Derek Shelton changed his lineup all the time last season. The Pirates manager was trying to switch things up for a struggling offense back then.

He’s changed it around a bit this year, too, partially because of some struggles, but mostly because key performers have been on the injured list.

With third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes back — and performing like he never left — the Pirates suddenly have a solidified top three hitters in their lineup. Second baseman Adam Frazier hits first, Hayes hits second and center fielder Bryan Reynolds slots into the third spot.

It’s a relief for Shelton, who doesn’t have to think much about the top portion of his lineup now that Hayes has returned.

Advertise with us

“I think the one misconception is I like to change it a lot,” Shelton said Saturday. “If you have the ability to keep it the same, especially in certain areas, it's way more advantageous. So the fact that those guys are up there and provide us some stability, it is important, and I think we've seen in the couple days back that they've performed well together.”

That may be underselling it. In the two games since Hayes has returned, the trio has hit 11-for-22 with two homers, a triple, four walks, nine RBIs and 10 runs scored. On Friday, they were the main offensive contributors in a 9-2 win over the Miami Marlins. It’s the most runs the Pirates have scored in any game this season.

Frazier and Reynolds producing is nothing new. They’ve been around all season, with Frazier currently leading MLB in hits, doubles and singles. He has the third-highest batting average and the seventh-highest on-base percentage in MLB, too. Reynolds has the sixth-most doubles in MLB and is tied for the ninth-highest offensive wins above replacement (oWAR) across the league.

Those two have been slotted into the first and third spots, respectfully, in the lineup for a vast majority of the season, only taking a handful of at-bats in any other spot in the order.

As a result, those spots in the order compare favorably to the one and three hitters across the league. Baseball reference keeps an sOPS+ stat, which compares the OPS of a specific spot in a team’s batting order to those around the league. A 100 sOPS+ would be league average. Every spot in the Pirates’ order is lower than 100, or below league average ... except the first and third hitters.

Advertise with us

So, basically, Frazier and Reynolds have been better than most leadoff and No. 3 hitters in the league.

That has been a nice boost for the Pirates, but it hasn’t made much of a difference in terms of the Pirates’ team results, or even offensive success. Hayes’ return, albeit in an extremely small sample size, has helped with both.

The Pirates have been operating with a mixture of a few players batting second throughout the season. Left fielder Ka’ai Tom and shortstop Kevin Newman have gotten a fair amount of work there. Neither have been particularly impressive on the offensive side of things. By that same metric used earlier, the Pirates’ No. 2 hitters have an 85 sOPS+, or below league average. At any rate, Hayes could be an enormous upgrade in production.

It’s pretty easy to imagine how Frazier, Hayes and Reynolds will be producing runs. Frazier gets on base more than almost anyone than baseball. Hayes has shown a penchant for the same thing himself, with a load of extra-base power to boot. Reynolds leads the team in RBIs and home runs, and that’s without Hayes in front of him for most of the season.

Frazier was asked after Friday’s game if he feels like he has a better chance of scoring when he gets on base now that Hayes is back.

Advertise with us

“I hadn't really thought about it that way, but yeah, especially with [Hayes and Reynolds] swinging the way they are now,” Frazier said. “That's kind of my job, just get on base for them and if we can continue that, I think we've got a lot better chance of winning ball games and the opportunity to put up a lot of runs. Yeah, that's pretty good protection with those two hitting behind me.”

Added Hayes: “All the time that I was out, I mean, I got to watch it. I got to watch all those games, and yeah, what they're doing is pretty special, so to be right there in the middle of it is fun for us. I mean, we're all, one through nine, just trying to put together good at-bats and draw walks, foul pitches off and put good swings on the ball.”

Whatever the Pirates do get from the rest of their lineup will be icing on the cake as long as their big three keep producing. When first baseman Colin Moran returns, maybe he can make it an extremely solid 1-4. It’s certainly an improvement from the last couple of months and the ever-shifting lineups of 2020.

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak