The Pirates are on a hot streak. They’ve won two of their last three series and split four games with the San Diego Padres in between. Maybe the good times won’t last. Maybe they will. Who’s to say? Either way, it’s time for another mailbag. As always, any question you have about the Pirates can and should be asked to @MikeDPersak on Twitter or mpersak@post-gazette.com via email.

@rhunt45: What do we do with Evans when Hayes comes back soon?

Mike Persak: First of all, it would be shocking if he were optioned, so we’ll start there. Phillip Evans has produced enough that when Ke’Bryan Hayes returns from injury, and the Pirates have to take someone off their active roster, Evans should be safe.

With that said, I think it makes the most sense to put Evans in the super-utility role. If anyone needs a day off, he can slide in at pretty much any position on the diamond. He can be a pinch hitter, he can be a defensive substitute, he can do whatever you need him to do. That really is why the Pirates like Evans in the first place. He’s a human Swiss army knife.

Advertise with us

He’s struggled a little bit in his most recent games, which is fine and to be expected after such a hot start, but he still warrants plenty of looks in the lineup day-in and day-out, and that’s what the Pirates will likely give him. The only difference will be that he might be playing all over the place, depending on who is available each game.

@farabaugh_allen: Should we start being concerned about Evans? A .1 decrease in BA, plus seems like he's striking out way more than before

Persak: A nice little segue into the next question. I have written about this before. With new guys who start on a hot streak in a small sample size, the question is always whether it’s sustainable. Often times, I try to look at how they are hitting off-speed and breaking pitches, because players without much track record will be challenged with fastballs early on a lot of times. Evans has actually hit off-speed pitches better than the fastball, so that’s encouraging.

He also still has an expected batting average of .297, so the results aren’t necessarily indicative of the swings he’s putting on the ball overall. The strikeouts are a bit concerning. He’s struck out eight times in his last 17 at-bats, but that could be a case of over-aggressiveness after a hot start. Either way, as I said earlier, I think he was due to come back to earth here after the start he had, but I think he’ll adjust and be a serviceable bat for them — just maybe not one of the best hitters in the league, like he had been before this cold spell.

@jtrpgh: What do the Bucs do at shortstop in the short term? is E. Gonzalez turning into a viable option?

Advertise with us

Persak: Kevin Newman is what he is. He’s a solid option at shortstop to me, and not much more or less. Right now, he is hitting the ball very poorly. His launch angle is in the negatives — almost 70% of his batted balls are ground balls, nearly 53% of his batted balls are categorized as being “topped” by Statcast. All of this is to say that he’s grounding out a lot.

The positive is that Newman has never had a full season quite this bad. Even in 2020, when he struggled at the start, he bounced back a bit to bump his numbers up by the end of the season. I expect him to improve a little bit here and do something relatively similar, even if I don’t expect him to finish with a .300-plus average like he did in 2019.

In the short term, though, I think it’s worth taking a look at Erik Gonzalez. He is a better defensive shortstop over his career, and if he’s hitting better, too, you’d might as well give him some run until Newman comes back. I don’t think either are long-term options for when the rebuild kicks into gear, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t give each an opportunity while they’re on the team.

@wvpirate: Where do you think Peguero will start the season? A, AA?

Persak: In short, I don’t know. I wish I could answer this better than that, but I don’t even think the Pirates know right now. One of the more interesting story lines around baseball right now is how minor league players will rebound from what was essentially an entire year off in 2020. How does that impact development? What does it mean for where they should start the season?

Advertise with us

I think all of those things are currently being worked out by MLB teams around the country. If I had to hazard a guess for Peguero, specifically, I would guess High-A Greensboro. Even if the Pirates think he could make the Class AA Altoona roster, I think it makes sense to be cautious with the prospects at least to start the season. It would be detrimental to start them too high in the system and risk hurting their confidence if they aren’t as ready as you think they are.

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak