As many Americans polish off their Christmas shopping lists, here are some things the Pirates and their fans could be wishing for as the calendar turns to 2021.
Infield clarity
As it stands, the Pirates have Cole Tucker, Erik Gonzalez and Kevin Newman set to battle for starting shortstop duties come spring training. If Newman doesn’t win that spot, he can play second, but Adam Frazier would also likely be a factor there.
At first base, Colin Moran and Josh Bell will have to split reps as it stands, especially since it seems that the National League may not have a designated hitter this season.
None of that is to mention that shortstop prospect Oneil Cruz will likely be knocking on the big-league door at some point during the next year, further muddying the infield picture.
It stands to reason that the Pirates could benefit from an offseason trade in the next couple of months, bringing back a prospect or two, to open up some space somewhere in the infield. Frazier, for instance, always seems to have trade rumors floating around him. Bell’s name came up earlier this offseason, too.
Read More
The Pirates shouldn’t be overly eager to get rid of any of these players more than another, necessarily, but it’s hard to see the benefit of truly splitting reps in the infield between players who could use development.
Healthy Jameson Taillon
Those aforementioned Bell trade rumors also included right-hander Jameson Taillon, with the New York Yankees reportedly on the other side of the deal.
At this point, that deal hasn’t materialized, so we will proceed under the assumption that Taillon is still in Pittsburgh for 2021.
Whenever he does pitch, it will be the first time he’s done so since May 1, 2019. It was after that he had his second Tommy John surgery and was forced out of action for the next season and a half.
What’s tantalizing about Taillon is that his last full year was 2018, and he was a true ace with a 3.20 ERA over 32 starts, leading the Pirates with 179 strikeouts along the way.
Perhaps it’s too optimistic to expect Taillon to return to that form, but if he can be anything close to that, the 29-year-old can help lock down the Pirates’ rotation alongside Joe Musgrove, Mitch Keller and Steven Brault.
At the very least, a healthy Taillon will be a sight for sore eyes given all he has fought through to get to this point.
Ke’Bryan Hayes hardware
Despite playing just 24 games in 2020, third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes had a fairly reasonable argument for NL Rookie of the Year.
He hit .376 with five homers, two triples and seven doubles, leading the team with a 202 OPS+, and he ultimately finished sixth in rookie of the year voting.
However, thanks to service rules, it seems likely that Hayes will once again be eligible for the award in 2020. If that’s the case, the Pirates should hope he does enough to win it this time.
If nothing else, that would mean a larger sample size of strong production from Hayes — and further proof that he can be the third baseman for years and years to come.
Bounceback seasons abound
Perhaps the most disappointing part of the Pirates’ 2020 season was the stark drop-off in production from previously promising players.
Bell had 37 home runs in 2019. Reynolds and Newman each hit above .300. Even Frazier was at .278.
Of those four players, Frazier had the highest batting average in 2020 with a lackluster .230. Suffice to say, that isn’t very good.
Part of the problem with the jumble of players who could get time on the Pirates’ infield and elsewhere is that it isn’t imminently clear which players should get time. It would help that problem if a few of the players who struggled mightily in 2020 can establish themselves as deserving pieces of the future.
Something worth spending for
The common complaint about the Pirates surrounds their perceived unwillingness to spend big on their team.
Last season, they had by far the lowest payroll in Major League Baseball. The thought would be that the payroll will start to rise when the Pirates have a nucleus of young players that is worth spending on.
After 2019, one would have thought that was close. After 2020, it seems further away. But if you go around the diamond and this checklist is ticked off — if Taillon can solidify the starters, Bell, Reynolds and Newman can bounce back, and Hayes takes another step — now you have a good base to build from.
Then it’s in ownership’s hands. Then they can start to spend to sign those players or bring in free agents to supplement them.
Perhaps this is something that won’t materialize until after the 2021 season is finished, but the pieces can begin to fall into place in 2020 if things go well.
Really, that is what this list is about. After a pitiful 2020, the Pirates need progress. They need something good to start to break their way.
Is that too much to ask for on Christmas?
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.