In a 3-2 count, Contreras decided enough was enough and again swung a breaking ball into the zone for his fifth and final strikeout of the night.

In total, Contreras threw 41 pitches in the first three innings. 31 of them were strikes. It is true that he slowed down a bit from there.

“I think it was hot and humid today, man. I could feel it out. I think that element hit him a little bit, and also he got away from attacking with his fastball a little bit, too,” Perez said. “So that was something that we kind of talked in between innings. However, I think that was his way to get out of inning. ... In the fourth inning, you could see it kind of hit him a little bit. Like I said, kind of got away a little bit from attacking with his fastball, and I don’t blame him. Akron is a team that is going to come out and swing early in the count and put the ball in play.”

Advertise with us

Perhaps fastball usage will be Contreras’ next adjustment, relying on that high-velocity heat to establish the rest of his arsenal. He’s got some time to do it, after all. While watching him and looking at his stats, it’s easy to forget he’s just 21.

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak